Table 4.
Trial | Pretesting methods | Changes in the intervention implemented as a result of the pretesting exercise |
TEXT MEa [9,19,32] | n=16; sampling: convenient; additional details: The aim of the pilot testing was to evaluate the messages and the system to deliver them. Participants received the relevant messages for 1 week. At the conclusion of the pilot study, participants received a questionnaire asking for the potential impact of the messages to change behavior, the process of receiving messages (eg, timing, personalization, and frequency), and for any further feedback | Refinement of the message bank and software system |
Text4Heartb [21,29] | n=20; sampling: convenient; additional details: The aim of the pilot testing was to test the healthy eating messages. Participants received 1 text message per day (28 in total) and had access to the supporting website; 4 weeks later, participants were contacted by text and email to complete a follow-up Web-based survey. Website usage statistics including the frequency, login period, and page views were also tracked | No changes made to healthy eating message content or tone (viewed as acceptable), self-efficacy included as underlying theoretical construct; higher level of tailoring (messages personalized with name, time of day to receive messages, and primary behavior targeted), website log-on system simplified |
Islam [22,33] | n=30; sampling: purposive; additional details: intervention pretested in patients with type 2 diabetes selected from a diabetes clinic of a tertiary hospital | Timing of text messages was set to be delivered from 10 am to 5 pm |
Heartc [24-26,30] | n=10; sampling: convenience; additional details: Pilot testing of the intervention was integrated into the full randomized controlled trial (during the study, the first 10 study participants were closely monitored for 6 weeks to ensure that they received the messages and to resolve technical issues) | All SMSd messages were made available on a website for participants to review retrospectively if they chose and correction of grammatical errors identified by participants |
StARe [8,18] | n=19; sampling: purposive; additional details: The full intervention package was tested in the 3 languages most commonly used in Cape Town (English, Afrikaans, and isiXhosa). Participants were contacted on a weekly basis by a researcher for a semi-structured interview on their experience of the intervention and the SMS text message delivery system | Change timing of the message and allowing users to change language |
aTEXT ME: Tobacco, Exercise and Diet Messages.
bText4Heart: Text message and Internet-based comprehensive cardiac rehabilitation intervention.
cHeart: Heart Exercise And Remote Technologies.
dSMS: short message service.
eStAR: Mobile Phone Text Messages to Support Treatment Adherence in Adults With High Blood Pressure.