Table 5.
Summary of findings for studies on Urological procedures (n=4)
| Citation | Study Purpose | Study Design | Setting | Participants | Treatment Decision | Key Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hsieh, 2010 | To understand how parents, elect to manage vesicoureteral reflux. | Cross-sectional study | Texas Children’s Hospital urology offices | 64 children; 70% White, 27% Hispanic, 3% other. | Open vs endoscopic repair of vesicoureteral reflux | • Hispanics accounted for 55.6% of open procedures and only 21.1% of endoscopic repair. • Hispanics rated stopping ultrasound and finances as more important considerations than whites (p <0.05) |
| Bisono, 2012 | To understand decision-making regarding neonatal circumcision | Qualitative study with in-depth interviews | Outpatient urology clinics in New-York Presbyterian Hospital | 129 Hispanic parents.* | Circumcision | • 67% had not circumcised their child. • Culture (χ2 =5.03, p<.0001), familial traditions (χ2 =6.1,p =.014), and believing circumcision to not be too risky, (χ2 = 20.5, p < .0001) influenced the decision to circumcise. |
| Binner, 2002 | To investigate the impact brochures on the parental decision about circumcision. | Cross-sectional study | Memorial-Hermann Hospital and the Woman’s Hospital of Texas in Houston, TX. | 190 women; 39% Black,27% White,26% Hispanic, 4% Asian, 4% other. | Circumcision | • Race/ethnicity was not associated with the decision to circumcise. |
| Ahaghotu, 2009 | To examine factors that drive Black parents to favor circumcision | Descriptive study | Outpatient urology clinics in Washington, D.C. | 146 parents; 95% Black, 5% other. | Circumcision | • 96% believed circumcision to be healthy. • 41% indicated health reasons as the most important factor for choosing circumcision. • 25% selected maternal preference as the main factor. • The mother was 12 times more likely than the father to make the final decision. • 72% believed that it is a necessary procedure. |
study included 10 non-Hispanic parents but data for race not included