Skip to main content
. 2016 Oct 17;2016(10):CD009612. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009612.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Ackerhans 1994 Participants had acute rhinitis
Anderson 1956 Not a RCT
Anonymous 1975 Not a RCT
Ashe 1968 Participants had nasal obstruction due to various reasons including allergy
Bailey 1969 Participants had nasal obstruction due to various reasons including allergy
Bende 1984 Participants had nasal obstruction, not due to common cold
Bende 1985 Nasal stuffiness was the only inclusion criterion, hence it is not clear for how long participants experienced nasal congestion and whether this was due to the common cold
Broms 1982 Participants suffered from nasal obstruction for more than 6 months
Castellano 2002 Participants had reduced airflow, which was not necessarily due to the common cold
Cohen 1977 Combination therapy
Connell 1969 Some of the patients had allergic rhinitis
De Paula Neves 1966 Combination therapy
Dorn 2003 Trial was not placebo‐controlled
Fox 1967 Trial was not placebo‐controlled
Hummel 1998 None of pre‐specified outcome measures were reported
Katrana 1956 Not a RCT
McElhenney 1966 Not a RCT
Meurman 1975 Trial was not placebo‐controlled
Pritchard 2014 Participants with hay fever were also included
Rumiantsev 1993 Combination therapy
Smith 1999 Not an RCT
Tzachev 2002 Participants had allergic rhinitis
Weisberg 1966 Combination therapy
Winther 1983 Nasal airway resistance was not measured; the weight of nasal discharge was measured
Zumpft 1975 Participants had allergic rhinitis

RCT: Randomised controlled trial