Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 15;2019(4):CD010412. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010412.pub2
Finding #2
Doctors in most studies also preferred that nurses performed only non‐medical tasks.
Assessment for each CERQual component
Methodological limitations Minor concerns because 3 studies did not report reflexivity; 2 studies did not report ethical consideration; and 2 studies did not report sampling strategy.
Coherence Moderate concerns because all studies welcomed the transfer of certain tasks to nurses, but only in 1 study doctors were not willing to shift tasks such as examination, diagnosis or therapy to nurses. Moreover, in LMICs, attitude among doctors was reported to be more mixed.
Relevance Minor concerns because most data were from HICs and there were 2 studies from LMICs.
Adequacy No or very minor concerns.
Overall CERQual assessment
Moderate confidence Due to minor concerns about methodological limitations and relevance; and moderate concerns about coherence.
Contributing studies/setting
Sub‐Saharan Africa (1); Asia (1); Oceania (3); Europe (7); North America (4)
Abbott 2013: Australia, general practices
Bailey 2006: Canada, primary care
Branson 2008: UK, primary care
Coulter 2000: USA, managed care organisation‐multispeciality group practices
Georgeu 2012: South Africa, PHC clinic
Ivers 2011: Haiti, rural communities
Kraus 2017: USA, primary care
Lindblad 2010: Sweden, primary health care
Lorch 2015: Australia, chlamydia testing
Marsden 2004: UK, practices
Rosemann 2006: Germany, clinic
Ross 2015: UK, mental health
Stenner 2010: UK, primary care
Stephen 2018: Australia, general practice
Twinn 1999: Hong Kong, primary care‐teaching clinics
Voogdt‐Pruis 2011: Netherlands, cardiovascular prevention