Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 15;2019(4):CD010412. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010412.pub2
Finding #7
Health professionals, including doctors, nurses, policymakers and other healthcare providers, believed that doctor‐nurse substitution led to improvements in the quality of care.
Assessment for each CERQual component
Methodological limitations Minor concerns because 1 study did not report reflexivity, ethical considerations and data analysis; 1 study did not report sampling strategies; 2 other studies did not report reflexivity.
Coherence Minor concerns because in 1 study based in LMICs (Malawi, Uganda and Zimbabwe), nurses perceived that delivering new services had increased their workload that might hinder the provision of the quality of service.
Relevance No or very minor concerns. In 9 studies, participants were nurses; in 9 studies, they were doctors; in 5 studies, they were other healthcare providers and in 4 studies, they were policymakers/managers.
Adequacy No or very minor concerns, although data were relatively few, many studies from several regions reported this finding.
Overall CERQual assessment
Moderate confidence Due to minor concerns about methodological limitations and coherence.
Contributing studies/setting
Sub‐Saharan Africa (2); Oceania (4); Europe ( 5); North America (3)
Abbott 2013: Australia, general practices
Boyle 2016: Australia, general practice
Carryer 2017: New Zealand, primary care
Coulter 2000: USA, managed care organisation‐multispeciality group practices
Dierick‐van Daele 2010a: Netherland, general practice
Kaasalainen 2013: Canada, long‐term care homes (primary care)
Leipert 2011; Canada, primary care
Ljungbeck 2017: Sweden, municipal healthcare
Lorch 2015: Australia, chlamydia testing
Marsden 2004: UK, practices
Nkhata 2016: Malawi, Uganda and Zimbabwe, ART
Perry 2005: UK, personal medical services
Rustagi 2015a: Mozambique, N/A
Stenner 2010: UK, primary care