Table 1.
Study/country | N | Inclusion criteria | Treatment/study duration | Co-interventions permitted | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Oshima et al31/Japan | 206 | Symptomatic and radiographic evidence of knee OA; age ⩾18 years | 4-8 wk/4-8 wk | Prior anti-inflammatory or analgesic medication or physical therapy | Pain while at rest, walking, going up/down stairs pain, during flexion/extension; oppressive pain (tenderness); swelling; patellar ballottement; synovial effusion; ROM; impairment in ADLs; patient- and clinician-rated global improvement |
Shichikawa et al32/Japan | 107 | Radiographic knee OA with pain on movement; age ⩾18 years | 5 wk/5 wk | Prior physical therapy | Pain while at rest, walking, going up/down stairs pain, during flexion/extension; oppressive pain (tenderness); swelling; patellar ballottement; synovial effusion; ROM; impairment in ADLs; patient- and clinician-rated global improvement |
Shichikawa et al33/Japan | 228 | Radiographic knee OA with pain on exercise; age ⩾18 years | 5 wk/5 wk | Prior anti-inflammatory medication or physical therapy | Pain while at rest, walking, going up/down stairs pain, duringflexion/extension; oppressive pain (tenderness); swelling; patellar ballottement; synovial effusion; ROM; impairment in ADLs; patient- and clinician-rated global improvement |
Puhl et al34/Germany | 209 | Radiographic knee OA; age 40-75 years | 5 wk/14 wk | Paracetamol rescue | Primary: Lequesne, paracetamol use Secondary: VAS, investigator/patient global assessment |
Lohmander et al35/Sweden | 240 | Radiographic OA; VAS ⩾10 mm; age 40-75 years; Lequesne score ⩾4 at baseline | 5 wk/20 wk | Paracetamol rescue | Primary: Lequesne, VAS ratings for knee function, pain, ROM, and activity level Secondary: paracetamol use, investigator/patient global assessment |
Day et al36/Australia | 203 | Mild/moderate early OA; pain on walking; age 40-75 years | 5 wk/18 wk | Paracetamol rescue | Primary: WOMAC pain, stiffness, and disability Secondary: Lequesne, paracetamol use, investigator and patient global assessment |
United Kingdom (unpublished)37 | 231 | Radiographic OA; moderate pain >3 months | 5 wk/25 wk | Co-proxomol as rescue | Primary: VAS pain Secondary: Lequesne, paracetamol use, investigator/patient global assessment |
France (unpublished)37 | 254 | Radiographic OA; VAS global pain ⩾35 mm | 5 wk/13 wk 3 wk/13 wk |
Paracetamol as rescue | Primary: Lequesne Secondary: VAS pain, paracetamol use, investigator global assessment |
Abbreviations: ADL, activities of daily living; OA, osteoarthritis; ROM, range of motion; VAS, visual analog scale; WOMAC, Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index.