Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 26;11(1 Suppl):4–18. doi: 10.1177/1758573218768099

Table 1.

Overview of human studies evaluating therapy protocols of rotator cuff repair.

Study Study type Sample size Follow-up Results and conclusions
Chang et al.38 Systematic review and meta-analysis n = 482 (six RCT) Baseline, three, and six months Early ROM exercise protocols accelerated recovery and postoperative stiffness, but likely result in improper tendon healing with large tears.
Sheps et al.46 RCT n = 189 Six weeks and three, six, 12, and 24 months The early motion group demonstrated increased abduction and scapular plane elevation (p = 0.002) at six weeks, but no difference afterward. No difference in clinical outcomes or ADLs for early mobilization or immobilized groups at 24 months.
Koh et al.42 RCT n = 100 Six and 24 months No difference in healing rate between four and eight months of immobilization after RCR for medium-sized rotator cuff tears.
Kim et al.16 Case series n = 221 Three and 12 months Retears are infrequent after three months if sufficient healing and integrity demonstrated by repair at three months.
Iannotti et al.53 Cohort study n = 113 Two, six, 12, 16, 26, 39, and 52 weeks Recurrent retear rate on MRI evaluation of RCR is 17% within one year. Retears primarily occur between six and 26 weeks.
Cuff and Pupello39 RCT n = 68 Nine and 12 months Slightly higher rotator cuff healing rate in delayed PROM versus early PROM, but similar outcomes at one year in both groups.
Lee et al.43 RCT n = 64 Three, six, and 12 months Increased risk of anatomic failure may occur with aggressive early passive rehabilitation versus limited early passive rehabilitation.
Kim et al.41 RCT n = 105 Three, six, and 12 months Early PROM exercise did not statistically improve early gains in ROM or alleviate pain, but did not negatively affect cuff healing.
Arndt et al.37 Randomized prospective study n = 100 Three, six, 12, and final follow-up Early passive motion demonstrated improved functional results with no significant difference in healing.
Duzgun et al.40 RCT n = 29 One, three, five, eight, 12, 16, and 24 weeks Accelerated protocols were superior to slow protocol in functional activity level and pain during activity and at night.
Raab et al.45 RCT n = 26 Three months CPM had a beneficial effect on ROM and pain relief for female patients and patients ≥60 years old, but no effect on overall shoulder score at three months.

ADL: activities of daily living; CPM: continuous passive motion; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging; PROM: passive range of motion; RCR: rotator cuff repair; RCT: randomized control trial; ROM: range of motion.