Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 20;2016(12):CD009840. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009840.pub2
  Trial author contacted Trial author replied Trial author provided data Comments
Barton 2000 Yes Yes Yes Additional data not used
Beck 2002 Yes Yes Yes Additional data not used
Bourdel‐Marchasson 2000 Yes Yes Yes Not used, and unable to provide data requested on weight
Bouillanne 2013 Yes Yes Yes Data received on weight and energy intake
Brouillette 1991 No N/A N/A  
Castellanos 2009 Yes No N/A  
Chang 2005 Yes No N/A  
Dennis 2005 Yes Yes Yes Information used on complication rates
Duncan 2006 Yes Yes Yes Awaiting data on length of stay
Essed 2007 Yes No N/A  
Essed 2009 Yes No N/A  
Faxen‐Irving 2011 Yes Yes Yes Data on energy intake, length of stay, BMI and ADLs provided. No data available on infections
Gaskill 2009 Yes Yes No Assume unable to provide data
Germain 2006 Yes Yes Yes Data provided for BMI mean and SD of change
Hankey 1993 Yes No N/A  
Hickson 2004 Yes Yes Yes Author unable to provide this data on energy intake and hospital readmission as it was not measured, therefore not usable. Data provided on complications as requested
Holyday 2012 Yes Yes Yes Data obtained and used for hospital readmission rates
Johansen 2004 Yes No N/A Data not used
Kraft 2012 Yes No N/A  
Kretser 2003 No N/A N/A Unable to find contact for author
Larsson 1990 Yes No N/A Data not used
Lin 2010 Yes No N/A  
Lin 2011 No N/A N/A  
Mathey 2001a Yes No N/A  
Mathey 2001b Yes No N/A  
Nijs 2006 No N/A N/A  
Olofsson 2007 Yes Yes Yes Data used for BMI, weight and complications
Pivi 2011 Yes No N/A  
Potter 2001 Yes No N/A  
Remsburg 2001 No N/A N/A  
Salva 2011 Yes No N/A  
Silver 2008 No N/A N/A  
Simmons 2008 Yes Yes No Data not available
Simmons 2010 Yes Yes No Data not available
Smolliner 2008 Yes Yes Yes Data provided for mean and SD of change for weight, BMI, handgrip, and QoL
Splett 2003 Yes No N/A  
Taylor 2006 No N/A N/A  
Van Ort 1995 Yes No N/A  
Leslie 2012 No N/A N/A  
Munk 2014 No N/A N/A  
V an den Berg 2015 Yes Yes Yes The clinical trial register number did not allow the trial to be identified within the register. The authors provided a link to the trial protocol via the WHO International Clinical Trials Registry Platform.
ADL: activities of daily living; BMI: body mass index; N/A: not applicable; QoL: (health‐related) quality of life; SD: standard deviation: WHO World Health Organisation