Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 19;2016(12):CD005074. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005074.pub4

2. Action plan (AP) intervention and comparison used in included studies.

  Individualised AP Standard written AP Support for AP during study period SME (individual/group) Prescription /supply OCS Prescription /supply ABS Written COPD educational component Comparison
Martin 2004 Written   3‐Monthly visit regarding use of AP Individual interview with respiratory nurse, length not stated, individualised action plan according to current treatment and symptoms All had 7‐day supply All had 7‐day supply No Usual care by own GP
McGeoch 2004   Yes No Individual session by practice nurse or respiratory educator in association with GP 1 hour, covering major points of COPD self‐management plan, and use of validated sputum colour charts Prescription Prescription Educational package Non‐standard education on COPD according to practice standards
Rice 2010 Written   Monthly phone call from nurse Group 1‐1.5 hours, individualised action plan with respiratory nurse Yes Prescription   Usual care + 1‐page summary of principles of COPD care according to published guidelines. No AP
Rootmensen 2008 Oral   No Individual protocol‐based educational session covering disease, medications, vaccination, smoking cessation and exacerbation management, 45 minutes in length Oral medication provided to some, % unknown Oral medication provided to some, % unknown No Usual care
Trappenburg 2011 Written   Standardised phone calls at 1 and 4 months Individualised action plan education, length of session not stated 2%' 22% ✓ COPD information Usual care ‐ pharmacological and non‐pharmacological care according to most recent evidence‐based guidelines, specifically AP denied. All included participants seen by respiratory nurse, who systematically checked and discussed aspects of COPD care, including vaccination, optimisation of medication, inhalation techniques, exercise, nutritional aspects, smoking (cessation) and exacerbation management.
Watson 1997   Yes No Individual session education about use of the action plan with COPD booklet by a senior respiratory outreach nurse; length not stated Prescription Prescription ✓ Guide to living positively with COPD Usual care by GP, specifically denied access to AP and booklet
Wood‐Baker 2006 Written   No Individual educational session with respiratory nurse, covering COPD, smoking cessation, immunisation, nutrition, exercise, sputum clearance, breathing, medication, inhaler use. Individualised action plan developed with GP input. Length not known 2% 22% COPD information booklet Usual care, COPD information booklet and individual educational session with nurse, but no AP

ABS: antibiotics; AP: action plan; COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; GP: general practitioner; OCS: oral corticosteroids; SME: self‐management education.