Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 19;2016(12):CD005074. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005074.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Apps 2008 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Benzo 2013 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Bischoff 2011 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Bischoff 2013 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Bosch 2007 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Botvinikova 2010 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Bourbeau 2003 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention, and educational intervention was too long (weekly visits over a 2‐month period).
Bucknall 2012 Educational intervention was too long (4× 40‐minute individual training sessions).
Cave 2010 Intervention did not involve an action plan.
Chavannes 2009 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Choi 2014 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Chuang 2011 Educational intervention was too long (4 weekly telephone sessions 20 minutes each).
Coultas 2012 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Davies 2014 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Dhein 2003 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Effing 2009 Control group was not given usual care. Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Efraimsson 2008 Educational intervention was too long (2× 1 hour sessions).
Fan 2012 Educational intervention was too long (4 weekly 90‐minute individual sessions).
Hesselink 2004 Study participants included those with a diagnosis of asthma or COPD. Intervention did not include an action plan.
Jarab 2012 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Khdour 2009 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Kiser 2012 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Lawlor 2007 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Lenferink 2013 Educational intervention was too long (4× 2.5‐hour sessions).
Maltais 2008 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. Control group was not given usual care.
Miller 2010 Educational intervention was too long (4× 40‐minute individual sessions).
Monninkhof 2003 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Newman 1995 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Parenteau 2003 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT).
Rea 2004 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Roberts 2007 This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). This was a pilot study of the acceptability of a pictorial action plan.
Rowett 2005 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Sedeno 2006 Educational intervention was too long (8 sessions exceeding 1 hour).
Sedeno 2009 Citation to study was already excluded; educational sessions exceeded 1 hour.
Siddique 2012 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Song 2014 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Sridhar 2008 Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention.
Uijen 2012 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Wakabayashi 2006 Intervention did not include an action plan.
Wittmann 2007 Control group was not given usual care. Educational intervention was too long (4× 1.5‐hour sessions).
Worth 2004 It was not possible to extract outcome data regarding action plan (AP) only.
Yu 2014 Intervention did not include an action plan.