Apps 2008 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Benzo 2013 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Bischoff 2011 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Bischoff 2013 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Bosch 2007 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Botvinikova 2010 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Bourbeau 2003 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention, and educational intervention was too long (weekly visits over a 2‐month period). |
Bucknall 2012 |
Educational intervention was too long (4× 40‐minute individual training sessions). |
Cave 2010 |
Intervention did not involve an action plan. |
Chavannes 2009 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Choi 2014 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Chuang 2011 |
Educational intervention was too long (4 weekly telephone sessions 20 minutes each). |
Coultas 2012 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Davies 2014 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Dhein 2003 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Effing 2009 |
Control group was not given usual care. Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Efraimsson 2008 |
Educational intervention was too long (2× 1 hour sessions). |
Fan 2012 |
Educational intervention was too long (4 weekly 90‐minute individual sessions). |
Hesselink 2004 |
Study participants included those with a diagnosis of asthma or COPD. Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Jarab 2012 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Khdour 2009 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Kiser 2012 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Lawlor 2007 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Lenferink 2013 |
Educational intervention was too long (4× 2.5‐hour sessions). |
Maltais 2008 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. Control group was not given usual care. |
Miller 2010 |
Educational intervention was too long (4× 40‐minute individual sessions). |
Monninkhof 2003 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Newman 1995 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Parenteau 2003 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). |
Rea 2004 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Roberts 2007 |
This was not a randomised controlled trial (RCT). This was a pilot study of the acceptability of a pictorial action plan. |
Rowett 2005 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Sedeno 2006 |
Educational intervention was too long (8 sessions exceeding 1 hour). |
Sedeno 2009 |
Citation to study was already excluded; educational sessions exceeded 1 hour. |
Siddique 2012 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Song 2014 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Sridhar 2008 |
Action plan was part of a broader self‐management intervention. |
Uijen 2012 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Wakabayashi 2006 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |
Wittmann 2007 |
Control group was not given usual care. Educational intervention was too long (4× 1.5‐hour sessions). |
Worth 2004 |
It was not possible to extract outcome data regarding action plan (AP) only. |
Yu 2014 |
Intervention did not include an action plan. |