Skip to main content
. 2016 Dec 1;2016(12):CD002007. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002007.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Adeboyeku 2011 Comparison of twice daily vs three times daily antibiotics, not single vs combination.
Al‐Ansari 2006 Comparison of once vs multiple daily dosing, not single vs combination.
Aminimanizani 2002 Comparison of single vs multiple daily dosing, not single vs combination.
Balsamo 1986 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Beaudry 1980 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Beringer 2012 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics; a comparison of a single intravenous dose of an antibiotic and multiple oral doses of the same antibiotic.
Blumer 2005 Comparison of two combination regimens.
Bosso 1988 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Church 1997 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Conway 1997 Comparison of colistin with multiple antibiotic combinations.
De Boeck 1989 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
De Boeck 1999 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Donati 1987 Home vs hospital therapy, not single vs combination.
Gold 1985 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Hatziagorou 2013 Not a comparison of a single vs combination antibiotics; evaluation of tool to assess treatment response in children.
Hoogkamp 1983 Non‐randomised study: first 7 participants allocated to single treatment; next 7 to combination treatment with marked differences in baseline characteristics.
Hubert 2009 Comparison of intermittent vs continuous infusions, not single vs combination.
Hyatt 1981 Comparison of anti‐staphylococcal drug (oxacillin) vs oxacillin plus 2 anti‐pseudomonal drugs.
Jewett 1985 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Keel 2011 Not a comparison of a single vs combination antibiotic; comparison of intravenous and oral versions of the same agent.
Kenny 2009 Study of eradication of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, not a comparison of single vs combination.
Krause 1979 Pseudo‐randomised study. Treatment and comparison groups were not sufficiently similar at baseline.
Kuni 1992 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics.
Levy 1982 Comparison of 2 single agents.
McCabe 2013 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics; evaluation of a twice‐daily tobramycin regimen.
Nelson 1985 Review article on single vs combination antibiotic treatment, i.e. not an RCT.
Noah 2010 Inhaled vs systemic antibiotics.
Padoan 1987 Reported number of courses of treatment instead of number of people included. Some participants may have been counted twice or included in both treatment group therefore analysis unclear.
Permin 1983 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Prayle 2013 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics; comparison of morning vs evening intravenous tobramycin.
Riethmueller 2009 Continuous vs intermittent infusions.
Roberts 1993 Randomisation method unclear ‐ participants appeared to have been randomised to single or combination therapy each morning using a cross‐over method.
Semykin 2010 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics; trial of inhaled tobramycin therapy.
Stack 1985 Comparison of single agent compared with two other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Turner 2013 Not a comparison of single vs combination antibiotics; study of continuous vs intermittent infusion piperacillin‐tazobactam.
Wesley 1988 Comparison of single agent compared with 2 other antibiotics (i.e. drug A vs drug B plus drug C).
Whitehead 2002 Efficacy of once daily tobramycin, not a comparison of single vs combination agents.

CXR: chest X‐ray
 vs: versus