Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 31;2017(3):CD011639. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011639.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abdelmalek 2012 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Barnes 1997 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Beckebaum 2004 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Becker 2008 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Benitez 2010 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Berenguer 2006 Randomisation was performed at least 1 year after liver transplantation.
Biancofiore 2004 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Bilbao 2009 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Bogetti 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Boillot 2000 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Boillot 2001 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Boillot 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Boillot 2009 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Boleslawski 2004 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Calmus 2010 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Chen 2005 Comparison of different regimens of same drug
Cicinnati 2007 Randomisation was performed at least 1 year after liver transplantation.
Cillo 2014 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Cosimi 1987 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Cosimi 1990 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Cuervas‐Mons 2015 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Day 2004 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
De Simone 2009 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
De Simone 2015 Comparison of different regimens of same drug
Duvoux 2015 Randomisation was performed from 6 months to 10 years.
Eason 2003 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Ericzon 1997 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Farges 1994 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Filipponi 2004 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Firpi 2006 Not a randomised clinical trial
Firpi 2010 Randomisation was performed only after recurrence of hepatitis C infection.
Fischer 2012 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Fleckenstein 1996 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Garcia Gonzalez 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Garcia‐Saenz‐de‐Sicilia 2014 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Geissler 2016 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Gerhardt 2009 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Gonzalez‐Pinto 2005 Although this is a long‐term report of an included study (Loinaz 2001), after the randomisation period was complete, immunosuppression was left to local centre's protocol.
Grant 2012 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Hardinger 2004 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Herlenius 2010 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Hodge 2002 Randomisation was performed between 3 months and 27 months after liver transplantation.
Hytiroglou 1993 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Junge 2005 Randomisation was performed at least 1 year after liver transplantation.
Kato 2007 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Keiding 1997 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Klintmalm 1994 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group. or both
Klintmalm 2007 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Klintmalm 2014 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Klupp 1998 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Langrehr 1997 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Langrehr 1998a Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Langrehr 1998b Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Langrehr 2001 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Langrehr 2002 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Lerut 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Lerut 2008 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Levy 2004 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Levy 2006 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Levy 2014 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Llado 2006 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Llado 2014 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Lu 2006a Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Lupo 2008 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Margarit 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
McDiarmid 1991 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
McDiarmid 1991a Not on maintenance immunosuppression
McDiarmid 1993 Includes paediatric population undergoing liver transplants
Moench 2007 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Mor 1994 Includes paediatric population undergoing liver transplants
Nashan 1996 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Neuberger 2009 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Neuhaus 1993 Not a randomised clinical trial
Neuhaus 1994 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Neuhaus 1997 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Neuhaus 2000 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Neuhaus 2002 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Neumann 2012 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Nevens 2007 Randomisation was performed after development of renal impairment.
Northup 2006 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Otero 2009 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Pageaux 1995 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Pageaux 2006 Randomisation was performed after development of renal impairment.
Pascher 2015 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Ramirez 2013 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Reding 1993 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Reggiani 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Reich 2005 Randomisation was performed after development of renal impairment.
Saliba 2016 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Saliba 2016a Comparison of different regimens of same drug
Salizzoni 2001 Not clear whether the immunosuppressive regimens were continued beyond the induction phase
Schiano 2006 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Schmeding 2007 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Schmeding 2011 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Shaked 2016 Randomisation was performed at an average of 17 months after liver transplantation.
Shenoy 2007 Randomisation was performed at least 6 months after transplantation only in people with renal dysfunction.
Simone 2008 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Studenik 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Takada 2013 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Teperman 2013 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Therapondos 2002 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Timmermann 2002 Details of maintenance immunosuppression not available.
Tisone 1998 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Trunečka 2015 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Villamil 2014 Randomisation was performed at least 6 months after liver transplantation.
Washburn 2001 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Washburn 2008 Not on maintenance immunosuppression
Watson 2007 Randomisation was performed after development of renal impairment.
Wiesner 2001 No fixed immunosuppression regimen in either intervention group or control group, or both
Yoshida 2005 Not on maintenance immunosuppression