Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 17;2017(2):CD011683. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011683.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abroms 2014 Individually tailored text messages. No specific targeting to ethnic minorities
Aghi 1984 Individual counselling available as part of the intervention. Not targeted to ethnic minority
Albright 2009 Not considered a mass media intervention
Albright 2012 Not considered a mass media intervention
Alcalay 1999 Before‐after assessment without control group
Bermejo 2012 Participants attended a group event before receiving the mass media component
Block 2004 Individually tailored content. Unclear targeting to ethnic minority
Brady 2010 Campaign targeted to a patient group
Bramley 2005 Individually tailored text messages based on initial counselling
Brimblecombe 2013 Protocol for a multi‐component store intervention. No relevant outcome measures
Brown 2012 Not considered a mass media intervention
Buis 2013 Retrospective analyses
Buller 2008 Intervention not clearly targeted to ethnic minorities
Burger 2003 Intervention focused on risk communication rather than disease prevention. Study not designed to show effect of a targeted approach
Burns 2010 Assessment of quit line calls from Latino compared to non‐Latino population before and after Spanish‐language campaign
Campbell 2004 Individually tailored newsletters
Campbell 2014 Repeated cross‐sectional surveys. No control group
Cantrell 2013 Experimental study of pictorial versus text‐only tobacco warning labels in different ethnic groups
Carlini 2008 Personal invitation letters to re‐enrol into counselling. Not considered a mass media intervention
Cessnun 2011 The target population is adolescents, secondarily their parents. Not considered a mass media intervention
Chang 2010 Not considered a mass media intervention
Chang 2014 As Chang 2010
Chhichhia 2011 Not considered a mass media intervention
Chung 2014 Before‐after assessment without control group
Collins 2014 Individually tailored text messages
Cummins 2015 Report on implementation and impact of tobacco quit line counselling services
Darity 1997 Results presented as repeated cross‐sectional surveys. Not relevant study design as analysed
Dedier 2014 Individually tailored automatic telephone coach
Dunton 2008 Individually tailored intervention components
Emmons 2003 Individually tailored intervention components. Not targeted to ethnic minorities
Ferguson 2015 Not any of the specified study designs
Fitzgerald 2009 No impact assessment reported
Foster 2014 Multicomponent store intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. No clear targeting to ethnic minorities
Froelicher 2010 Not considered a mass media intervention
Fukuoka 2011 Individually tailored intervention components
Gans 2016 Multicomponent community intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. No clear targeting to ethnic minorities
Gerber 2009 Not considered a mass media intervention
Gerber 2013 Not considered a mass media intervention
Gittelsohn 2012 Multicomponent store intervention. Mass media components only minor part of complex intervention
Gittelsohn 2013 As Gittelsohn 2012
Glover 2013 Protocol. Not considered a mass media intervention. Before‐after assessment without control group
Graham 2012 Description of programme development and click‐through rates for different online advertisements
Gray 2012 Protocol. Not considered a mass media intervention
Grigg 2008 Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 2 after
Hammerback 2012 Not considered a mass media intervention. Before‐after assessment without control group
Hanson 2012 Description of programme development and user's opinion of campaign
Henderson 2012 Individually tailored content. Patient education
Hind 2010 Protocol. Study does not evaluate the effect of the mass media component
Ho 2008 Community intervention with many intervention activities involving several institutions. Mass media component smaller part of complex intervention compared to no intervention
Houry 2010 Written information targeted to problem behaviours or life situations, not to ethnic minority characteristics
Huang 2015 Intervention not targeted to ethnic minorities. Not any of the specified study designs
Irvine 2004 Individually tailored, interactive multimedia programme. Unclear targeting to ethnic minorities
Ivers 2006 Content of intervention not identical in the 3 intervention sites
Jantz 2002 Interactive education programme
Jason 1988 The whole population exposed to the mass media component (not described as targeted). Study designed to evaluate the effect of extended community outreach to ethnic minority group
Jenkins 1997 Controlled before‐after study with only 1 intervention site and 1 control site
Joseph 2014 Individually tailored content through interaction and contact with project staff. Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities
Joseph 2015 Before‐after assessment with no control group
Kandula 2014 Not considered a mass media intervention
Kim 2013 Text messages sent with a possibility to reply and receive answers
Kreuter 2004 Individually tailored women's magazines based on baseline questionnaire
Kreuter 2005 Individually tailored women's magazines based on baseline questionnaire
LaChausse 2012 Intervention not targeted to ethnic minorities. Individual feedback
Larsen 2014 Individually tailored content and counselling. Before‐after without control group
Larson 2009 Community intervention study with many intervention activities on different levels. Time series data with 5 measurement points and gradual implementation of the intervention
Lee 2011 Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities
Li 1984 Non‐randomised controlled trial with 4 arms. 1 site each for 2 of the arms. Alternating 2 interventions every other week in a third site
Linares 2013 Before‐after assessment without control group
Lipkus 1999 Not considered a mass media intervention
Ma 2004 Description of programme and campaigns. No impact assessment
Mackey 2015 Individually tailored content and counselling. Adapted to characteristics of college life, not ethnicity
Magoc 2009 Individually tailored, interactive computer programme
Marin 1990 Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 2 after
Marin 1994 Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 1 after
McAlister 1992 Non‐randomised controlled trial with 2 intervention sites and 1 control site
McDonnell 2011 Study of a culturally adapted self‐help smoking cessation programme delivered either as an interactive web‐programme or as booklets
Mead 2013 Community intervention with many intervention activities involving several institutions. Mass media component smaller part of complex intervention compared to no intervention
Mhurchu 2007 Pilot study. Description of recruitment and data collection methods
Mhurchu 2010 Nutrition education material tailored to individual shopping preferences in addition to cultural targeting
Migneault 2012 Individually tailored, interactive automatic telephone counselling. Can be considered as patient education
Moskowitz 2016 Not considered a mass media intervention
Muñoz 1997 Study of the effect of adding a mood management programme to a culturally adapted smoking cessation self‐help programme
Muñoz 2006 Describes 4 studies, including 2 RCTs. Smoking cessation programme with individual tailoring
Nollen 2007 Not considered a mass media intervention
Orleans 1998 Participants randomised to different formats of individual telephone counselling
Patten 2010 Not considered a mass media intervention
Patten 2012 Description of a research programme. No impact assessment data presented
Pekmezi 2010 Individually tailored feedback delivered via Internet or print
Perez 2009 Not considered a mass media intervention
Reininger 2015 Multicomponent community intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. Not any of the specified study designs
Resnicow 1997 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2000 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2001 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2002 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2005 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2008 Not considered a mass media intervention
Resnicow 2009 Individually tailored newsletters
Rimmer 2009 Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities
Romero 2012 Before‐after assessment without control group
Schlundt 2009 Community intervention study with many intervention activities on different levels. Time series data with 5 measurement points and gradual implementation of the intervention
Scisney‐Matlock 2012 Individually tailored, interactive computer programme with e‐mail feedback
Shaikh 2011 Not considered a mass media intervention
Shakeshaft 2014 Community intervention with many components and intervention activities, including social marketing campaigns. Whole population approach, including aboriginal communities. Not specific targeting to and impact assessment in ethnic minority groups.
Sharma 2010 Description of programme and activities. No impact assessment
Shea 1996 Description of programme and activities. No impact assessment
Skewes 2007 Not considered a mass media intervention
Steinberg 2013 Personal contact with research team through text‐messages and email
Stevens 2002 Before‐after assessment without control group
Streja 2014 The main aim of the study was to reduce secondhand smoke exposure among children with asthma
Swartz 2006 Individually tailored web‐based smoking cessation programme
Taylor 2010 Before‐after assessment without control group
Thomas 2010 Evaluation of intervention without control group
Vallone 2011 Before‐after assessment without control group
Webb 2010a Experimental study of health risk communication with different message content and culturally specific framing
Wetter 2007 Mass media used to create awareness of Spanish‐language smoking cessation services. Study of different formats of quit line counselling
Whitehead 2007 Individually tailored print material
Wilson 2005 Study compares the number of calls to quit line services after different campaigns, including 1 designed for Māori audience. Not relevant study design
Wilson 2010 Cluster‐randomised trial with 3 arms. Only 1 site per arm
Wilson 2014 Individually tailored, interactive computer programme. Feasibility study without control group
Withall 2012 Controlled before‐after study with only 1 intervention site and 1 control site. Not targeted to ethnic minority
Wolf 2009 Not considered a mass media intervention
Wright 2013 Individually tailored automated interactive voice response telephone counselling
Zhu 2012 Not considered a mass media intervention