Abroms 2014 |
Individually tailored text messages. No specific targeting to ethnic minorities |
Aghi 1984 |
Individual counselling available as part of the intervention. Not targeted to ethnic minority |
Albright 2009 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Albright 2012 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Alcalay 1999 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Bermejo 2012 |
Participants attended a group event before receiving the mass media component |
Block 2004 |
Individually tailored content. Unclear targeting to ethnic minority |
Brady 2010 |
Campaign targeted to a patient group |
Bramley 2005 |
Individually tailored text messages based on initial counselling |
Brimblecombe 2013 |
Protocol for a multi‐component store intervention. No relevant outcome measures |
Brown 2012 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Buis 2013 |
Retrospective analyses |
Buller 2008 |
Intervention not clearly targeted to ethnic minorities |
Burger 2003 |
Intervention focused on risk communication rather than disease prevention. Study not designed to show effect of a targeted approach |
Burns 2010 |
Assessment of quit line calls from Latino compared to non‐Latino population before and after Spanish‐language campaign |
Campbell 2004 |
Individually tailored newsletters |
Campbell 2014 |
Repeated cross‐sectional surveys. No control group |
Cantrell 2013 |
Experimental study of pictorial versus text‐only tobacco warning labels in different ethnic groups |
Carlini 2008 |
Personal invitation letters to re‐enrol into counselling. Not considered a mass media intervention |
Cessnun 2011 |
The target population is adolescents, secondarily their parents. Not considered a mass media intervention |
Chang 2010 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Chang 2014 |
As Chang 2010
|
Chhichhia 2011 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Chung 2014 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Collins 2014 |
Individually tailored text messages |
Cummins 2015 |
Report on implementation and impact of tobacco quit line counselling services |
Darity 1997 |
Results presented as repeated cross‐sectional surveys. Not relevant study design as analysed |
Dedier 2014 |
Individually tailored automatic telephone coach |
Dunton 2008 |
Individually tailored intervention components |
Emmons 2003 |
Individually tailored intervention components. Not targeted to ethnic minorities |
Ferguson 2015 |
Not any of the specified study designs |
Fitzgerald 2009 |
No impact assessment reported |
Foster 2014 |
Multicomponent store intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. No clear targeting to ethnic minorities |
Froelicher 2010 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Fukuoka 2011 |
Individually tailored intervention components |
Gans 2016 |
Multicomponent community intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. No clear targeting to ethnic minorities |
Gerber 2009 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Gerber 2013 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Gittelsohn 2012 |
Multicomponent store intervention. Mass media components only minor part of complex intervention |
Gittelsohn 2013 |
As Gittelsohn 2012
|
Glover 2013 |
Protocol. Not considered a mass media intervention. Before‐after assessment without control group |
Graham 2012 |
Description of programme development and click‐through rates for different online advertisements |
Gray 2012 |
Protocol. Not considered a mass media intervention |
Grigg 2008 |
Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 2 after |
Hammerback 2012 |
Not considered a mass media intervention. Before‐after assessment without control group |
Hanson 2012 |
Description of programme development and user's opinion of campaign |
Henderson 2012 |
Individually tailored content. Patient education |
Hind 2010 |
Protocol. Study does not evaluate the effect of the mass media component |
Ho 2008 |
Community intervention with many intervention activities involving several institutions. Mass media component smaller part of complex intervention compared to no intervention |
Houry 2010 |
Written information targeted to problem behaviours or life situations, not to ethnic minority characteristics |
Huang 2015 |
Intervention not targeted to ethnic minorities. Not any of the specified study designs |
Irvine 2004 |
Individually tailored, interactive multimedia programme. Unclear targeting to ethnic minorities |
Ivers 2006 |
Content of intervention not identical in the 3 intervention sites |
Jantz 2002 |
Interactive education programme |
Jason 1988 |
The whole population exposed to the mass media component (not described as targeted). Study designed to evaluate the effect of extended community outreach to ethnic minority group |
Jenkins 1997 |
Controlled before‐after study with only 1 intervention site and 1 control site |
Joseph 2014 |
Individually tailored content through interaction and contact with project staff. Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities |
Joseph 2015 |
Before‐after assessment with no control group |
Kandula 2014 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Kim 2013 |
Text messages sent with a possibility to reply and receive answers |
Kreuter 2004 |
Individually tailored women's magazines based on baseline questionnaire |
Kreuter 2005 |
Individually tailored women's magazines based on baseline questionnaire |
LaChausse 2012 |
Intervention not targeted to ethnic minorities. Individual feedback |
Larsen 2014 |
Individually tailored content and counselling. Before‐after without control group |
Larson 2009 |
Community intervention study with many intervention activities on different levels. Time series data with 5 measurement points and gradual implementation of the intervention |
Lee 2011 |
Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities |
Li 1984 |
Non‐randomised controlled trial with 4 arms. 1 site each for 2 of the arms. Alternating 2 interventions every other week in a third site |
Linares 2013 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Lipkus 1999 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Ma 2004 |
Description of programme and campaigns. No impact assessment |
Mackey 2015 |
Individually tailored content and counselling. Adapted to characteristics of college life, not ethnicity |
Magoc 2009 |
Individually tailored, interactive computer programme |
Marin 1990 |
Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 2 after |
Marin 1994 |
Interrupted time series study with 2 data points before the intervention and 1 after |
McAlister 1992 |
Non‐randomised controlled trial with 2 intervention sites and 1 control site |
McDonnell 2011 |
Study of a culturally adapted self‐help smoking cessation programme delivered either as an interactive web‐programme or as booklets |
Mead 2013 |
Community intervention with many intervention activities involving several institutions. Mass media component smaller part of complex intervention compared to no intervention |
Mhurchu 2007 |
Pilot study. Description of recruitment and data collection methods |
Mhurchu 2010 |
Nutrition education material tailored to individual shopping preferences in addition to cultural targeting |
Migneault 2012 |
Individually tailored, interactive automatic telephone counselling. Can be considered as patient education |
Moskowitz 2016 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Muñoz 1997 |
Study of the effect of adding a mood management programme to a culturally adapted smoking cessation self‐help programme |
Muñoz 2006 |
Describes 4 studies, including 2 RCTs. Smoking cessation programme with individual tailoring |
Nollen 2007 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Orleans 1998 |
Participants randomised to different formats of individual telephone counselling |
Patten 2010 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Patten 2012 |
Description of a research programme. No impact assessment data presented |
Pekmezi 2010 |
Individually tailored feedback delivered via Internet or print |
Perez 2009 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Reininger 2015 |
Multicomponent community intervention. Mass media components only minor part of intervention. Not any of the specified study designs |
Resnicow 1997 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2000 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2001 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2002 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2005 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2008 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Resnicow 2009 |
Individually tailored newsletters |
Rimmer 2009 |
Mass media component (in control group) not targeted to ethnic minorities |
Romero 2012 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Schlundt 2009 |
Community intervention study with many intervention activities on different levels. Time series data with 5 measurement points and gradual implementation of the intervention |
Scisney‐Matlock 2012 |
Individually tailored, interactive computer programme with e‐mail feedback |
Shaikh 2011 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Shakeshaft 2014 |
Community intervention with many components and intervention activities, including social marketing campaigns. Whole population approach, including aboriginal communities. Not specific targeting to and impact assessment in ethnic minority groups. |
Sharma 2010 |
Description of programme and activities. No impact assessment |
Shea 1996 |
Description of programme and activities. No impact assessment |
Skewes 2007 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Steinberg 2013 |
Personal contact with research team through text‐messages and email |
Stevens 2002 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Streja 2014 |
The main aim of the study was to reduce secondhand smoke exposure among children with asthma |
Swartz 2006 |
Individually tailored web‐based smoking cessation programme |
Taylor 2010 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Thomas 2010 |
Evaluation of intervention without control group |
Vallone 2011 |
Before‐after assessment without control group |
Webb 2010a |
Experimental study of health risk communication with different message content and culturally specific framing |
Wetter 2007 |
Mass media used to create awareness of Spanish‐language smoking cessation services. Study of different formats of quit line counselling |
Whitehead 2007 |
Individually tailored print material |
Wilson 2005 |
Study compares the number of calls to quit line services after different campaigns, including 1 designed for Māori audience. Not relevant study design |
Wilson 2010 |
Cluster‐randomised trial with 3 arms. Only 1 site per arm |
Wilson 2014 |
Individually tailored, interactive computer programme. Feasibility study without control group |
Withall 2012 |
Controlled before‐after study with only 1 intervention site and 1 control site. Not targeted to ethnic minority |
Wolf 2009 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |
Wright 2013 |
Individually tailored automated interactive voice response telephone counselling |
Zhu 2012 |
Not considered a mass media intervention |