Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 9;2017(2):CD003543. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003543.pub4

Bantar 2006.

Methods STUDY DESIGN: ITS
Risk of Bias: MEDIUM
Participants PROVIDERS: all physicians in the hospital
 PARTICIPANTS: all patients in the hospital
CLINICAL PROBLEM: IV antibiotics, restriction applied to carbapenems
SETTING: a single university hospital in Argentina. Total use was compared for > 2 years before and after the intervention
Interventions FORMAT, Intervention 1: educational outreach by review and recommend change; restrictive ‐ compulsory order form
Intervention Functions: education, enablement, persuasion, restriction
Intervention 2: unavailability of antibiotics during a national financial crisis
DELIVERER: AMT
COMPARISON: usual care
DESIRED CHANGE: decrease excessive (choice)
Outcomes PRESCRIBING: use of all IV antibiotics and carbapenems in DDD/1000 OBD
CLINICAL: all‐cause inpatient mortality
Notes FUNDING: none. Competing Interests: 2 authors declared conflicts of interest for speaker and advisory board fees
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: no response from authors
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Intervention independent (ITS) ? Low risk Intervention 1 was independent of other changes. The "crisis" (following the intervention) was a national economic crisis and will be reported separately in the review.
Analysed appropriately (ITS) ? Low risk Segmented regression analysis
Shape of effect pre‐specified (ITS) ? Low risk Point of intervention was point of analysis.
Unlikely to affect data collection (ITS) ? Low risk Data were obtained from pharmacy systems.
Knowledge of the allocation adequately prevented(ITS)? High risk Prescribing data were processed by the investigators to convert grams to DDD and identify only IV antibiotics.
Incomplete outcome data addressed (ITS) ? Low risk Routine pharmacy data
Free of selected reporting (ITS) ? Unclear risk Processing of data has potential for selective outcome reporting.
Free of other bias (ITS) ? Low risk 3 years' data pre‐ and 2 years' data postintervention