Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 9;2017(2):CD003543. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003543.pub4

Calfee 2003.

Methods STUDY DESIGN: unintended consequences, case control
Risk of Bias: HIGH
Participants PROVIDERS: all physicians in adult medical and surgical units
 PARTICIPANTS: all patients in the units
 CLINICAL PROBLEM: use of targeted antibiotics (3rd‐generation cephalosporins, piperacillin/tazobactam, aztreonam, carbapenems, parenteral clindamycin, oral and parenteral vancomycin, parenteral fluoroquinolones and macrolides, and fluconazole)
 SETTING: 1 hospital in the USA
Interventions FORMAT, Interventions: restrictive by review and make change, automatic stop order for prescriptions not meeting policy indications
 Intervention Functions: restriction
 DELIVERER: AMT
 COMPARISON: case control study
 DESIRED CHANGE: decrease excessive use of targeted drugs
Outcomes UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCES: proportion of nosocomial infections reported solely on the basis of a treating physician’s diagnosis during the endemic and epidemic periods (Table 1)
Notes ROBINS‐I RISK OF BIAS CRITERIA:
1. Confounding: Low, confounding unlikely
2. Selection of participants into the study: Unclear, insufficient detail about selection of cases for the endemic and epidemic period
3. Measurement classification of interventions: Low, intervention status well defined, recorded at the time of intervention, and unaffected by knowledge of the outcome or risk of the outcome
4. Deviation from intended interventions: Low, no switches to other interventions or evidence of intervention failure
5. Missing data: Unclear, outcomes are reported as % with no numerator or denominator data
6. Measurement of outcome: High, outcome measure objective, but outcome assessors were aware of the intervention status, and the study does not report the actual number of cases
7. Selection of the reported result: High, reported effect selected from multiple measurements within the outcome domain
FINANCIAL SUPPORT:Funding: no information. Competing Interests: no information
ADDITIONAL DATA: no response from authors to request for additional data