Marwick 2013.
Methods | STUDY DESIGN: ITS Risk of Bias: MEDIUM |
|
Participants | PROVIDERS: all physicians in medical and surgical wards PARTICIPANTS: all patients in medical and surgical wards CLINICAL PROBLEM: suspected sepsis (systemic inflammatory response and clinical suspicion of infection) SETTING: 1 university hospital in Scotland | |
Interventions | FORMAT: Interventions: audit and feedback; educational meetings with dissemination of guidelines; reminders (physical, posters in the wards and monthly email to doctors) Intervention Functions: education, enablement, environmental restructuring, persuasion DELIVERER: AMT COMPARISON: usual care DESIRED CHANGE: increase effective | |
Outcomes | PRESCRIBING: Choice: time to first antibiotic dose | |
Notes | FINANCIAL SUPPORT: Funding: Scottish Government Chief Scientist Office (CSO) Clinical Academic Training Fellowship (CAF/07/06). Competing Interests: salary costs for 2 investigators from CSO, no others declared ADDITIONAL DATA: email response from authors to request for additional data with additional detail from a PhD thesis |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Intervention independent (ITS) ? | High risk | There was a national intervention (Scottish Patient Safety Program) that included reducing time to rescue of deteriorating patients throughout the pre‐ and postintervention phases. |
Analysed appropriately (ITS) ? | Low risk | Segmented regression analysis |
Shape of effect pre‐specified (ITS) ? | Low risk | Point of intervention was point of analysis. |
Unlikely to affect data collection (ITS) ? | Low risk | Objective primary outcome measure (time to first antibiotic dose) collected by single person (CM). |
Knowledge of the allocation adequately prevented(ITS)? | Low risk | Objective primary outcome measure (time to first antibiotic dose) collected by single person (CM). |
Incomplete outcome data addressed (ITS) ? | Low risk | Outcome data collected on all participants. |
Free of selected reporting (ITS) ? | Low risk | Outcome data collected on all participants. |
Free of other bias (ITS) ? | Low risk | Data collected over winter months in pre‐ and postintervention period. |