Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 9;2017(2):CD003543. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003543.pub4

Marwick 2013.

Methods STUDY DESIGN: ITS
Risk of Bias: MEDIUM
Participants PROVIDERS: all physicians in medical and surgical wards
 PARTICIPANTS: all patients in medical and surgical wards
 CLINICAL PROBLEM: suspected sepsis (systemic inflammatory response and clinical suspicion of infection)
 SETTING: 1 university hospital in Scotland
Interventions FORMAT: Interventions: audit and feedback; educational meetings with dissemination of guidelines; reminders (physical, posters in the wards and monthly email to doctors)
 Intervention Functions: education, enablement, environmental restructuring, persuasion
 DELIVERER: AMT
 COMPARISON: usual care
 DESIRED CHANGE: increase effective
Outcomes PRESCRIBING: Choice: time to first antibiotic dose
Notes FINANCIAL SUPPORT: Funding: Scottish Government Chief Scientist Office (CSO) Clinical Academic Training Fellowship (CAF/07/06). Competing Interests: salary costs for 2 investigators from CSO, no others declared
ADDITIONAL DATA: email response from authors to request for additional data with additional detail from a PhD thesis
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Intervention independent (ITS) ? High risk There was a national intervention (Scottish Patient Safety Program) that included reducing time to rescue of deteriorating patients throughout the pre‐ and postintervention phases.
Analysed appropriately (ITS) ? Low risk Segmented regression analysis
Shape of effect pre‐specified (ITS) ? Low risk Point of intervention was point of analysis.
Unlikely to affect data collection (ITS) ? Low risk Objective primary outcome measure (time to first antibiotic dose) collected by single person (CM).
Knowledge of the allocation adequately prevented(ITS)? Low risk Objective primary outcome measure (time to first antibiotic dose) collected by single person (CM).
Incomplete outcome data addressed (ITS) ? Low risk Outcome data collected on all participants.
Free of selected reporting (ITS) ? Low risk Outcome data collected on all participants.
Free of other bias (ITS) ? Low risk Data collected over winter months in pre‐ and postintervention period.