Skip to main content
. 2017 Feb 4;2017(2):CD010331. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010331.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abad 2001 Intervention: oral sucrose vs lidocaine‐prilocaine cream.
Acharya 1998 Median age at inclusion into the study: 3 to 65 days.
Ahmed 2009 Intervention: EMLA vs control in infants undergoing circumcision.
Arendts 2008 Aged 12 months to 12 years.
Ballantyne 2003 Age at time of enrolment into study: 2 to 85 days.
Benini 1993 EMLA vs placebo in infants undergoing circumcision.
Biran 2011 Comparison groups: sucrose and EMLA vs sucrose and placebo cream.
Brisman 1998 Age at enrolment: 1 to 74 days.
Choy 1999 Age of participants 1 to 14 years.
Clarke 1986 Age of participants 1 to 14 years.
Essink‐Tebbes 1999 Non‐randomised controlled trial.
Gourrier 1995 Non‐randomised controlled trial.
Jain 2000b The cutaneous withdrawal reflex was elicited in response to stimulation of the dorsum of the neonate's foot using nylon filaments rather than a needle‐related pain procedure.
Joyce 2001 Intervention: music and EMLA in infants undergoing circumcision.
Kucukoglu 2015 Focus on instrumental touching on infant pain perception. No placebo used. Age at enrolment unclear.
Kurien 1985 Median age 24 to 30 months.
Lemyre 2007 Majority of infants given sucrose in addition to the intervention and placebo.
Lindh 2000 Randomised controlled trial comparing EMLA and placebo. Only outcome measure reported in this study is heart rate variability.
Marcatto 2011 Intervention EMLA vs glucose.
McIntosh 1994 Non‐randomised controlled trial.
Moore 2001 Postnatal age not reported.
Nahum 2007 Age of infants 1 to 60 days.
Newbury 2009 Aged 3 months to 15 years.
Nilsson 1990 Non‐randomised controlled trial.
Robieux 1991 Aged 3 to 36 months.
Taddio 1995 No control group. Randomisation based on site of EMLA application (right or left heel).
Taddio 2006 Interventions: tetracaine vs intravenous morphine vs tetracaine and intravenous morphine vs no treatment (control group not randomised).
van Kan 1997 Aged 1 to 15 years.
Weatherstone 1993 Intervention: 30% lidocaine vs placebo in infants undergoing circumcision.

EMLA: eutectic mixture of local anaesthetics.