Study |
Efficacy |
Participants with at least one adverse event |
Serious adverse events |
Withdrawals |
Goldenberg 1986
USA |
No significant difference between naproxen and placebo on any measure |
Naproxen 2/19
Placebo 2/19
Each had 1 dyspepsia, and 1 diarrhoea |
None reported |
1 naproxen (not returned)
1 placebo (epigastric distress) |
Kravitz 1994
USA |
No significant difference between naproxen and placebo on any measure |
AE data not reported in straightforward way |
1 ibuprofen sedation, memory problems, impaired mentation |
1 ibuprofen due to pre‐existing skin problem
14 did not complete all five weeks due to lack of efficacy, but data not given by treatment |
Mahagna 2016
NCT00755521
Israel |
50% pain intensity reduction
etoricoxib 4/32
placebo 6/32
30% pain intensity reduction
etoricoxib 9/32
placebo 9/32
No significant difference FIQ
No significant difference in SF‐36
No significant difference in HARS or HADS scales |
Total AE
etoricoxib 10/32
placebo 13/32 |
None |
All cause
etoricoxib 3/32
placebo 2/32
AE withdrawal
etoricoxib 2/32
placebo 0/32
LoE withdrawal
etoricoxib 0/32
placebo 0/32 |
Quijada‐Carrera 1996
Spain |
Clinically significant improvement
tenoxicam 4/41
placebo 7/41
25% reduction in pain
tenoxicam 6/41
placebo 9/41
No difference in number of tender points, sleep quality, or morning stiffness |
At least 1 AE
tenoxicam 18/41
placebo 7/41 |
None reported |
All cause
tenoxicam 17/41
placebo 15/41
AE withdrawal
tenoxicam 3/41
placebo 1/41
LoE withdrawal
tenoxicam 4/41
placebo 3/41 |
Russell 1991
USA |
No significant difference reported between ibuprofen and placebo for any outcome |
No data |
None reported |
AE withdrawals
ibuprofen 0
placebo 4 |
Yunus 1989
USA |
Mean pain score 2.4 in both groups at 3 weeks
No significant difference for sleep, morning fatigue, stiffness, or other symptoms
Moderate or complete pain relief at 3 weeks
ibuprofen 6/22
placebo 7/24 |
At least one AE
ibuprofen 5/22
placebo 4/24 |
None reported |
All cause withdrawal by week 3
ibuprofen 2/22
placebo 2/24
AE withdrawal
ibuprofen 1/22
placebo 0/24 |