Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 30;2017(3):CD011640. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011640.pub2

2. Risk of bias (by comparison).

Study name Intervention(s) and controls Random sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding of participants and personnel Blinding of outcom assessment Incomplete outcome data Selective
 reporting For‐profit bias Other bias
Fogari 2012 Renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor
 Control: Antihypertensives Unclear Low Low Low High High Low Low
Ersoz 2005 Bile acids
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear Unclear High High High High Unclear Low
Harrison 2009 Orlistat plus antioxidants
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High High Unclear Low
Kedarisetty 2014 Pentoxifylline plus antioxidants
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear Unclear High High Low High Unclear Low
Polyzos 2011 Renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor plus antioxidants
 Control: Antioxidants Low Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Low Low Low
Bugianesi 2005 Sulphonylureas
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear Unclear High High Unclear High Unclear Low
Sanyal 2010 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: Antioxidants Low Low Low Low Low Low High Low
Basu 2013 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear Unclear High High Unclear High Unclear Low
Sanyal 2004 Thiazolidinediones plus antioxidants
 Control: Antioxidants Unclear low Unclear Unclear low High Unclear Low
Parikh 2016 Antioxidants
 Control: Bile acids Unclear Unclear High High High High Low Low
Copaci 2009 Intervention 1: Pentoxifylline
 Intervention 2: Pentoxifylline plus bile acids
 Control: Bile acids Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Stilidi 2014 Renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor plus bile acids
 Control: Bile acids Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Shiffman 2015 Anti‐caspase
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High High Low
Ratziu 2016 Anti‐fibrotic
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High High Low
Harrison 2003 Antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High Unclear Low
Kugelmas 2003 Antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear High Unclear Unclear High Low Low
Gomez 2009 Antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Low Low High High Low
Magosso 2013 Antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low Low Low High Low
Basu 2014 Antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Low Low High High Low High High Low
Santos 2003 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High High Low
Lindor 2004 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Low Low Low High High High Low
Mendez‐Sanchez 2004 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Low Unclear Low Low High High Unclear Low
Leuschner 2010 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Low Low High Low
Ratziu 2011 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Low Low High Low
Mudaliar 2013 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Low Low Low Low Low High Low
Safadi 2014 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low High High High Low
Neuschwander‐Tetri 2015 Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low Low High High Low
Gianturco 2013 Intervention 1: Bile acids plus antioxidants
 Intervention 2: Antioxidants
 Intervention 3: Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High Unclear Low
Dufour 2006 Intervention 1: Bile acids plus antioxidants
 Intervention 2: Bile acids
 Control: No intervention Unclear Low Low Low High High High Low
Stefan 2014 Glucocorticosteroid inhibitor
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High High Low
Morita 2005 Other anti‐diabetes medication
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Low Low
Armstrong 2016 Other anti‐diabetes medication
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low Low Low High Low
Wang 2015 Intervention 1: Other anti‐diabetes medication
 Intervention 2: Sulphonylureas plus other anti‐diabetes medication
 Intervention 3: Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear High High Unclear High Unclear Low
Merat 2003 Other cholesterol‐lowering agents
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High Low Low
Loomba 2015 Other cholesterol‐lowering agents
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low Unclear High High Low
Van Wagner 2011 Pentoxifylline
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High Unclear Low
Ratziu 2014 Phosphodiesterase type 4 inhibitor
 Control: No intervention Unclear Low Low Low High High High Low
Alam 2016 Renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor
 Control: No intervention Low Low High High High Low Low Low
Hajaghamohammadi 2008 Silymarin
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Hashemi 2009 Silymarin
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Taghvaei 2013 Silymarin
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Solhi 2014 Silymarin
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High High Unclear Low
Chan 2015 Silymarin
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Aller 2015 Silymarin plus antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Low Unclear Unclear Unclear Low High Unclear Low
Bonfrate 2015 Silymarin plus antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Lewis 2006 Statins
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Nelson 2009 Statins
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Low High Low Low
Baranova 2015 Statins
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Foster 2011 Statins plus antioxidants
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Uygun 2004 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Low Unclear High High High High Unclear Low
Haukeland 2009 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High High Low
Nar 2009 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Shields 2009 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Low Low Unclear Low Low High Unclear Low
Garinis 2010 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Low High High Unclear Low
Sofer 2011 Sulphonylureas
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Low High Unclear Low
Belfort 2006 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low High High High Low
Cui 2006 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Aithal 2008 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Low Low Low Low Low Low High Low
Ratziu 2008 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low High High High Low
Gastaldelli 2009 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Yaginuma 2009 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Jin 2010 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Cusi 2013 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High High Low
Kakazu 2013 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear High Unclear High High Low Low
Sunny 2015 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High High Low
Yan 2015 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: No intervention Low Unclear High High Unclear High Low Low
Athyros 2006 Intervention 1: Statins
 Intervention 2: Statins plus other cholesterol‐lowering agents
 Control: Other cholesterol‐lowering agents Low Low High High Low Low High Low
Razavizadeh 2012 Antioxidants
 Control: Silymarin Unclear Unclear Low Low Unclear High Unclear Low
Hajiaghamohammadi 2012 Thiazolidinediones
 Sulphonylureas
 Control: Silymarin Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Low High Low Low
Siddique 2015 Thiazolidinediones
 Control: Statins Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Klyarytskaya 2015 Renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor plus statins plus antioxidants
 Control: Statins plus antioxidants Unclear Unclear High High Unclear High Unclear Low
Askarimoghadam 2013 Sulphonylureas plus antioxidants
 Control: Sulphonylureas Unclear Unclear High High Unclear High Unclear Low
Song 2014 Sulphonylureas plus other anti‐diabetes medication
 Control: Sulphonylureas Low Unclear Unclear Unclear Unclear High Unclear Low
Sharma 2012 Pentoxifylline
 Control: Thiazolidinediones Low Low High High High High Unclear Low
Omer 2010 Sulphonylureas
 Control: Thiazolidinediones Unclear Unclear High High High High Unclear Low
Razavizade 2013 Sulphonylureas
 Control: Thiazolidinediones Low Low Low Low Low Low Low Low
Torres 2011 Intervention 1: Thiazolidinediones plus renin‐angiotensin‐aldosterone system inhibitor
 Intervention 2: Thiazolidinediones plus sulphonylureas
 Control: Thiazolidinediones Low Low High High High High High Low