Liston 2000
Methods | Cross‐over group design Participants randomised to groups by the toss of a coin Allocation concealment not reported 17% drop outs at the end of the first treatment phase Blinding of outcome assessors to group allocation | |
Participants | 10 participants allocated to the EXP then CTL order, and 8 participants allocated to the CTL then EXP order Inclusion criteria: higher level gait disorder; CT scan with large vessel infarct, basal ganglia and white matter lacunes, or extensive leukoaraiosis; discharged from all rehabilitation services; informed consent Exclusion criteria: severe cognitive impairment; significant physical impairments from other causes | |
Interventions | Treated as inpatients or outpatients for 3 x 1‐hour sessions per week for 4 weeks Treadmill training (EXP): participants walked on a treadmill for as long as they felt comfortable, rest breaks were allowed; no body weight support was provided using a harness Conventional physiotherapy (CTL): a schedule of 31 interventions in 3 treatment modules: gait ignition or failure, postural alignment and other | |
Outcomes | Assessed at baseline, at cross‐over (4 weeks), after treatment phase (at 8 weeks) and 6 weeks after final treatment:
|
|
Notes | The rating of drop outs was changed based on correspondence from the trialist Trial treated as a parallel‐group design for this review by using the first treatment phase data only (that is baseline and cross‐over data only) | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | By the toss of a coin |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | High risk | Not reported |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Blinding of outcome assessors to group allocation |