Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 16;2016(11):CD009178. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009178.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Asano 2013 Not an RCT
Asayama 2003 Participants had no identified sleep problem at baseline
Bergener 1968 Geriatric population with mixed diagnoses. No primary sleep aim. No identified sleep problem at baseline
Bergonzi 1973 Not an RCT
Cardinali 2014 Not an RCT
Cohen‐Mansfield 2000 Not an RCT
Cruz‐Aguilar 2013 Not an RCT
Eeles 2003 Not an RCT (group assignment by birth date)
Gehrmann 2009 Participants had no identified sleep problem at baseline
Gillman 1997 Not an RCT
GInsburg 1976 Not an RCT (incomplete Latin square design). Uncertain diagnoses
Haworth 2001 Trial register entry in 2001 for an investigator‐led trial of melatonin planned for 2001 to 2002. Described in the trial register as 'a pilot study'. We found no evidence that this trial was ever completed and were unable to obtain any information from the author.
Howcroft 2005 Not an RCT
Kittur 1999 Not an RCT
Linnoila 1980a Participants were 19 psychogeriatric inpatients, 7 of whom were identified as having 'senile dementia'
Linnoila 1980b Participants were 20 psychogeriatric inpatients, 10 of whom were identified as having 'senile dementia'
Magnus 1978 Participants were 17 elderly patients with unspecified organic dementia. No identified sleep problems at baseline
Mahlberg 2004 Not an RCT
Markowitz 2003 No identified sleep problem at baseline. Aimed to assess effect of galantamine on sleep but no primary aim to improve sleep.
Meguro 2004 Not an RCT. Participants selected for wandering behaviour
Mishima 1992 Not an RCT. Participants had multi‐infarct dementia
Moraes 2003 No identified sleep problems at baseline
Moraes 2006 No identified sleep problems at baseline. (Patients excluded for severe sleep disturbance)
NCT00035204 No primary aim to improve sleep. No placebo control (comparison of two cholinesterase inhibitors)
NCT00480870 No identified sleep problems at baseline. No primary aim to improve sleep
NCT00626210 Not an RCT
NCT00706186 Study terminated July 2010. Withdrawn by investigator
NCT00940589 No identified sleep problems at baseline
NCT01548287 No identified sleep problems at baseline (confirmed by representative of sponsor)
Petit 1993 No mention of randomised allocation. No identified sleep problems at baseline
Riemersma‐van der Lek2008 No identified sleep problems at baseline
Riley McCarten 1995 Not an RCT
Ruths 2004 No identified sleep problems at baseline. Drug withdrawal study
Schubert 1984 Not an RCT
Scoralick 2016 Only 10/24 included participants were randomised; majority of control data were drawn from an earlier study.
Scripnikov 2007 No primary sleep aim. No identified sleep problems at baseline
Shaw 1992 Participants were elderly psychiatric inpatients, < 50% had dementia
Shinno 2008 Not an RCT
Simon Padilla 2009 Not an RCT
Singer 2007 Not an RCT.
Stahl 2004 No primary sleep aim. (Investigated sleep‐related adverse events in RCTs of galantamine)
Stemmelin 2013 No identified sleep problems at baseline
Tozawa 1998 Identified from Conference proceedings and other literature. Probably a small RCT (7 participants). Minimal information and no results obtainable
UMIN000006388 Not an RCT
UMIN000016374 No placebo control, comparing hypnotic, antidepressant and herbal medicine
Valtonen 2005 No identified sleep problems at baseline
Walther 2011 Planned trial (Swissmedic 2007DR2217) was not completed. Only 2 patients could be randomised, published as case reports
Yehuda 1996 No primary sleep aim. No identified sleep problems at baseline

Abbreviations

AD = Alzheimer's disease
 MCI = mild cognitive impairment