Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 1;2016(11):CD006683. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006683.pub3

Kraff 1982.

Methods Study design: Parallel group RCT
Participants Country: USA
Setting: Eye hospital
Intervention: NSAIDs plus steroids
  • Number of people (eyes) randomised: 330 (NR)

  • Number (%) of people followed up: 323 (98%)

  • Average age in years: 69

  • Age range in years: 37‐91

  • Percentage women: 60%

  • Ethnic group: NR

  • Percentage with diabetes: NR

  • Percentage with uveitis: NR


Comparator: Steroids plus placebo
  • Number of people (eyes) randomised: 170 (NR)

  • Number (%) of people followed up: 169 (99%)

  • Average age in years: 68

  • Age range in years: 45‐97

  • Percentage women: 54%

  • Ethnic group: NR

  • Percentage with diabetes: NR

  • Percentage with uveitis: NR


Included criteria: Eligible for extracapsular cataract extraction with implantation of a Shearing posterior chamber lens.
Excluded criteria: NR
Pretreatment: None noted; age, gender, follow‐up and endothelial cell density preoperative compared.
Eyes: Unclear if one or both eyes included.
Interventions Intervention: NSAIDs plus steroids
  • indomethacin (brand name not reported)

    • Times per day: 5 times every 10 to 15 mins 18 hrs before surgery; 1 x 12 hrs before surgery; 1 x at bedtime; 1 x 2 hrs before surgery; 1 x 1.5 hrs before surgery; 1 x 30 mins before surgery; 4 times a day postoperative

    • Duration preoperative: days: 1

    • Duration postoperative: days: 274

  • dexamethasone (in combination with neomycin sulfate, polymyxin B sulfate) for 4 days followed by dexamethasone alone for 4 weeks followed by fluorometholone for at least 6 months (Maxitrol and Maxidex)

    • Times per day: 4 times a day (dexamethasone) and 3 times a day (fluorometholone)

    • Duration preoperative: days: 1

    • Duration postoperative: days: 274


Comparator: Steroids plus placebo
  • dexamethasone (in combination with neomycin sulfate, polymyxin B sulfate) for 4 days followed by dexamethasone alone for 4 weeks followed by fluorometholone for at least 6 months (Maxitrol and Maxidex)

    • Times per day: 4 times a day (dexamethasone) and 3 times a day (fluorometholone)

    • Duration preoperative: days: 1

    • Duration postoperative: days: 274

  • placebo (vehicle)

    • Times per day: 5 times every 10 to 15 mins 18 hrs before surgery; 1 x 12 hrs before surgery; 1 x at bedtime; 1 x 2 hrs before surgery; 1 x 1.5 hrs before surgery; 1 x 30 mins before surgery; 4 times a day postoperative

    • Duration preoperative: days: 1

    • Duration postoperative: days: 274


Type of surgery: ECCE and phacoemulsification (unplanned ICCE n = 19 were excluded).
Outcomes Follow‐up: between 2.5 and 12 months. Quote: "The mean interval between surgery and angiography was 4.1 months, with a range of 2.5 to 12 months. Ninety percent of the angiograms were performed between 2.5 and 5 months after surgery, and 10% between 6 and 12 months after surgery."
  • Adverse effects

  • CMO (fluorescein angiography using Miyake 1977)

  • Snellen acuity only (not included in the analyses).

Contact details Authors name: Manus C Kraff
Institution: Abraham Lincoln School of Medicine, University of Illinois
Email: NR
Address: 5600 W. Addison Street, Chicago, IL 60634
Notes Funding sources: Core Grant EY 1792 NEI Bethesda Maryland
Declaration of interest: NR
Date study conducted: NR
Trial registration number: NR
Contacting study investigators: Trial authors not contacted.
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Low risk Judgement comment: Randomisation was using a table of random numbers.
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk Judgement comment: Not reported how allocation administered.
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) 
 All outcomes Low risk Judgement comment: Quote: "The study was double‐masked; neither the physician nor the patient knew what drops the patient was receiving."
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) 
 All outcomes Low risk Judgement comment: Quote: "The study was double‐masked; neither the physician nor the patient knew what drops the patient was receiving." Quote: "The angiograms were read in a masked fashion by a retired specialist (LMJ) who had no knowledge of either the drug regimen or the type of surgical procedure."
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) 
 All outcomes Unclear risk Judgement comment: Some patients were excluded (n = 19) and not reported: two with vitreous loss, two with vitreous pressure and a shallow anterior chamber and 15 with possible rupture of the posterior capsule. Unclear which groups these were in. Follow‐up high for visual acuity (> 95%) but lower for CMO (60% in indomethacin group versus 64% in placebo).
Selective reporting (reporting bias) Unclear risk Judgement comment: No access to protocol or trial registry entry.