Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 22;2014(4):CD001920. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001920.pub3

3. Summary of treatment components.

Study Group Categories (and treatment components)
    Assistive
Devices
Cardiopulmonary
intervention
Functional
Task
Training
Modality Musculoskeletal
intervention
(active)
Musculoskeletal
intervention
(passive)
Neurophysiological
intervention
Aksu 2001 ‘All groups' Described as 'Bobath'
Allison 2007 ‘Intervention' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
UL function training
Musc. strengthening
  ‘Control' Walking
UL function training
Musc. strengthening
Baer 2007 ‘Part practice' Walking
  ‘Whole practice' Walking
Bai 2008 ‘Early rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Bale 2008 ‘Functional strength training' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
UL function training
Musc. strengthening
  ‘Training as usual' ADL training Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
Described as 'Bobath'
Sensorimotor facilitation
Behrman 2011 ‘Locomotor training program' Walking
  ‘Home exercise program' Sitting and/or standing balance Musc. strengthening
Blennerhassett 2004 ‘Mobility’ Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Musc. strengthening
Brock 2005 ‘Bobath' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Walking
Stair climbing
Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Trunk mobilisations/
postural reactions (Bobath)
PNF
  ‘Task practice' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Carlson 2006 ‘Treatment' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Chan 2006 ‘Motor relearning' Sit‐to‐stand practice
Described as 'MRP'
  ‘Conventional therapy' Sit‐to‐stand practice
Chen 2004 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Stair climbing
UL function training
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Sensorimotor facilitation
Chen 2006 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL function training
Passive movement
Chen 2010 ‘Test' Walking Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Chu 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL function training
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Sensorimotor facilitation
Cooke 2006 ‘Additional conventional therapy (CPT+CPT)' ADL training Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Massage
Sensorimotor facilitation
  ‘Functional strength training (FST +CPT)' Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Massage
Sensorimotor facilitation
  ‘Conventional physiotherapy (CPT)' ADL training Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Massage
Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Sensorimotor facilitation
Dean 1997 ‘Motor learning' Sitting and/or standing balance
Described as 'MRP'
Dean 2000 ‘Motor learning' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Musc. strengthening
Dean 2006 ‘Experimental' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Musc. strengthening
Dean 2007 ‘Experimental' Sitting and/or standing balance
Described as 'MRP'
Deng 2011 ‘Intervention' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
UL training
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Duncan 1998 ‘Mixed' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
UL training
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
PNF
Duncan 2003 ‘Mixed' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
UL training
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
PNF
Fan 2006 ‘Treated' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Fang 2003 ‘Additional early physiotherapy intervention' Passive movement Described as 'Bobath'
Fang 2004 old ‘Rehabilitation' Passive movement
Massage
Fang 2004 young ‘Rehabilitation' Passive movement
Massage
Ge 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Acupuncture
Physical agents
Active and
active assisted movement
Massage Described as 'Bobath'
Gelber 1995 ‘Neurophysiological (NDT)' ADL training Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
  ‘Orthopaedic (TFR)' Walking aids
Orthoses for walking
ADL training Musc. strengthening Passive movement
Green 2002 ‘Mixed'     ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
       
Holmgren 2006 ‘Intervention' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Musc. strengthening
Hou 2006 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Physical agents Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Howe 2005 ‘Mixed' Sitting and/or standing balance
Described as 'MRP'
Hu 2007 haem ‘Test'     Details of individual components not available     Details of individual components not available  
Hu 2007 isch ‘Test'     Details of individual components not available     Details of individual components not available  
Huang 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Acupuncture
Physical agents
Active and
active assisted movement
Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Hui‐Chan 2009 ‘PLBO‐TRT' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Jiang 2006 ‘Treated' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Acupuncture Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Jing 2006 ‘Exercise' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Passive movement PNF
  ‘Exercise and OT' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
Walking
UL training
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
PNF
Kim 2011 ‘PNF' Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement PNF
  ‘General exercise' Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Kim 2012 ‘Experimental' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Musc. strengthening Passive movement
  ‘Control' Sitting and/or standing balance Musc. strengthening Passive movement
Kwakkel 2002 ‘Lower extremities' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
Walking
  ‘Upper extremities' UL training
Kwakkel 2008 ‘Circuit training'   Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Musc. strengthening
Langhammer 2000 ‘Motor learning' Described as 'MRP'
  ‘Neurophysiological (Bobath)' Described as 'Bobath'
Langhammer 2007 ‘Intensive exercise' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Musc. strengthening
Lennon 2006 ‘Bobath' Described as 'Bobath'
  ‘Gait specific' Walking
Li 1999 ‘Early rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
Li 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Li 2005 ‘Motor learning' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
UL training
Described as 'MRP'
Acupuncture
Physical agents
  ‘Neurodevelopmental therapy' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Acupuncture
Physical agents
Body and limb positioning Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Liao 2006 ‘Treatment' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Trunk mobilisations/
postural reactions (Bobath)
  ‘Control' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Lincoln 2003 ‘Neurophysiological
(Bobath)'
Described as 'Bobath'
  ‘Motor learning' Described as 'MRP'
Liu 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
McClellan 2004 ‘Motor learning' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Described as 'MRP'
  ‘Placebo (upper limb control)' UL training
Mudge 2009 ‘Exercise' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Musc. strengthening
Mudie 2002 ‘Feedback' Sitting and/or standing balance Physical agents
  ‘Motor learning (Task‐related training)' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
  ‘Neurophysiological
(Bobath)'
Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
Described as 'Bobath'
Trunk mobilisations/
postural reactions (Bobath)
Ni 1997 ‘Comprehensive rehabilitation training' Orthoses for walking Sitting and/or standing balance Physical agents Described as 'Bobath'
Pan 2004 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Pang 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
UL training
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Pang 2006 ‘Treatment' Acupuncture Described as 'Bobath'
Pollock 1998 ‘Mixed' Sitting and/or standing balance
  ‘Neurophysiological (Bobath)' Described as 'Bobath'
Qian 2004 'Treatment' ADL training Acupuncture
Physical agents
Body and limb positioning Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Qian 2005 ‘Treatment' ADL training
Walking
Acupuncture
Physical agents
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Sensorimotor facilitation
Richards 1993 ‘Experimental' Walking Physical agents Musc. strengthening Tilt table
  'Early conventional' Described as 'Bobath'
  'Routine conventional' Described as 'Bobath'
Salbach 2004 ‘Motor learning' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Described as 'MRP'
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
  ‘Placebo (upper limb control)' UL training
Described as 'MRP'
Shin 2011 ‘Combined exercise' Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Musc. strengthening
  ‘Conventional exercise' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
  Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Trunk mobilisations/
postural reactions (Bobath)
Stephenson 2004 ‘Proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation (PNF)' Walking PNF
  ‘Body weight support treadmill training' Walking
Tang 2009 ‘Observation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
Sensorimotor facilitation
  ‘Control' ADL training
Transfer practice
Walking
Body and limb positioning Described as 'Bobath'
Thaut 2007 ‘Rhythmic auditory stimulation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Stair climbing
  ‘Neurodevelopmental therapy (NDT)/Bobath‐based training' Walking Described as 'Bobath'
Torres‐Arreola 2009 ‘Strategy 1 (S1) (Physiotherapy)' Walking aids ADL training
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
UL training
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
  ‘Strategy 2 (S2) Education'
Verheyden 2006 ‘Experimental' Sitting and/or standing balance
Described as 'MRP'
Active and
active assisted movement
Described as 'Bobath'
  ‘Control' Described as 'MRP'       Described as 'Bobath'
Verma 2011 ‘Experimental' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
 
  ‘Control' Described as 'Bobath'
Wade 1992 ‘Mixed' Walking aids Aerobic, fitness,
endurance
ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Wang 2004a ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
UL training
Described as 'MRP'
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Wang 2004b ‘Treatment' Physical agents Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Sensorimotor facilitation
  'Control' Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Wang 2005 ‘Neurophysiological' Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
Described as 'Bobath'
Trunk mobilisations/
postural reactions (Bobath)
  ‘Orthopaedic' ADL training
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Musc. strengthening
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Wang 2006 ‘Rehabilitation'     ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
 
Wei 1998 ‘Exercise' Described as 'Bobath'
Wellmon 1997 ‘Motor learning' Sitting and/or standing balance
  ‘Control'
Wu 2006 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Xiao 2003 ‘Intensive rehabilitation' Physical agents Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
  ‘Conventional' Described as 'Bobath'
Xie 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Stair climbing
UL training
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Xie 2005 ‘Treatment' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
Walking
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Xu 1999 'Rehabilitation' Described as 'Bobath'
Xu 2003a ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Xu 2003b ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training Body and limb positioning Sensorimotor facilitation
Xu 2004 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL training
Sitting and/or standing balance
Transfer practice
Walking
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
Xue 2006 ‘Training' Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Described as 'MRP'
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
Yan 2002 ‘Rehabilitation' Resting splints Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Yelnik 2008 ‘NDT‐based treatment' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Hands on facilitation
(Bobath)
Inhibition of abn musc. tone (Bobath)
Described as 'Bobath'
  ‘Multisensorial' Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Yin 2003a ‘Rehabilitation' Resting splints Sitting and/or standing balance Body and limb positioning Described as 'Bobath'
Zhang 1998 ‘Early rehabilitation' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Stair climbing
Musc. strengthening Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Massage
Sensorimotor facilitation
Zhang 2004 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Walking
Described as 'MRP'
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Zhao 2002 ‘Rehabilitation nursing' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Zhao 2003 ‘Rehabilitation' ADL practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
Active and
active assisted movement
Passive movement
Zhu 2001 ‘Rehabilitation' Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Described as 'MRP'
Physical agents Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Described as 'Bobath'
Zhu 2004b ‘Treated' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL training
Active and
active assisted movement
Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Zhu 2006 ‘Test' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL training
Inc. angle of
upright sitting
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Described as 'Bobath'
PNF
Zhu 2007 haem ‘Cerebral haemorrhage' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL training
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Zhu 2007 isch ‘Cerebral infarction' ADL practice
Sitting and/or standing balance
Sit‐to‐stand practice
Transfer practice
Walking
Stair climbing
UL training
Passive movement
Body and limb positioning
Zhuang 2012 ‘Acupuncture' Acupuncture
  ‘Physiotherapy' Described as 'Bobath'

Abn: abnormal; ADL: activities of daily living; Inc:increasing; MRP: motor relearning programme; Musc: muscle; Norm: normal; PNF: proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation; UL: upper limb