Skip to main content
. 2017 Jan 14;2017(1):CD011279. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011279.pub2

Table 2.

Reasons for exclusion

Review Reason for exclusion from overview
Aggarwal 2011 Not exercise/physical activity
Brønfort 2015 Protocol stage only ‐ possibly include when published as full review
Bierma‐Zeinstra 2011 Protocol stage only ‐ exclude when published as full review
Brønfort 2014 Withdrawn from the Cochrane Library
Choi 2010 Not chronic using definition of > 3 months
Craane 2006 Protocol stage only ‐ possibly include when published as full review
Dagfinrud 2008 Physiotherapy ‐ required therapist to perform intervention
Dahm 2010 Acute pain, not chronic. Intervention was advice
Dal Bello‐Haas 2013 Malignant condition
de Souza 2012 Drug‐ and surgery‐based interventions
Fokkenrood 2013 Did not include RCTs (excluded studies with control groups)
Franke 2015 Not exercise/physical activity
Green 2003 Physiotherapy ‐ required therapist to perform intervention
Gross 1998 Withdrawn from the Cochrane Library
Gross 2012 Not exercise/physical activity
Gross 2015b Not exercise/physical activity
Hayden 2012 Protocol stage only ‐ possibly include when published as full review
Heintjes 2003 Withdrawn from the Cochrane Library January 2015
Henschke 2010 Not exercise/physical activity
Heymans 2004 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Hilde 2006 Withdrawn from the Cochrane Library
Hoving 2014 No exercise intervention, and no pain outcome measure
Hurley 2013 Protocol stage only ‐ exclude when published as full review
IJzelenberg 2011 Protocol stage only ‐ exclude when published as full review
Jones 2000 Drug‐based interventions
Jordan 2010 Intervention to improve adherence to exercise, not exercise itself
Kamper 2014 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Karjalainen 1999 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Karjalainen 2003 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Larun 2016 Chronic fatigue, not chronic pain
Liddle 2015 Pain in pregnancy only, not chronic pain
Liu 2013 Protocol stage only ‐ unsure about inclusion when published as full review
Miller 2014 Protocol stage only ‐ exclude when published as full review
Moi 2013 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
O'Brien 2004 No pain outcome measure
O'Connell 2013 Overview of reviews, not systematic review
Østerås 2013 Protocol stage only ‐ possibly include when published as full review
Page 2012 No pain outcome measure
Page 2014 Manual therapy ‐ required therapist to perform intervention
Peters 2013 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Preston 2004 No pain outcome measure
Proctor 2007 Exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Radner 2012 Drug‐based interventions
Regnaux 2014 Protocol stage only ‐ possibly include when published as full review
Richards 2012 Not exercise/physical activity
Riemsma 2003 Not exercise/physical activity
Schaafsma 2013 No pain outcome measure
Steultjens 2004 Occupational therapy ‐ exercise could not be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Stones 2005 Exercise cannot be assessed as stand‐alone intervention
Takken 2008 Aged < 18 years ‐ not adults
van Dessel 2014 Not chronic pain and no specific pain outcome measure
White 2004 No pain outcome measure
Williams 2012 Not exercise/physical activity
Zammit 2010 Surgery or required therapist to perform intervention

RCT: randomised controlled trial.