Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 17;2016(11):CD012437. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012437
Remission established: odds ratios, risk ratios and risk difference for all treatment comparisons ‐ random‐effects model
Treatment Reference OR (95% CrI) RR (95% CrI) RD % (95% CrI)
MTX + DMARD MTX + PL 0.70(0.22,2.23) 0.71(0.22,2.11) ‐0.01(‐0.04,0.05)
PL   1.02(0.12,8.51) 1.02(0.13,6.35) 0.00(‐0.05,0.25)
SD ETN SC   1.79(0.76,4.33) 1.73(0.77,3.73) 0.04(‐0.01,0.13)
SD ADA SC   1.22(0.20,8.20) 1.21(0.21,6.15) 0.01(‐0.04,0.24)
SD GOLI IV   1.42(0.41,5.02) 1.39(0.42,4.22) 0.02(‐0.03,0.15)
SD GOLI SC   3.62(0.36,35.55) 3.21(0.38,13.57) 0.11(‐0.03,0.59)
SD ETN SC + MTX   3.21(1.48,7.01) 2.89(1.44,5.42) 0.09(0.02,0.22)
SD ABA IV + MTX   4.73(2.39,9.83) 3.99(2.23,6.95) 0.15(0.06,0.28)
SD ABA SC + MTX   3.50(1.34,8.74) 3.12(1.32,6.43) 0.10(0.02,0.26)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   10.54(3.79,32.51) 7.16(3.30,13.55) 0.30(0.12,0.56)
SD ADA SC + MTX   3.94(1.73,9.61) 3.44(1.67,6.81) 0.12(0.03,0.28)
SD INF IV + MTX   2.26(0.88,6.08) 2.13(0.88,4.89) 0.06(‐0.01,0.19)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   3.63(1.35,10.50) 3.21(1.33,7.25) 0.11(0.02,0.30)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   3.27(1.24,8.88) 2.94(1.22,6.48) 0.09(0.01,0.26)
SD CERTO + MTX   10.74(1.18,283.80) 7.24(1.17,21.74) 0.31(0.01,0.88)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   4.30(0.91,25.42) 3.69(0.92,11.98) 0.13(0.00,0.51)
LD GOLI IV   2.21(0.65,7.72) 2.09(0.66,5.86) 0.05(‐0.02,0.23)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   1.51(0.58,4.16) 1.48(0.59,3.61) 0.02(‐0.02,0.13)
LD ETN SC + MTX   2.96(1.03,8.69) 2.70(1.03,6.35) 0.08(0.00,0.26)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   1.31(0.37,4.63) 1.29(0.38,3.96) 0.01(‐0.03,0.14)
HD TOCI IV   7.03(1.84,31.06) 5.42(1.76,13.25) 0.22(0.04,0.55)
HD GOLI SC   4.69(1.16,20.27) 3.97(1.15,10.81) 0.15(0.01,0.45)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   12.92(4.14,49.77) 8.11(3.56,15.88) 0.35(0.13,0.66)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   9.48(3.37,28.37) 6.67(2.99,12.84) 0.28(0.10,0.53)
HD INF IV + MTX   3.49(1.22,10.51) 3.11(1.21,7.20) 0.10(0.01,0.30)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   10.91(2.39,64.71) 7.33(2.23,16.48) 0.31(0.06,0.71)
PL MTX + DMARD 1.45(0.13,16.52) 1.42(0.14,12.42) 0.01(‐0.07,0.26)
SD ETN SC   2.56(0.89,7.68) 2.42(0.89,6.93) 0.05(‐0.01,0.13)
SD ADA SC   1.76(0.21,16.15) 1.71(0.22,12.41) 0.02(‐0.06,0.25)
SD GOLI IV   2.04(0.37,11.34) 1.96(0.40,9.70) 0.03(‐0.05,0.17)
SD GOLI SC   5.22(0.39,68.59) 4.45(0.40,30.13) 0.12(‐0.04,0.61)
SD ETN SC + MTX   4.56(1.89,11.45) 4.02(1.76,9.98) 0.10(0.04,0.20)
SD ABA IV + MTX   6.74(1.80,27.16) 5.57(1.67,20.56) 0.16(0.05,0.30)
SD ABA SC + MTX   4.96(1.09,22.38) 4.33(1.08,17.14) 0.11(0.01,0.28)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   15.31(3.22,75.02) 10.02(2.67,37.41) 0.31(0.12,0.57)
SD ADA SC + MTX   5.62(1.39,25.28) 4.81(1.35,18.90) 0.13(0.03,0.29)
SD INF IV + MTX   3.25(0.73,15.40) 2.99(0.75,12.72) 0.07(‐0.02,0.20)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   5.18(1.15,25.60) 4.48(1.13,19.01) 0.12(0.01,0.31)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   4.67(1.04,22.15) 4.11(1.04,16.92) 0.11(0.00,0.28)
SD CERTO + MTX   15.62(1.25,484.40) 9.93(1.23,54.76) 0.32(0.01,0.89)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   6.20(0.89,51.49) 5.14(0.90,27.65) 0.14(‐0.01,0.52)
LD GOLI IV   3.16(0.59,17.69) 2.92(0.61,13.92) 0.06(‐0.03,0.25)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   2.15(0.48,10.46) 2.06(0.50,9.20) 0.04(‐0.04,0.14)
LD ETN SC + MTX   4.24(1.07,17.46) 3.78(1.07,13.63) 0.09(0.00,0.26)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   1.87(0.34,10.69) 1.81(0.36,9.21) 0.03(‐0.05,0.15)
HD TOCI IV   10.18(1.72,66.28) 7.53(1.62,32.99) 0.23(0.04,0.56)
HD GOLI SC   6.78(1.08,43.15) 5.55(1.07,25.91) 0.16(0.01,0.46)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   18.61(3.66,112.50) 11.21(2.96,44.17) 0.36(0.13,0.67)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   13.61(2.86,68.76) 9.29(2.45,35.46) 0.29(0.10,0.54)
HD INF IV + MTX   4.98(1.07,25.53) 4.33(1.06,18.66) 0.11(0.00,0.31)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   15.72(2.31,130.70) 10.00(2.09,43.78) 0.32(0.06,0.72)
SD ETN SC PL 1.76(0.18,17.32) 1.69(0.24,15.33) 0.03(‐0.21,0.14)
SD ADA SC   1.21(0.07,20.18) 1.20(0.09,16.14) 0.01(‐0.23,0.23)
SD GOLI IV   1.41(0.12,16.35) 1.38(0.15,14.33) 0.02(‐0.23,0.16)
SD GOLI SC   3.52(0.81,16.88) 2.95(0.83,11.43) 0.09(‐0.01,0.45)
SD ETN SC + MTX   3.14(0.34,30.37) 2.82(0.41,24.64) 0.08(‐0.16,0.23)
SD ABA IV + MTX   4.66(0.50,44.57) 3.92(0.58,34.30) 0.14(‐0.12,0.29)
SD ABA SC + MTX   3.40(0.34,34.84) 3.01(0.42,27.46) 0.09(‐0.15,0.27)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   10.48(1.43,79.41) 6.91(1.28,49.53) 0.29(0.06,0.52)
SD ADA SC + MTX   3.92(0.40,39.59) 3.40(0.47,30.44) 0.11(‐0.14,0.29)
SD INF IV + MTX   2.25(0.22,23.79) 2.11(0.28,19.89) 0.05(‐0.20,0.19)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   3.60(0.34,38.36) 3.15(0.42,29.24) 0.10(‐0.15,0.30)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   3.21(0.31,33.38) 2.87(0.39,26.31) 0.09(‐0.16,0.27)
SD CERTO + MTX   11.15(0.48,564.20) 6.80(0.54,81.10) 0.29(‐0.09,0.88)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   4.29(0.30,70.57) 3.60(0.36,41.14) 0.12(‐0.15,0.50)
LD GOLI IV   2.17(0.18,25.75) 2.04(0.23,20.97) 0.05(‐0.20,0.23)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   1.49(0.15,16.00) 1.45(0.19,14.02) 0.02(‐0.22,0.14)
LD ETN SC + MTX   2.92(0.27,31.42) 2.64(0.33,24.82) 0.08(‐0.17,0.26)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   1.29(0.11,15.14) 1.27(0.14,13.32) 0.01(‐0.23,0.15)
HD TOCI IV   7.04(0.55,89.56) 5.25(0.62,50.27) 0.20(‐0.09,0.54)
HD GOLI SC   4.55(1.02,24.12) 3.76(1.01,19.15) 0.13(0.00,0.35)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   12.86(1.15,155.00) 7.82(1.11,70.11) 0.33(0.03,0.66)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   9.38(1.32,73.10) 6.43(1.21,45.84) 0.26(0.05,0.50)
HD INF IV + MTX   3.46(0.32,37.71) 3.04(0.39,28.79) 0.09(‐0.16,0.30)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   10.89(0.78,168.40) 6.93(0.82,67.45) 0.29(‐0.04,0.70)
SD ADA SC SD ETN SC 0.69(0.09,5.40) 0.71(0.10,4.25) ‐0.02(‐0.14,0.20)
SD GOLI IV   0.80(0.17,3.58) 0.81(0.19,3.12) ‐0.01(‐0.12,0.12)
SD GOLI SC   2.02(0.17,22.98) 1.85(0.19,9.98) 0.07(‐0.10,0.55)
SD ETN SC + MTX   1.78(0.98,3.28) 1.66(0.98,2.89) 0.05(0.00,0.13)
SD ABA IV + MTX   2.64(0.86,8.24) 2.31(0.88,6.23) 0.11(‐0.02,0.25)
SD ABA SC + MTX   1.95(0.52,6.80) 1.80(0.56,5.28) 0.07(‐0.06,0.23)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   5.93(1.54,23.52) 4.14(1.42,11.54) 0.26(0.06,0.53)
SD ADA SC + MTX   2.19(0.66,7.51) 1.98(0.70,5.75) 0.08(‐0.04,0.25)
SD INF IV + MTX   1.26(0.35,4.76) 1.23(0.39,4.03) 0.02(‐0.09,0.16)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   2.03(0.55,7.94) 1.86(0.59,5.85) 0.07(‐0.06,0.26)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   1.83(0.49,6.84) 1.70(0.53,5.28) 0.06(‐0.07,0.23)
SD CERTO + MTX   6.05(0.54,173.40) 4.14(0.58,17.25) 0.27(‐0.05,0.85)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   2.40(0.41,17.30) 2.13(0.45,8.97) 0.09(‐0.07,0.47)
LD GOLI IV   1.24(0.27,5.59) 1.21(0.30,4.48) 0.02(‐0.10,0.20)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.84(0.23,3.24) 0.85(0.26,2.91) ‐0.01(‐0.12,0.10)
LD ETN SC + MTX   1.65(0.51,5.30) 1.56(0.55,4.24) 0.05(‐0.06,0.21)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.73(0.15,3.38) 0.75(0.18,2.98) ‐0.02(‐0.13,0.11)
HD TOCI IV   3.97(0.79,21.11) 3.13(0.81,10.30) 0.18(‐0.02,0.52)
HD GOLI SC   2.63(0.51,13.94) 2.30(0.55,8.37) 0.11(‐0.06,0.41)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   7.26(1.70,35.12) 4.66(1.54,13.53) 0.31(0.07,0.62)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   5.29(1.38,21.36) 3.84(1.31,10.96) 0.24(0.04,0.50)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.95(0.50,7.90) 1.80(0.54,5.80) 0.07(‐0.06,0.27)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   6.14(1.05,42.98) 4.19(1.05,13.49) 0.27(0.01,0.68)
SD GOLI IV SD ADA SC 1.16(0.12,10.30) 1.15(0.15,8.96) 0.01(‐0.22,0.15)
SD GOLI SC   2.93(0.15,54.59) 2.56(0.19,26.46) 0.09(‐0.17,0.57)
SD ETN SC + MTX   2.61(0.34,18.74) 2.38(0.42,15.27) 0.08(‐0.16,0.22)
SD ABA IV + MTX   3.86(0.53,27.42) 3.29(0.61,20.65) 0.13(‐0.10,0.29)
SD ABA SC + MTX   2.85(0.34,21.22) 2.55(0.41,16.70) 0.09(‐0.15,0.26)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   8.70(1.00,72.73) 5.85(1.00,37.81) 0.28(0.00,0.56)
SD ADA SC + MTX   3.21(0.42,24.69) 2.81(0.50,19.01) 0.10(‐0.13,0.28)
SD INF IV + MTX   1.85(0.23,14.89) 1.75(0.28,12.48) 0.04(‐0.19,0.19)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   2.95(0.36,24.01) 2.63(0.43,18.22) 0.09(‐0.14,0.29)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   2.65(0.31,21.24) 2.41(0.38,16.56) 0.08(‐0.16,0.26)
SD CERTO + MTX   9.30(0.48,342.30) 5.75(0.54,50.05) 0.28(‐0.08,0.87)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   3.54(0.30,45.36) 3.02(0.36,26.00) 0.11(‐0.14,0.50)
LD GOLI IV   1.78(0.20,16.52) 1.69(0.25,13.47) 0.04(‐0.19,0.23)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   1.22(0.15,9.80) 1.21(0.19,8.76) 0.01(‐0.21,0.13)
LD ETN SC + MTX   2.42(0.28,19.81) 2.22(0.34,15.66) 0.07(‐0.17,0.26)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   1.07(0.11,9.71) 1.06(0.14,8.49) 0.00(‐0.22,0.14)
HD TOCI IV   5.76(1.72,19.49) 4.34(1.48,14.65) 0.19(0.05,0.42)
HD GOLI SC   3.83(0.39,38.62) 3.22(0.45,25.05) 0.12(‐0.12,0.43)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   10.55(2.48,49.64) 6.46(1.81,28.75) 0.32(0.13,0.57)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   7.76(0.92,64.05) 5.42(0.94,35.92) 0.26(‐0.01,0.53)
HD INF IV + MTX   2.84(0.34,23.63) 2.53(0.41,17.70) 0.09(‐0.15,0.29)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   9.03(0.76,112.30) 5.86(0.81,42.45) 0.29(‐0.04,0.70)
SD GOLI SC SD GOLI IV 2.54(0.19,35.63) 2.26(0.21,15.81) 0.08(‐0.11,0.57)
SD ETN SC + MTX   2.25(0.52,9.72) 2.06(0.57,7.98) 0.07(‐0.08,0.20)
SD ABA IV + MTX   3.33(0.79,14.04) 2.86(0.82,10.67) 0.12(‐0.03,0.27)
SD ABA SC + MTX   2.45(0.50,11.43) 2.22(0.55,8.97) 0.08(‐0.08,0.25)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   7.47(1.48,40.23) 5.10(1.36,19.75) 0.28(0.06,0.55)
SD ADA SC + MTX   2.77(0.62,12.74) 2.45(0.67,9.74) 0.10(‐0.06,0.27)
SD INF IV + MTX   1.59(0.33,7.86) 1.53(0.38,6.60) 0.03(‐0.11,0.18)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   2.55(0.78,8.64) 2.29(0.80,6.92) 0.08(‐0.03,0.24)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   2.31(0.47,11.30) 2.10(0.52,8.80) 0.07(‐0.08,0.25)
SD CERTO + MTX   7.77(0.58,252.40) 5.09(0.62,27.52) 0.28(‐0.05,0.86)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   3.07(0.41,26.15) 2.64(0.45,14.11) 0.11(‐0.08,0.49)
LD GOLI IV   1.55(0.43,5.55) 1.49(0.46,4.72) 0.03(‐0.07,0.18)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   1.06(0.22,5.21) 1.06(0.25,4.64) 0.00(‐0.13,0.12)
LD ETN SC + MTX   2.09(0.40,10.76) 1.93(0.44,8.34) 0.06(‐0.09,0.24)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.92(0.25,3.40) 0.92(0.27,3.10) 0.00(‐0.11,0.10)
HD TOCI IV   5.02(0.80,33.52) 3.86(0.83,17.14) 0.19(‐0.02,0.53)
HD GOLI SC   3.28(0.50,22.95) 2.80(0.55,13.84) 0.12(‐0.07,0.43)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   9.19(1.68,56.26) 5.76(1.51,22.84) 0.32(0.07,0.64)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   6.66(1.27,35.02) 4.72(1.22,18.47) 0.25(0.03,0.51)
HD INF IV + MTX   2.44(0.48,13.07) 2.21(0.53,9.75) 0.08(‐0.08,0.29)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   7.78(1.07,64.92) 5.12(1.06,22.12) 0.28(0.01,0.69)
SD ETN SC + MTX SD GOLI SC 0.89(0.08,10.10) 0.90(0.18,8.44) ‐0.01(‐0.50,0.18)
SD ABA IV + MTX   1.31(0.12,14.37) 1.24(0.26,11.15) 0.04(‐0.45,0.25)
SD ABA SC + MTX   0.96(0.08,11.17) 0.96(0.18,9.10) ‐0.01(‐0.50,0.22)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   2.96(0.34,25.94) 2.21(0.56,16.14) 0.18(‐0.24,0.44)
SD ADA SC + MTX   1.10(0.10,12.89) 1.08(0.21,10.13) 0.01(‐0.48,0.24)
SD INF IV + MTX   0.63(0.05,7.62) 0.67(0.12,6.55) ‐0.05(‐0.53,0.15)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   1.01(0.08,12.47) 1.01(0.18,9.79) 0.00(‐0.49,0.24)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   0.91(0.08,11.45) 0.93(0.17,9.11) ‐0.01(‐0.49,0.22)
SD CERTO + MTX   3.11(0.13,171.40) 2.18(0.22,26.61) 0.18(‐0.38,0.82)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.21(0.08,21.40) 1.16(0.15,13.28) 0.02(‐0.47,0.42)
LD GOLI IV   0.61(0.05,8.20) 0.66(0.10,6.84) ‐0.05(‐0.54,0.18)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.42(0.03,5.11) 0.46(0.08,4.64) ‐0.08(‐0.57,0.10)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.83(0.07,10.66) 0.85(0.15,8.61) ‐0.02(‐0.51,0.21)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.37(0.03,4.99) 0.41(0.06,4.46) ‐0.09(‐0.57,0.10)
HD TOCI IV   1.99(0.14,28.76) 1.69(0.26,16.67) 0.10(‐0.41,0.48)
HD GOLI SC   1.30(0.22,8.06) 1.23(0.37,6.71) 0.03(‐0.32,0.24)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.67(0.27,50.42) 2.51(0.48,23.04) 0.23(‐0.29,0.59)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.62(0.31,23.79) 2.05(0.52,15.43) 0.15(‐0.27,0.42)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.98(0.08,12.35) 0.98(0.17,9.59) 0.00(‐0.49,0.25)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.07(0.20,54.35) 2.23(0.36,21.96) 0.18(‐0.34,0.63)
SD ABA IV + MTX SD ETN SC + MTX 1.48(0.53,4.24) 1.38(0.59,3.35) 0.05(‐0.09,0.21)
SD ABA SC + MTX   1.09(0.31,3.61) 1.08(0.37,2.92) 0.01(‐0.14,0.18)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   3.32(0.91,12.57) 2.48(0.93,6.26) 0.21(‐0.01,0.48)
SD ADA SC + MTX   1.23(0.40,3.93) 1.19(0.46,3.09) 0.03(‐0.12,0.20)
SD INF IV + MTX   0.71(0.21,2.48) 0.74(0.25,2.17) ‐0.04(‐0.17,0.11)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   1.13(0.32,4.15) 1.11(0.38,3.22) 0.02(‐0.14,0.21)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   1.02(0.29,3.55) 1.02(0.35,2.89) 0.00(‐0.15,0.18)
SD CERTO + MTX   3.40(0.32,96.36) 2.50(0.37,9.56) 0.21(‐0.12,0.80)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.35(0.24,9.23) 1.28(0.28,4.96) 0.04(‐0.15,0.42)
LD GOLI IV   0.69(0.16,2.98) 0.73(0.19,2.49) ‐0.04(‐0.18,0.15)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.47(0.14,1.68) 0.51(0.17,1.58) ‐0.07(‐0.20,0.05)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.92(0.32,2.70) 0.94(0.37,2.26) ‐0.01(‐0.13,0.15)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.41(0.09,1.76) 0.45(0.11,1.64) ‐0.07(‐0.21,0.06)
HD TOCI IV   2.21(0.46,11.41) 1.88(0.52,5.73) 0.12(‐0.10,0.47)
HD GOLI SC   1.47(0.30,7.52) 1.38(0.35,4.55) 0.05(‐0.14,0.36)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   4.06(1.01,18.90) 2.80(1.01,7.22) 0.25(0.00,0.57)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.97(0.82,11.42) 2.30(0.85,6.00) 0.18(‐0.03,0.45)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.09(0.30,4.14) 1.08(0.35,3.17) 0.01(‐0.14,0.22)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.44(0.61,23.13) 2.52(0.66,7.40) 0.22(‐0.06,0.62)
SD ABA SC + MTX SD ABA IV + MTX 0.74(0.29,1.75) 0.78(0.35,1.55) ‐0.04(‐0.17,0.09)
SD GOLI SC + MTX   2.25(0.64,8.15) 1.80(0.71,4.15) 0.15(‐0.08,0.44)
SD ADA SC + MTX   0.83(0.33,2.17) 0.86(0.40,1.83) ‐0.03(‐0.16,0.13)
SD INF IV + MTX   0.48(0.15,1.60) 0.53(0.19,1.48) ‐0.09(‐0.24,0.07)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   0.77(0.22,2.72) 0.81(0.29,2.19) ‐0.04(‐0.20,0.17)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   0.69(0.21,2.32) 0.74(0.26,1.95) ‐0.05(‐0.21,0.14)
SD CERTO + MTX   2.30(0.22,64.08) 1.81(0.27,6.40) 0.16(‐0.19,0.75)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   0.91(0.17,6.04) 0.92(0.21,3.36) ‐0.01(‐0.21,0.37)
LD GOLI IV   0.46(0.11,1.93) 0.52(0.15,1.70) ‐0.09(‐0.25,0.10)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.32(0.10,1.08) 0.37(0.13,1.07) ‐0.12(‐0.27,0.01)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.63(0.17,2.23) 0.68(0.22,1.89) ‐0.06(‐0.22,0.13)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.27(0.06,1.16) 0.32(0.09,1.14) ‐0.13(‐0.27,0.02)
HD TOCI IV   1.49(0.32,7.39) 1.36(0.39,3.84) 0.07(‐0.16,0.42)
HD GOLI SC   0.99(0.21,4.87) 0.99(0.26,3.09) 0.00(‐0.20,0.31)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   2.75(0.71,11.99) 2.03(0.77,4.78) 0.20(‐0.06,0.53)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.02(0.55,7.41) 1.67(0.63,4.00) 0.13(‐0.10,0.41)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.74(0.22,2.50) 0.78(0.28,2.02) ‐0.04(‐0.20,0.16)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   2.31(0.43,15.08) 1.82(0.50,4.87) 0.16(‐0.12,0.57)
SD GOLI SC + MTX SD ABA SC + MTX 3.08(0.76,13.00) 2.32(0.81,6.60) 0.20(‐0.05,0.48)
SD ADA SC + MTX   1.13(0.36,3.92) 1.10(0.43,3.12) 0.02(‐0.15,0.19)
SD INF IV + MTX   0.65(0.18,2.58) 0.69(0.22,2.27) ‐0.05(‐0.22,0.11)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   1.04(0.27,4.32) 1.03(0.33,3.37) 0.01(‐0.18,0.21)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   0.93(0.25,3.73) 0.94(0.31,3.04) ‐0.01(‐0.19,0.18)
SD CERTO + MTX   3.14(0.27,91.33) 2.32(0.33,9.80) 0.20(‐0.15,0.79)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.24(0.21,9.08) 1.19(0.26,5.02) 0.03(‐0.18,0.41)
LD GOLI IV   0.63(0.14,3.03) 0.67(0.18,2.55) ‐0.05(‐0.22,0.15)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.43(0.12,1.76) 0.47(0.15,1.65) ‐0.08(‐0.24,0.06)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.85(0.21,3.58) 0.87(0.26,2.88) ‐0.02(‐0.20,0.18)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.37(0.08,1.84) 0.42(0.10,1.70) ‐0.09(‐0.25,0.06)
HD TOCI IV   2.03(0.39,11.76) 1.74(0.46,5.96) 0.11(‐0.13,0.46)
HD GOLI SC   1.35(0.26,7.64) 1.28(0.31,4.78) 0.04(‐0.17,0.36)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.75(0.85,19.24) 2.60(0.89,7.76) 0.24(‐0.03,0.57)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.75(0.68,11.78) 2.15(0.74,6.29) 0.17(‐0.07,0.45)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.00(0.26,4.19) 1.00(0.32,3.25) 0.00(‐0.18,0.21)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.16(0.54,22.86) 2.33(0.61,7.65) 0.20(‐0.09,0.62)
SD ADA SC + MTX SD GOLI SC + MTX 0.37(0.09,1.49) 0.48(0.19,1.35) ‐0.18(‐0.46,0.07)
SD INF IV + MTX   0.21(0.05,0.90) 0.30(0.10,0.92) ‐0.24(‐0.52,‐0.02)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   0.34(0.08,1.49) 0.45(0.15,1.34) ‐0.19(‐0.47,0.07)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   0.31(0.07,1.31) 0.41(0.14,1.22) ‐0.20(‐0.48,0.05)
SD CERTO + MTX   1.03(0.08,31.79) 1.02(0.15,3.86) 0.01(‐0.43,0.64)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   0.41(0.06,3.16) 0.52(0.11,2.04) ‐0.16(‐0.48,0.26)
LD GOLI IV   0.21(0.04,1.04) 0.29(0.08,1.03) ‐0.24(‐0.52,0.01)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.14(0.03,0.61) 0.21(0.07,0.67) ‐0.27(‐0.54,‐0.07)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.28(0.06,1.23) 0.38(0.12,1.17) ‐0.21(‐0.49,0.04)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.12(0.02,0.63) 0.18(0.05,0.70) ‐0.28(‐0.55,‐0.06)
HD TOCI IV   0.66(0.11,3.95) 0.76(0.21,2.34) ‐0.08(‐0.42,0.31)
HD GOLI SC   0.44(0.13,1.52) 0.56(0.20,1.31) ‐0.15(‐0.37,0.09)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   1.23(0.24,6.60) 1.13(0.41,2.97) 0.05(‐0.31,0.42)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   0.89(0.41,1.99) 0.93(0.55,1.57) ‐0.02(‐0.20,0.15)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.33(0.07,1.53) 0.43(0.14,1.36) ‐0.19(‐0.47,0.08)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   1.04(0.16,7.84) 1.03(0.27,3.02) 0.01(‐0.37,0.46)
SD INF IV + MTX SD ADA SC + MTX 0.58(0.16,2.08) 0.62(0.20,1.86) ‐0.06(‐0.24,0.09)
SD RITUX IV + MTX   0.92(0.24,3.53) 0.94(0.31,2.77) ‐0.01(‐0.20,0.19)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   0.83(0.22,3.06) 0.85(0.28,2.51) ‐0.02(‐0.21,0.16)
SD CERTO + MTX   2.75(0.25,80.90) 2.09(0.30,8.25) 0.18(‐0.17,0.78)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.09(0.18,7.62) 1.08(0.23,4.23) 0.01(‐0.21,0.40)
LD GOLI IV   0.56(0.12,2.44) 0.61(0.16,2.09) ‐0.06(‐0.24,0.13)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.38(0.10,1.41) 0.43(0.14,1.35) ‐0.09(‐0.26,0.04)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.76(0.19,2.89) 0.79(0.24,2.38) ‐0.03(‐0.22,0.15)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.33(0.07,1.50) 0.38(0.09,1.42) ‐0.10(‐0.27,0.05)
HD TOCI IV   1.80(0.35,9.44) 1.58(0.42,4.83) 0.09(‐0.15,0.44)
HD GOLI SC   1.19(0.23,6.33) 1.15(0.29,3.95) 0.02(‐0.19,0.34)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.30(0.75,15.65) 2.35(0.81,6.23) 0.23(‐0.05,0.55)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.40(0.61,9.56) 1.93(0.69,5.15) 0.15(‐0.09,0.43)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.89(0.30,2.55) 0.91(0.36,2.11) ‐0.02(‐0.15,0.15)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   2.79(0.48,18.97) 2.11(0.55,6.33) 0.19(‐0.11,0.60)
SD RITUX IV + MTX SD INF IV + MTX 1.61(0.39,6.53) 1.51(0.44,4.92) 0.05(‐0.11,0.25)
SD GOLI IV + MTX   1.45(0.36,5.50) 1.38(0.41,4.35) 0.04(‐0.12,0.22)
SD CERTO + MTX   4.83(0.41,139.90) 3.36(0.46,14.62) 0.25(‐0.09,0.83)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.90(0.30,14.52) 1.73(0.34,7.58) 0.07(‐0.12,0.46)
LD GOLI IV   0.98(0.19,4.59) 0.98(0.23,3.74) 0.00(‐0.15,0.18)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.67(0.26,1.69) 0.69(0.30,1.60) ‐0.03(‐0.13,0.05)
LD ETN SC + MTX   1.31(0.30,5.36) 1.27(0.35,4.26) 0.03(‐0.13,0.21)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.58(0.11,2.82) 0.60(0.13,2.53) ‐0.04(‐0.18,0.10)
HD TOCI IV   3.11(0.58,17.79) 2.52(0.63,8.80) 0.16(‐0.07,0.50)
HD GOLI SC   2.07(0.38,11.71) 1.84(0.43,7.08) 0.09(‐0.10,0.40)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   5.76(1.23,29.64) 3.78(1.18,11.45) 0.29(0.03,0.61)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   4.20(0.99,17.74) 3.10(0.99,9.28) 0.22(0.00,0.48)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.55(0.37,6.58) 1.46(0.42,4.93) 0.05(‐0.11,0.25)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   4.86(0.78,36.18) 3.38(0.81,11.54) 0.25(‐0.03,0.66)
SD GOLI IV + MTX SD RITUX IV + MTX 0.90(0.21,3.64) 0.91(0.28,2.98) ‐0.01(‐0.22,0.18)
SD CERTO + MTX   3.00(0.26,85.82) 2.23(0.32,9.56) 0.19(‐0.17,0.79)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.19(0.17,9.07) 1.15(0.22,5.06) 0.02(‐0.21,0.41)
LD GOLI IV   0.61(0.19,1.95) 0.65(0.23,1.76) ‐0.05(‐0.21,0.09)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.42(0.10,1.77) 0.46(0.13,1.66) ‐0.08(‐0.28,0.06)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.82(0.19,3.57) 0.84(0.24,2.91) ‐0.02(‐0.23,0.17)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.36(0.10,1.22) 0.40(0.13,1.18) ‐0.09(‐0.25,0.02)
HD TOCI IV   1.96(0.35,10.94) 1.68(0.43,5.67) 0.10(‐0.16,0.45)
HD GOLI SC   1.28(0.22,7.76) 1.23(0.29,4.76) 0.03(‐0.20,0.36)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.60(0.76,18.40) 2.51(0.81,7.46) 0.24(‐0.05,0.56)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.61(0.59,11.59) 2.06(0.67,6.26) 0.17(‐0.09,0.44)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.96(0.22,4.22) 0.97(0.28,3.26) 0.00(‐0.21,0.21)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.03(0.46,22.18) 2.25(0.54,7.62) 0.20(‐0.12,0.61)
SD CERTO + MTX SD GOLI IV + MTX 3.38(0.30,95.03) 2.47(0.35,10.37) 0.21(‐0.15,0.80)
SD TOFA PO + MTX   1.33(0.21,10.15) 1.26(0.26,5.55) 0.04(‐0.19,0.42)
LD GOLI IV   0.68(0.14,3.34) 0.71(0.17,2.77) ‐0.04(‐0.22,0.15)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.46(0.12,1.94) 0.50(0.15,1.80) ‐0.07(‐0.24,0.06)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.91(0.21,3.88) 0.92(0.26,3.14) ‐0.01(‐0.20,0.18)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.40(0.08,2.00) 0.44(0.10,1.85) ‐0.08(‐0.25,0.07)
HD TOCI IV   2.18(0.40,12.48) 1.84(0.48,6.34) 0.12(‐0.13,0.47)
HD GOLI SC   1.43(0.25,8.39) 1.34(0.32,5.14) 0.05(‐0.17,0.36)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.99(0.88,20.79) 2.74(0.91,8.32) 0.25(‐0.02,0.58)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.92(0.68,12.70) 2.27(0.74,6.77) 0.18(‐0.06,0.45)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.07(0.25,4.68) 1.06(0.31,3.59) 0.01(‐0.18,0.22)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.37(0.53,25.33) 2.47(0.60,8.31) 0.21(‐0.09,0.63)
SD TOFA PO + MTX SD CERTO + MTX 0.39(0.01,6.54) 0.53(0.08,4.31) ‐0.16(‐0.78,0.32)
LD GOLI IV   0.20(0.01,2.58) 0.29(0.06,2.25) ‐0.25(‐0.83,0.10)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.14(0.00,1.63) 0.21(0.04,1.55) ‐0.28(‐0.86,0.04)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.27(0.01,3.26) 0.38(0.08,2.75) ‐0.22(‐0.81,0.14)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.12(0.00,1.60) 0.18(0.03,1.53) ‐0.29(‐0.87,0.04)
HD TOCI IV   0.63(0.02,9.38) 0.74(0.15,5.59) ‐0.09(‐0.72,0.39)
HD GOLI SC   0.43(0.01,6.41) 0.56(0.10,4.40) ‐0.15(‐0.78,0.29)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   1.18(0.04,15.85) 1.10(0.28,7.55) 0.04(‐0.60,0.51)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   0.86(0.03,10.85) 0.91(0.23,6.33) ‐0.03(‐0.66,0.40)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.32(0.01,3.83) 0.44(0.09,3.13) ‐0.20(‐0.80,0.17)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   1.00(0.03,16.78) 1.00(0.20,7.22) 0.00(‐0.66,0.53)
LD GOLI IV SD TOFA PO + MTX 0.51(0.06,3.84) 0.57(0.11,3.26) ‐0.07(‐0.46,0.15)
LD RITUX IV + MTX   0.35(0.05,2.23) 0.40(0.09,2.08) ‐0.11(‐0.49,0.06)
LD ETN SC + MTX   0.69(0.09,4.57) 0.73(0.16,3.73) ‐0.05(‐0.43,0.18)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.30(0.03,2.31) 0.35(0.06,2.12) ‐0.11(‐0.49,0.07)
HD TOCI IV   1.63(0.17,14.23) 1.45(0.29,7.68) 0.08(‐0.34,0.46)
HD GOLI SC   1.08(0.12,9.33) 1.06(0.20,6.10) 0.01(‐0.38,0.35)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   3.03(0.35,24.24) 2.17(0.52,10.32) 0.21(‐0.23,0.57)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.18(0.29,14.76) 1.78(0.45,8.32) 0.14(‐0.27,0.45)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.81(0.10,5.60) 0.84(0.19,4.34) ‐0.03(‐0.41,0.22)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   2.54(0.77,8.35) 1.90(0.84,4.96) 0.16(‐0.05,0.42)
LD RITUX IV + MTX LD GOLI IV 0.68(0.14,3.49) 0.70(0.18,3.15) ‐0.03(‐0.21,0.10)
LD ETN SC + MTX   1.34(0.26,6.97) 1.29(0.32,5.50) 0.03(‐0.16,0.22)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.59(0.16,2.13) 0.62(0.19,1.99) ‐0.04(‐0.18,0.06)
HD TOCI IV   3.21(0.52,21.14) 2.57(0.58,10.98) 0.16(‐0.09,0.50)
HD GOLI SC   2.11(0.33,14.71) 1.88(0.39,8.95) 0.09(‐0.13,0.40)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   5.89(1.07,35.70) 3.84(1.05,14.58) 0.29(0.01,0.61)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   4.28(0.85,22.51) 3.16(0.88,12.10) 0.22(‐0.03,0.49)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.57(0.32,8.29) 1.48(0.38,6.27) 0.05(‐0.15,0.26)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   5.02(0.68,41.56) 3.45(0.73,14.51) 0.25(‐0.05,0.66)
LD ETN SC + MTX LD RITUX IV + MTX 1.97(0.45,8.35) 1.83(0.49,6.47) 0.06(‐0.07,0.24)
LD GOLI IV + MTX   0.87(0.17,4.33) 0.87(0.19,3.78) ‐0.01(‐0.12,0.12)
HD TOCI IV   4.73(0.84,27.17) 3.68(0.86,13.18) 0.19(‐0.02,0.53)
HD GOLI SC   3.09(0.56,17.99) 2.66(0.59,10.63) 0.12(‐0.05,0.42)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   8.66(1.83,45.28) 5.47(1.63,17.09) 0.32(0.08,0.64)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   6.35(1.46,27.01) 4.52(1.36,13.87) 0.25(0.05,0.51)
HD INF IV + MTX   2.32(0.54,9.92) 2.11(0.57,7.28) 0.08(‐0.06,0.28)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   7.28(1.16,54.51) 4.88(1.13,17.36) 0.28(0.02,0.69)
LD GOLI IV + MTX LD ETN SC + MTX 0.44(0.08,2.25) 0.48(0.11,2.06) ‐0.07(‐0.25,0.08)
HD TOCI IV   2.39(0.42,14.52) 2.00(0.49,7.43) 0.13(‐0.12,0.48)
HD GOLI SC   1.58(0.27,9.48) 1.46(0.33,5.95) 0.06(‐0.17,0.37)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   4.41(0.89,24.33) 2.98(0.92,9.81) 0.26(‐0.02,0.59)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   3.20(0.73,14.55) 2.45(0.79,7.88) 0.19(‐0.05,0.46)
HD INF IV + MTX   1.17(0.26,5.51) 1.15(0.32,4.19) 0.02(‐0.18,0.23)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   3.68(0.58,28.24) 2.65(0.64,9.74) 0.22(‐0.08,0.63)
HD TOCI IV LD GOLI IV + MTX 5.42(0.85,36.93) 4.15(0.87,18.80) 0.20(‐0.02,0.54)
HD GOLI SC   3.57(0.54,25.19) 3.03(0.59,15.30) 0.13(‐0.06,0.43)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   9.93(1.80,60.87) 6.18(1.59,25.14) 0.33(0.08,0.64)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   7.23(1.42,39.03) 5.08(1.33,20.87) 0.26(0.05,0.52)
HD INF IV + MTX   2.67(0.52,14.26) 2.40(0.56,10.66) 0.09(‐0.07,0.29)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   8.50(1.13,72.78) 5.57(1.11,24.42) 0.29(0.01,0.70)
HD GOLI SC HD TOCI IV 0.66(0.09,4.91) 0.73(0.17,3.28) ‐0.07(‐0.44,0.29)
HD TOCI IV + MTX   1.83(0.81,4.61) 1.46(0.88,3.04) 0.12(‐0.05,0.31)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   1.35(0.23,7.71) 1.23(0.39,4.44) 0.06(‐0.33,0.39)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.49(0.08,2.84) 0.58(0.16,2.31) ‐0.11(‐0.46,0.16)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   1.55(0.18,14.57) 1.33(0.31,5.42) 0.09(‐0.35,0.55)
HD TOCI IV + MTX HD GOLI SC 2.78(0.43,18.85) 2.03(0.57,8.00) 0.20(‐0.18,0.55)
HD GOLI SC + MTX   2.00(0.60,7.01) 1.65(0.71,4.74) 0.12(‐0.11,0.34)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.74(0.12,4.36) 0.79(0.20,3.43) ‐0.04(‐0.36,0.20)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   2.37(0.29,21.00) 1.83(0.41,7.89) 0.16(‐0.23,0.59)
HD GOLI SC + MTX HD TOCI IV + MTX 0.73(0.13,3.62) 0.82(0.30,2.30) ‐0.07(‐0.44,0.28)
HD INF IV + MTX   0.27(0.05,1.32) 0.39(0.12,1.22) ‐0.24(‐0.57,0.05)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   0.84(0.10,7.14) 0.90(0.23,2.86) ‐0.04(‐0.47,0.44)
HD INF IV + MTX HD GOLI SC + MTX 0.37(0.08,1.66) 0.47(0.15,1.46) ‐0.17(‐0.45,0.09)
HD TOFA PO + MTX   1.16(0.18,8.74) 1.10(0.29,3.31) 0.03(‐0.34,0.48)
HD TOFA PO + MTX HD INF IV + MTX 3.12(0.48,24.05) 2.31(0.56,8.31) 0.20(‐0.11,0.62)
Random‐effects model Residual deviance 75.74 vs 74 data points    
  Deviance information criteria 478.266    
Fixed‐effect model Residual deviance 113.5 vs 74 data points    
  Deviance information criteria 504.534    
Note        
Total participants 13,479      
Total studies 29      
2‐arm 16      
3‐arm 11      
4‐arm 1      
5‐arm 1