Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 11;10:758. doi: 10.3389/fimmu.2019.00758

Table 2.

Assessing risk of bias and concerns regarding the applicability of diagnostic studies.

Study Risk of bias Concerns regarding applicability
Patient selection Index test Reference standard Flow and timing Patient selection Index test Reference standard
Nagral et al. (29) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Devlin et al. (17) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Feussner et al. (18) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Kuse et al. (19) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Okubo et al. (20) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Hughes et al. (21) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Lun et al. (22) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Barnes et al. (23) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Kobayashi et al. (5) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Massoud et al. (24) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Rodriguez-Peralvarez et al. (25) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Wang et al. (26) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Schütz et al. (27) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg
Dickson et al. (28) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg
Molajoni et al. (30) graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0002.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0003.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg graphic file with name fimmu-10-00758-i0001.jpg

The Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies tool (QUADAS-2) was used to appraise trustworthiness and applicability of the study findings (12). The signaling questions were carried out independently by two reviewers (F.K. and E.K.). Any discrepancy between the reviewers was resolved through discussion until a common conclusion was achieved. The analysis found that Barnes et al. (23), Nagral et al. (29), Kuse et al. (19), Lun et al. (22), Rodriguez-Peralvarez et al. (25), and Wang et al. (26) exhibited low risk.

Inline graphicInline graphicInline graphic.