Table 4.
Method | Dataset | Algorithm | AUC | |
---|---|---|---|---|
LPBNI [31] | LPI | 4870 lncRNA–protein interactions from NPInter database (2380 lncRNAs and 106 proteins) | Bipartite Network | 0.8780 |
PPI | × | |||
LLI | × | |||
Yang et al. [33] | LPI | 4883 lncRNA–protein interactions from NPInter database (1116 lncRNAs and 99 proteins) | A random walk model HeteSim | 0.7972 |
PPI | 1608 protein–protein interactions from STRING database | |||
LLI | × | |||
LPIHN [34] | LPI | 10232 lncRNA–protein interactions from NPInter database (1113 lncRNAs and 99 proteins) | Random Walk with Restart | 0.8839 |
PPI | 804 protein–protein interactions from STRING database | |||
LLI | lncRNA expression similarity from NONCODE 4.0 database (1113 lncRNA expression profiles) | |||
Zheng et al. [32] | LPI | 4467 lncRNA–protein interactions from NPInter database (1050 lncRNAs and 84 proteins) | SNF; A random walk model HeteSim | 0.9068 |
PPI | Sequence similarity from UniProt database; Functional annotation similarity from GO database; Protein domain similarity from Pfam database; STRING similarity from STRING database; |
|||
LLI | × | |||
PLPIHS [35] | LPI | lncRNA–protein interactions from GENCODE Release 24 (15941 lncRNAs and 20284 proteins) Co-expression data from COXPRESdb; Co-expression data from ArrayExpress and GEO; lncRNA–protein interactions from NPInter database; |
SVM; A random walk model HeteSim | 0.9678 |
PPI | Protein–protein interactions from STRING database | |||
LLI | lncRNA co-expression similarity from NONCODE database (lncRNA expression profiles) |
Bold representation performs best in AUC values and we found that the performance of the method is better when the heterogeneous network is composed by more sources. When heterogeneous networks are constructed by the same sources, the performance will be better for the heterogeneous networks constructed by weighted networks. 1 https://github.com/USTC-HIlab/LPBNI (offline package); 2 https://github.com/cyang235/LncADeep (offline package); 3 lncRNA–protein interactions; 4 protein–protein interactions; 5 lncRNA–lncRNA interactions; 6 A relevance search based on random walk in heterogeneous network to evaluate the relevance between a pair of lncRNA and protein, and a large relevance score means a high possibility that the lncRNA and protein interacts [94]. 7 Similarity Network Fusion: It is a nonlinear message-passing based method that iteratively updates each network and makes it more and more similar to the other [95].