Coyle 2001.
Methods | Design: cluster randomized trial; 20 schools assigned to study groups Location: southeast Texas and northern California, USA Time frame: 1993 to 1996 Sample size calculation (and outcome of focus): no information |
|
Participants | General with N: 20 public schools; 3869 students in grade 9 Inclusion criteria: school districts served diverse populations (ethnicity and socioeconomic status); areas with high HIV prevalence; close to research team Exclusion criteria: no information | |
Interventions | Study focus: prevention of HIV, STI, and pregnancy for high school youth Theory or model: Social Cognitive Theory + social influence model and models of school change
Duration: 2‐year program |
|
Outcomes | Primary: frequency of unprotected sex; condom use during last sex; use of effective contraception during last sex (i.e. condom, birth control pills, or both)
Secondary: attitudes about sex or condom use; HIV/STD knowledge; beliefs; self efficacy; barriers to condom use; HIV/STD risk perceptions Follow‐up: 7 months, i.e. after year 1 lessons (9th grade); 19 months, i.e. after year 2 lessons (10th grade); 31 months, i.e. 12 months after year 2 lessons |
|
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Restricted randomization process to assign schools: schools ranked on index of possible confounders, and adjacent schools in ranking paired and randomly assigned to intervention or control |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Schools identified prior to randomization. All students in identified grades were eligible. |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | High risk | Presume no blinding of participants or providers; not feasible due to type of intervention |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) | High risk | No mention |
Outcome measures | High risk | Contraceptive use from self‐report |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | High risk | Loss to follow‐up: 19 months, 17% (immediately after year 2); 31 months, 21% (12 months after year 2) Exclusions after randomization: 346 students left year 1 and did not enroll in Fall year 2; 95 took baseline survey but were grade 11 or 12 |
Other bias | Unclear risk | Analysis for cluster randomized trial: multilevel models (levels measurement occasion, student, and school); predictor variables, i.e. baseline responses on outcomes, intervention group, geographic area, and "outcome specific covariates" (related to outcome and intervention; unspecified) |