1. Cycle characteristics of included trials.
Study ID | Population | Previous HSG or hysteroscopy | Intervention | Additional endometrial biopsy | Detected abnormalities treated | Timing of hysteroscopy |
Seyam 2015 | Unexplained infertility of 2 years duration | Normal HSG | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes | Follicular phase |
Aghahosseini 2012 | Two or more IVF failures | Normal HSG; no hysteroscopy in previous 2 months | Hysteroscopy | No | No details | No details available |
Alleyassin 2017 | First IVF | Normal HSG; women with history of hysteroscopy excluded. | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes | Preceding cycle; luteal phase |
Demirol 2004 | Two or more IVF failures | Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes | Preceding cycle; follicular phase |
El‐Nashar 2011 | Unselected IVF population | No details of HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | Yes | Yes | No details |
Elsetohy 2015 | First IVF | Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes | Within 3 months of IVF; follicular phase |
El‐Toukhy 2016 | Two or more IVF failures | Hysteroscopy done within two months were excluded; Included women with previous history of hysteroscopy (45% in hysteroscopy group vs 44% in control) | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes; (only one partial septum not treated). |
Preceding cycle; follicular phase |
Juul Hare 2018 | One IVF failure | No details available | Hysteroscopy | Yes | No details available | No details available |
Rama Raju 2006 | Two or more IVF failures | Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | Yes | Yes | Preceding cycle; follicular phase |
Shawki 2012 | Unselected IVF population | Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | Those with suspicious lesion after injecting methylene blue were biopsied. | Yes | No details available |
Smit 2016 | First IVF | Excluded those with previous hysteroscopy | Hysteroscopy | No | Yes; (31/43 abnormalities treated; 5 septum and 2 submucous fibroids not treated) | 1 to 3 months before IVF; follicular phase |
IVF: in vitro fertilisation
HSG: hysterosalpingography