Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 16;2019(4):CD012856. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012856.pub2

1. Cycle characteristics of included trials.

Study ID Population Previous HSG or hysteroscopy Intervention Additional endometrial biopsy Detected abnormalities treated Timing of hysteroscopy
Seyam 2015 Unexplained infertility of 2 years duration Normal HSG Hysteroscopy No Yes Follicular phase
Aghahosseini 2012 Two or more IVF failures Normal HSG; no hysteroscopy in previous 2 months Hysteroscopy No No details No details available
Alleyassin 2017 First IVF Normal HSG; women with history of hysteroscopy excluded. Hysteroscopy No Yes Preceding cycle; luteal phase
Demirol 2004 Two or more IVF failures Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy No Yes Preceding cycle; follicular phase
El‐Nashar 2011 Unselected IVF population No details of HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy Yes Yes No details
Elsetohy 2015 First IVF Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy No Yes Within 3 months of IVF; follicular phase
El‐Toukhy 2016 Two or more IVF failures Hysteroscopy done within two months were excluded; Included women with previous history of hysteroscopy (45% in hysteroscopy group vs 44% in control) Hysteroscopy No Yes;
(only one partial
septum not
treated).
Preceding cycle;
follicular phase
Juul Hare 2018 One IVF failure No details available Hysteroscopy Yes No details available No details available
Rama Raju 2006 Two or more IVF failures Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy Yes Yes Preceding cycle; follicular phase
Shawki 2012 Unselected IVF population Normal HSG; no details of history of hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy Those with suspicious lesion after injecting methylene blue were biopsied. Yes No details available
Smit 2016 First IVF Excluded those with previous hysteroscopy Hysteroscopy No Yes; (31/43 abnormalities treated; 5 septum and 2 submucous fibroids not treated) 1 to 3 months before IVF; follicular phase

IVF: in vitro fertilisation

HSG: hysterosalpingography