Skip to main content
. 2016 Nov 29;2016(11):CD012436. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012436
Trial Intervention(s) and comparator(s) Duration of intervention
 (duration of follow‐up) Description of participants Trial period
 (year to year) Country Setting Ethnic groups
 (%) Duration of obesity
 (mean years (SD))
Atabek 2008 I: metformin + diet and physical activity advice 6 months (6 months) Obese adolescents with hyperinsulinaemia Turkey Hospital in/outpatient clinic/other based in University School of Medicine
C: placebo + diet and physical activity advice
Berkowitz 2003 I: behavioural programme + sibutramine 6 months (6 months) Obese adolescent boys and postmenarchal girls March 1999 to August 2002 USA University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine White 49, black 49, other 2
C: behavioural programme + placebo White 62, black 33, other 5
Berkowitz 2006 I: behavioural therapy programme + sibutramine 12 months (12 months) Obese adolescents July 2000 to February 2002 USA 33 weight loss clinics and outpatient clinic based in a University School of Medicine White 56, African‐American 22, Hispanic or Mexican American 16, other 6
C: behavioural therapy programme + placebo White 59, African‐American 19, Hispanic or Mexican‐American 14, other 9
Chanoine 2005 I: orlistat + diet + exercise + behavioural therapy 54 weeks (54 weeks) Obese adolescents August 2000 to October 2002 USA and Canada 32 clinical centres White 75, black 19, other 6
C: placebo + diet + exercise + behavioural therapy White 78, black 14, other 8
Clarson 2009 I: metformin + lifestyle intervention 6 months (6 months) Obese adolescents with insulin resistance Enrolled 2005 to 2007 Canada Participants assessed in community clinic and there were monthly visits to clinic during intervention. Intervention carried out in community ‐ at adolescent's home ‐ unclear where group sessions took place
C: lifestyle intervention only
Franco 2014 I: sibutramine + dietary guidance 6 months (6 months) Obese adolescents Brazil Paediatric endocrinology outpatient clinic in childhood obesity group of the Instituto da Crianca do Hospital das Clinicas de Faculdade de Medicina de Universidade de Sao Paulo
C: placebo + dietary guidance
Freemark 2001 I: metformin 6 months (6 months) Obese adolescents with fasting hyperinsulinaemia and a family history of type 2 diabetes USA Inpatient and outpatient clinic of a university White 64, black 36
C: placebo White 47, black 53
Garcia‐Morales 2006 I: sibutramine + diet + exercise 6 months (6 months) Obese Mexican adolescents August 2001 to August 2003 Mexico Outpatients attending the endocrinology department of the Federico Gomez Children's Hospital of Mexico
C: placebo + diet + exercise
Godoy‐Matos 2005 I: sibutramine + hypocaloric diet + exercise 7 months (7 months) Obese adolescents January 2002 to April 2003 Brazil Regular clinical setting
C: placebo + hypocaloric diet + exercise
Kendall 2013 I: metformin + healthy lifestyle advice 6 months (6 months) Obese children and adolescents with hyperinsulinaemia or impaired fasting glucose or impaired glucose tolerance (or both) UK UK paediatric endocrine centres White 80, Asian 19, Afro‐Caribbean 11
C: placebo + healthy lifestyle advice White 72, Asian 26, Afro‐Caribbean 1
Maahs 2006 I: orlistat + diet and exercise therapy 26 weeks (26 weeks) Obese adolescents December 2002 to September 2003 USA General clinical research centre at University of New Mexico Hospital Hispanic 60
C: placebo + diet and exercise therapy Hispanic 65
Mauras 2012 I: metformin + diet/exercise intervention 6 months (6 months) Obese children with normal glucose tolerance but elevated hsCRP or fibrinogen concentrations (or both) USA White 51, African‐American 37, other 11 Uncomplicated (exogenous) obesity for < 5 years
C: diet/exercise intervention White 39, African‐American 42, other 19
NCT00001723 I: orlistat + behavioural weight loss programme 6 months (6 months) Obese children and adolescents with obesity‐related diseases RCT began in 1999 and ended in 2008 USA National Institutes of Health Clinical Center Non‐Hispanic black 63,
non‐Hispanic white 37
C: placebo + behavioural weight loss programme Non‐Hispanic black 60,
non‐Hispanic whites 40
Ozkan 2004 I: conventional treatment + orlistat Intervention group was followed for 5 to 15 months (mean duration of treatment 11.7, SD 3.7 months) Adolescents with severe exogenous obesity Turkey Outpatient clinic
C: conventional treatment Control group was followed for 6 to 17 months (mean 10.2, SD 3.7 months)
Prado 2012 I: metformin + nutritional guide and exercise programme 3 months (6 months) Obese female adolescents at risk of developing type 2 diabetes June 2009 to July 2010 Chile Conducted at Center of Adolescent Health Serjoven
C: placebo + nutritional guide and exercise programme
Rezvanian 2010 I1: metformin + healthy eating and physical activity advice 12 weeks (24 weeks) Obese children and adolescents Iran Pediatric Obesity and Metabolic Syndrome Research Clinic of the Pediatric Preventive Cardiology Department, Isfahan Cardiovascular Research Center
I2: fluoxetine + healthy eating and physical activity advice
I3: metformin and fluoxetine + healthy eating and physical activity advice
C: placebo + healthy eating and physical activity advice
Srinivasan 2006 I: metformin first then placebo + standardised information on healthy eating and exercise 6 months (12 months) Obese children and adolescents (aged 9 to 18) with suspected insulin resistance Australia Outpatient clinic of a tertiary paediatric hospital (university teaching hospital) 64% were from ethnic backgrounds with high prevalence of insulin resistance and the metabolic syndrome (e.g. Indian subcontinent, Pacific Islands), 25% were from a northern European background, and 11% were from a mixed background
C: placebo first then metformin + standardised information on healthy eating and exercise
Van Mil 2007 I: sibutramine + energy‐restricted diet and exercise plan 12 weeks (24 weeks) Obese adolescents The Netherlands Outpatient clinic
C: placebo + energy‐restricted diet and exercise plan
Wiegand 2010 I: metformin + multiprofessional lifestyle intervention 6 months (6 months) Obese insulin‐resistant adolescents May 2006 to December 2006 Germany and Switzerland Paediatric obesity centre White 87, other 13
C: placebo + multiprofessional lifestyle intervention White 92, other 9
Wilson 2010 I: metformin + lifestyle intervention programme 52 weeks (100 weeks) Obese adolescents October 2003 to August 2007 USA 6 Glaser paediatric research centres White 56, African‐American 21, Asian 8, other 15, Hispanic ethnicity 18
C: placebo + lifestyle intervention programme White 71, African‐American 16, Asian 0, other 13, Hispanic ethnicity 29
Yanovski 2011 I: metformin + dietitian‐administered weight‐reduction programme 6 months (12 months) Obese insulin‐resistant children September 2000 to August 2008 USA Trial took place at the NIH clinical research centre Non‐Hispanic white 42, Non‐Hispanic black 42, Hispanic white 11, other 5
C: placebo + dietitian‐administered weight‐reduction programme Non‐Hispanic white 49, Non‐Hispanic black 38, Hispanic white 11, other 2
"‐" denotes not reported.
C: comparator; hsCRP: high sensitivity C‐reactive protein; I: intervention; RCT: randomised controlled trial; SD: standard deviation.