Skip to main content
. 2017 Mar 13;2017(3):CD012286. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012286.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Andres Jacome 2003 Not an RCT
Azouz 2015 Cross‐over study performed during 1 clinic visit. Participants used 2 different inhaler types in a randomised order before and after normal, and then enhanced training with the IN‐CHECK device. Before‐and‐after data presented only
Basheti 2005a Intervention delivered to pharmacists; focus was pharmacists' knowledge rather than participant outcomes
Bosnic‐Anticevich 2010 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data presented
Compton 2000 Healthy participants
Eakin 2015 Preliminary observational findings from a complex educational intervention. Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Epstein 2001 Not an RCT
Eriksson 1980 Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes
Fornell 2014 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Garcia‐Cardenas 2013 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Grover 2016 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Hesselink 2004 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data presented
Hodges 1981 Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes
Horner 2008 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Jolly 2012 Not stated that participants had asthma; likely mixed population with asthma and COPD judging by age and sex of participants
Jolly 2015 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data
Kritikos 2007 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Lee 2010 Not an RCT
McElnay 1989 Randomised portion of trial involved healthy volunteers
Mulloy 1996 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
NCT01426581 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data
NCT01456494 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data
NCT01641211 Subanalysis of a larger trial investigating a multi‐faceted intervention to improve asthma management in older adults. Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
NCT02046759 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
NCT02307669 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
NCT02363192 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
NCT02715219 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Pedersen 1983 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Poureslami 2016 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Rachelefsky 1986 Cross‐over study of spacer drug delivery
Reiser 1986 Cross‐over study primarily assessing impact of spacer delivery on lung function
Sandos Dde 2010 Not an RCT
Schacer 2005 Control group but no mention of random allocation
Tuazon 2002 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique
Verver 1996 Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data
WIlliams 1983 Not an RCT ‐ children used as their own controls
Wong 1995 Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes
Yoon 1993 Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique

COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RCT: randomised controlled trial.