Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Andres Jacome 2003 | Not an RCT |
Azouz 2015 | Cross‐over study performed during 1 clinic visit. Participants used 2 different inhaler types in a randomised order before and after normal, and then enhanced training with the IN‐CHECK device. Before‐and‐after data presented only |
Basheti 2005a | Intervention delivered to pharmacists; focus was pharmacists' knowledge rather than participant outcomes |
Bosnic‐Anticevich 2010 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data presented |
Compton 2000 | Healthy participants |
Eakin 2015 | Preliminary observational findings from a complex educational intervention. Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Epstein 2001 | Not an RCT |
Eriksson 1980 | Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes |
Fornell 2014 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Garcia‐Cardenas 2013 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Grover 2016 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Hesselink 2004 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data presented |
Hodges 1981 | Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes |
Horner 2008 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Jolly 2012 | Not stated that participants had asthma; likely mixed population with asthma and COPD judging by age and sex of participants |
Jolly 2015 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data |
Kritikos 2007 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Lee 2010 | Not an RCT |
McElnay 1989 | Randomised portion of trial involved healthy volunteers |
Mulloy 1996 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
NCT01426581 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data |
NCT01456494 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data |
NCT01641211 | Subanalysis of a larger trial investigating a multi‐faceted intervention to improve asthma management in older adults. Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
NCT02046759 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
NCT02307669 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
NCT02363192 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
NCT02715219 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Pedersen 1983 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Poureslami 2016 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Rachelefsky 1986 | Cross‐over study of spacer drug delivery |
Reiser 1986 | Cross‐over study primarily assessing impact of spacer delivery on lung function |
Sandos Dde 2010 | Not an RCT |
Schacer 2005 | Control group but no mention of random allocation |
Tuazon 2002 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
Verver 1996 | Mixed population with asthma and COPD; no disaggregated data |
WIlliams 1983 | Not an RCT ‐ children used as their own controls |
Wong 1995 | Trial of impact of spacer delivery on bronchodilatation outcomes |
Yoon 1993 | Primary focus of intervention not inhaler technique |
COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; RCT: randomised controlled trial.