Table.
Society or group | Risk categories for Barrett’s esophagus | Recommendations for screening | Recommendations against screening | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| |||||||
Age | Sex | Race | Morphologic features | Clinical history | |||
American Gastroenterological Association (2011)6 | ≥ 50 years | Male | Caucasian | Elevated BMI; intra-abdominal distribution of body fat | Chronic GERD Hiatus hernia |
Patients with multiple risk factors | General population with GERD without risk factors |
American College of Physicians (2012)7 | > 50 years | Male | NA | Elevated BMI Intra-abdominal distribution of fat | Nocturnal reflux symptoms Hiatus hernia Tobacco use |
Men > 50 years with > 5 years of GERD symptoms and additional risk factors (nocturnal reflux symptoms, hiatal hernia, elevated BMI, tobacco use, and intra-abdominal distribution of fat) | Routine screening in women, regardless of GERD symptoms |
British Society of Gastroenterology (2014)8 | ≥ 50 years | Male | Caucasian | Obesity | Chronic GERD | Chronic GERD symptoms and at least 3 risk factors Threshold of multiple risk factors should be lowered in the presence of family history (at least one first-degree relative with BE or EAC). |
Unselected population with GERD symptoms without risk factors |
American College of Gastroenterology (2016)9 | > 50 years | Male | Caucasian | Central obesity (waist circumference > 88 cm, waist to hip ratio > 0.8) | > 5 years of GERD symptoms and/or frequent (weekly or more) symptoms Current or past smoking history Family history (confirmed family history of BE or EAC in a first-degree relative) |
Men with > 5 years of GERD symptoms (heartburn or acid regurgitation) and/or frequent (weekly or more) symptoms, and 2 or more risk factors for BE or EAC | General population screening without risk factors Screening in females |
Cancer Council Australia (2015)10 | Increasing age | Male | NA | Central obesity | Waist-hip ratio Central adiposity Smoking history Family history of EAC and/or BE |
Clinical evaluation of future risk of BE should consider age, sex, GERD history, waist-hip ratio, other features of central adiposity, smoking history, and family history of EAC and/or BE. | General population screening, even if conducted coincident with colonoscopy screening, is not cost-effective. |
Asia-Pacific Expert Consensus (2016)11 | Older age | Male | Caucasian | NA | Long duration of reflux symptoms, Abdominal obesity, smoking |
NA | 94.7% agreement that there is no value for screening for BE in the Asia-Pacific region due to low prevalence and lack of benefit |
Asociacion Mexicana de Gastroenterologia (2016)12 | > 50 years | Male | NA | Obese or overweight | GERD symptoms > 5 years Hiatus hernia Smoking |
Intentional search for BE is justified in subjects with various risk factors: men > 50 years, a history of GERD symptoms > 5 years, especially if the patient is obese or overweight. | GERD symptoms alone (not sufficient justification for screening) |
BMI, body mass index; GERD, Gastroesophageal reflux disease; NA, not applicable; BE, Barrett’s esophagus; EAC, esophageal adenocarcinoma.