Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 17;7:e6536. doi: 10.7717/peerj.6536

Table 2. Overall ranking of the candidate reference genes in eight groups by ΔCt method, BestKeeper, NormFinder, geNorm, and RefFinder.

Method 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in different organs of cucumber plants (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT TIP41 CACS 40SRPS8 TUA PP2A CYP UBC RPL36Aa ACT ARF LEA26 F-Box
BestKeeper CACS TIP41 40SRPS8 PP2A TUA RPL36Aa CYP ARF F-Box ACT LEA26 UBC
Normfinder TIP41 CACS 40SRPS8 PP2A TUA CYP ARF RPL36Aa UBC ACT LEA26 F-Box
geNorm TIP41 — 40SRPS8 CACS TUA PP2A CYP UBC ACT ARF LEA26 RPL36Aa F-Box
Recommended comprehensive ranking TIP41 CACS 40SRPS8 PP2A TUA CYP RPL36Aa ARF UBC ACT LEA26 F-Box
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in different organs of pumpkin plants (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT TIP41 PP2A UBC F-Box ARF CACS CYP ACT 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa LEA26 TUA
BestKeeper  TIP41 UBC PP2A F-Box ARF CYP ACT CACS LEA26 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa TUA
Normfinder TIP41 PP2A UBC F-Box ARF CYP ACT CACS 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa LEA26 TUA
geNorm CACS — 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa PP2A TIP41 UBC ACT CYP F-Box ARF LEA26 TUA
Recommended comprehensive ranking TIP41 PP2A UBC CACS F-Box 40SRPS8 ARF CYP ACT RPL36Aa LEA26 TUA
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in different organs of cucumber/pumpkin grafted plants (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT CACS 40SRPS8 ARF CYP TUA RPL36Aa UBC TIP41 LEA26 F-Box ACT PP2A
BestKeeper  CYP RPL36Aa 40SRPS8 ARF CACS LEA26 UBC TUA ACT TIP41 F-Box PP2A
Normfinder 40SRPS8 CACS ARF TUA CYP RPL36Aa TIP41 F-Box UBC LEA26 ACT PP2A
geNorm CACS — ARF 40SRPS8 CYP RPL36Aa TUA UBC LEA26 ACT TIP41 F-Box PP2A
Recommended comprehensive ranking CACS 40SRPS8 ARF CYP RPL36Aa TUA UBC LEA26 TIP41 F-Box ACT PP2A
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in graft union of cucumber/pumpkin plants under low temperature (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT TUA CACS RPL36Aa F-Box 40SRPS8 CYP ARF ACT UBC LEA26 PP2A TIP41
BestKeeper  TUA RPL36Aa CACS CYP 40SRPS8 F-Box ACT ARF UBC PP2A TIP41 LEA26
Normfinder TUA CACS RPL36Aa F-Box 40SRPS8 ARF ACT CYP UBC LEA26 PP2A TIP41
geNorm CYP — UBC 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa TUA ACT CACS F-Box ARF LEA26 PP2A TIP41
Recommended comprehensive ranking TUA RPL36Aa CACS CYP 40SRPS8 UBC F-Box ACT ARF LEA26 PP2A TIP41
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in graft union during healing process (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT LEA26 F-Box TIP41 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa ARF UBC CACS TUA ACT PP2A CYP
BestKeeper  ARF TIP41 F-Box 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa ACT LEA26 UBC CYP CACS TUA PP2A
Normfinder LEA26 F-Box 40SRPS8 TIP41 RPL36Aa ARF UBC CACS TUA ACT PP2A CYP
geNorm UBC — ARF F-Box LEA26 TIP41 RPL36Aa 40SRPS8 CACS TUA ACT PP2A CYP
Recommended comprehensive ranking LEA26 ARF F-Box TIP41 40SRPS8 UBC RPL36Aa CACS ACT TUA CYP PP2A
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in graft union of different varities of grafted plants (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT TIP41 PP2A UBC ARF 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa LEA26 CACS ACT TUA F-Box CYP
BestKeeper  TIP41 LEA26 PP2A ARF UBC RPL36Aa ACT 40SRPS8 CACS F-Box TUA CYP
Normfinder TIP41 UBC PP2A 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa ARF LEA26 ACT CACS TUA F-Box CYP
geNorm PP2A — ARF TIP41 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa UBC CACS LEA26 ACT F-Box TUA CYP
Recommended comprehensive ranking TIP41 PP2A ARF UBC 40SRPS8 LEA26 RPL36Aa CACS ACT F-Box TUA CYP
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in all samples in grafted cucumber/pumpkin plants (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT CACS 40SRPS8 LEA26 UBC ARF TUA F-Box ACT RPL36Aa TIP41 CYP PP2A
BestKeeper  CACS LEA26 40SRPS8 TUA UBC RPL36Aa ARF ACT F-Box CYP TIP41 PP2A
Normfinder CACS 40SRPS8 UBC TUA LEA26 ARF F-Box ACT RPL36Aa TIP41 CYP PP2A
geNorm ARF — 40SRPS8 CACS LEA26 TUA UBC ACT F-Box TIP41 RPL36Aa CYP PP2A
Recommended comprehensive ranking CACS 40SRPS8 LEA26 ARF UBC TUA F-Box ACT RPL36Aa TIP41 CYP PP2A
Ranking Order of candidate reference genes in all samples (Better–Good–Average)
Delta CT CACS 40SRPS8 ARF UBC TUA LEA26 F-Box ACT TIP41 RPL36Aa CYP PP2A
BestKeeper LEA26 CACS UBC TUA 40SRPS8 RPL36Aa CYP ARF ACT TIP41 F-Box PP2A
Normfinder CACS 40SRPS8 ARF TUA F-Box UBC LEA26 ACT TIP41 RPL36Aa CYP PP2A
geNorm CACS — 40SRPS8 ARF LEA26 UBC TUA ACT F-Box TIP41 RPL36Aa CYP PP2A
Recommended comprehensive ranking CACS 40SRPS8 LEA26 ARF UBC TUA F-Box ACT RPL36Aa TIP41 CYP PP2A