Table 4.
An overview of the effects of experimenter/clinician sex on pain and placebo effects.
| Study | Sex effect | Target | Finding | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Otto and Dougher (47) | No effects | Pain | – | 
| 2 | Feine et al. (48) | No effects | Pain | – | 
| 3 | Bush et al. (49) | No effects | Pain | – | 
| 4 | Thorn et al. (52) | No effects | Pain | – | 
| 5 | Essick et al. (53) | No effects | Pain | – | 
| 6 | Weimer et al. (58) | No effects | Placebo | – | 
| 7 | Levine and De Simone (19) | Interaction effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced lower pain reports in males. | 
| 8 | Gijsbers and Nicholson (54) | Interaction effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced lower pain reports in males. | 
| 9 | Aslaksen et al. (25) | Interaction effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced lower pain reports in males. | 
| 10 | Vigil et al. (62) | Interaction effect | Pain | Male experimenters induced lower pain reports in females. | 
| 11 | Aslaksen and Flaten (56) | Interaction effect | Placebo | Male experimenters induced lower pain reports in males. | 
| 12* | Kállai et al. (22) | Interaction effect | Pain | Opposite sex experimenters induced lower pain reports. (i.e., females reported higher pain tolerance to male experimenters) | 
| 12 | Kállai et al. (22) | Main effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced higher pain intensity report in both sex subjects. | 
| 13 | Vigil et al. (59) | Main effect | Pain | Male experimenters induced lower pain reports in both sex subjects. | 
| 14 | Vigil and Alcock (60) | Main effect | Pain | Female clinicians generated higher pain reports in both sex patients. | 
| 15 | Sorge et al. (61) | Main effect | Pain | Male experimenters induced lower pain expressions in mice. | 
| 16 | Carter et al. (51) | Main effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced lower pain reports in both sex subjects. | 
| 17 | Fillingim et al. (50) | Main effect | Pain | Female experimenters induced lower pain reports in both sex subjects. | 
*The study of Kállai et al. (22) has reported both interaction and main effects. Therefore, this study is considered twice.