Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 30;17(2):222–232. doi: 10.9758/cpn.2019.17.2.222

Table 3.

Psychological questionnaires scores, breathing rates, HRV indices at pre-test, post-test, and follow-up for the HRV-BF group (n=18)

Variable Time F p ηp2 Bonferroni’s post-hoc comparison

Pre-test (1) Post-test (2) Follow-up (3)
BDI-II
 Total score 24.06±13.48 13.22±10.52 16.94±15.14 12.89*** <0.001 0.43 1>2, 3
 Cognitive depression 17.06±11.84 9.17±8.21 11.83±12.16 12.85*** <0.001 0.43 1>2, 3
 Somatic depression 7.00±2.79 4.06±2.69 5.11±3.31 7.46** 0.002 0.31 1>2
BAI, total score 21.11±10.90 11.72±8.10 14.50±11.74 12.32*** <0.001 0.42 1>2, 3
PSQI
 Total score 12.28±3.50 9.78±3.69 10.39±4.18 7.45** 0.002 0.31 1>2
 Subjective sleep quality (C1) 2.00±0.77 1.39±0.70 1.78±0.81 5.55** 0.008 0.25 1>2
 Sleep latency (C2) 1.67±0.91 1.56±0.86 1.72±0.83 0.38 0.690 0.02
 Sleep duration (C3) 1.78±1.06 1.22±0.94 1.22±1.06 3.32* 0.048 0.16 1>2
 Habitual sleep efficiency (C4) 1.17±1.15 1.06±1.06 0.56±0.92 2.92 0.084 0.15
 Sleep disturbance (C5) 1.44±0.51 1.39±0.61 1.56±0.71 0.62 0.542 0.04
 Use of sleeping medications (C6) 2.17±1.20 1.78±1.26 2.00±1.37 1.25 0.299 0.07
 Daytime dysfunction (C7) 2.06±0.94 1.39±0.85 1.56±0.92 5.14* 0.011 0.23 1>2
 Total time spent asleep (min) 28.06±15.82 22.22±13.53 30.17±20.69 3.54* 0.040 0.17 NS
 Total sleep time (hr) 5.58±1.59 6.64±1.16 6.59±1.37 7.40** 0.002 0.30 2, 3>1
 Sleep efficiency (%) 71.72±15.43 79.17±12.58 86.28±14.03 13.16*** <0.001 0.44 3>1, 2
PSAS
 Total score 43.11±13.70 33.83±12.09 38.06±14.02 8.35** 0.001 0.33 1>2
 Cognition arousal 24.89±9.07 18.56±7.88 22.11±9.52 7.92** 0.002 0.32 1, 3>2
 Physical arousal 18.22±6.37 15.28±5.54 15.94±5.85 3.31* 0.049 0.16
Breathing rate (breath/min) 14.56±4.36 11.02±4.06 11.07±3.63 6.44** 0.004 0.26 1>2, 3
HRV indices
 SDNN (ms) 39.80±16.71 49.97±26.92 51.94±25.26 6.57** 0.004 0.28 2, 3>1
 LF (ms2) 158.42±233.18 583.46±932.19 676.78±1058.31 5.03* 0.012 0.23
 HF (ms2) 147.89±114.23 185.08±182.59 184.85±163.03 0.72 0.497 0.04
 ln(LF) (ms2) 4.40±1.23 5.40±1.47 5.64±1.38 10.62*** <0.001 0.38 2, 3>1
 ln(HF) (ms2) 4.55±1.22 4.59±1.28 4.75±1.10 0.33 0.724 0.02
 LF/HF ratio 1.25±1.39 6.83±11.04 5.29±6.66 2.75 0.098 0.14
 Total power (ms2) 596.80±573.68 1,052.27±1,131.51 1,098.48±1,156.35 5.18* 0.011 0.23 2>1

Values are presented as mean±standard deviation.

HRV, heart rate variability; BF, biofeedback; BDI-II, Beck Depression Inventory-II; BAI, Beck Anxiety Inventory; PSQI, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; NS, not significant; PSAS, Pre-Sleep Arousal Scale; SDNN, standard deviation of normal to normal intervals; LF, low frequency; HF, high frequency.

*

p<0.05,

**

p<0.01,

***

p<0.001.