Ratjen 2010.
Methods | RCT. Parallel design. Duration: 27 months. Multicentre (21 centres) based in Europe (Germany, France, Spain, Austria, UK, Netherlands). |
|
Participants | 123 participants with CF free of P aeruginosa (88 randomised ‐ 31 participants not randomised because of high P aeruginosa antibody titres and 4 for other reasons). Age (mean (SD)): 28‐day TIS 8.7 (7.2) years, 56‐day TIS 8.7 (10.5) years. Gender: 28‐day TIS 26 (58%) males, 19 (42%) females; 56‐day TIS 22 (51%) males, 21 (49%) females. Lung function (mean (SD) FEV1 % predicted): 28‐day TIS 80.2 (18.9), 56‐day TIS 87.0 (19.2). |
|
Interventions | Group 1 (n = 45): 28 days of tobramycin solution for inhalation (TSI) (300 mg 2x daily), then stopped treatment. Group 2 (n = 43): 28 days of tobramycin solution for inhalation (TSI) (300 mg 2x daily), then randomised to a further 28 days (56 days in total). |
|
Outcomes |
Primary outcome
Median time to recurrence of any strain of P aeruginosa. Secondary outcomes Proportion of patients free of P aeruginosa 1 month after the end of treatment Number and length of hospital admissions for respiratory indications Occurrence of other pathogens Changes in FEV₁, FVC & FEF25‐75 Weight, height and BMI. |
|
Notes | Also known as ELITE trial. | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Described as randomised, but no description of randomisation techniques given. |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Did not report how allocation was concealed. |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) All outcomes | High risk | Open‐label study, no attempt at blinding. |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | 65 participants from 88 randomised achieved primary outcome. A total of 52 participants prematurely withdrawn from trial. 27 participants withdrew from the 28‐day treatment group with the following reasons: loss to follow up (n = 1); protocol deviation (n = 4); recurrence/non‐eradication (n = 21); other (n = 1). 25 participants withdrew from the 56‐day treatment group for the following reasons: withdrawn consent (n = 1); loss to follow up (n = 2); protocol deviation (n = 2); recurrence/no eradication (n = 19); abnormal audiology test (n = 1). |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | High risk | Study reports there were no major short‐ or long‐term (3 and 27 months) changes in spirometry, but does not record the figures for either of the 2 groups. Also, only summary statements and no numerical data are provided for weight, height or BMI. |
Other bias | Unclear risk | Recruited fewer participants than planned; actually randomised 88 participants (primary outcome evaluable in 65) ‐ planned randomisation of 100 participants. Did not randomise 35 participants from the recruited cohort of 123 participants: 31 because of high P aeruginosa antibody levels, one for an adverse event, one where consent was withdrawn, one for a protocol deviation and one 'other' (unspecified) reason. Participants with raised antibody levels were not included because the investigators believed that they were chronically infected with P aeruginosa based on their antibody results. This trial was initially supported by Chiron and later Novartis Pharma, the manufacturer of TSI. |