Table 3.
Date of flight | Item | Method | Unsupervised |
Supervised |
Index based |
Physical based |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Method |
Method |
Method |
Method |
|||||||
Classes | Shadow | Non-shadow | Shadow | Non-shadow | Shadow | Non-shadow | Shadow | Non-shadow | ||
2014, August | Manually extracted | Shadow | 27,039 | 6742 | 31,292 | 2489 | 32,683 | 1098 | 29,455 | 4326 |
Non-shadow | 20,485 | 170,695 | 8433 | 182,747 | 5608 | 185,572 | 10,598 | 180,582 | ||
Total | 47,524 | 177,437 | 39,725 | 185,236 | 38,291 | 186,670 | 40,053 | 184,908 | ||
Assessment accuracy (correctness metric) | 80.6% | 93.4% | 96.7% | 87.2% | ||||||
2015, June | Manually extracted | Shadow | 19,038 | 3917 | 21,038 | 1917 | 21,393 | 1562 | 20,084 | 2871 |
Non-shadow | 2566 | 199,440 | 2109 | 199,897 | 1192 | 200,814 | 2456 | 199,550 | ||
Total | 21,604 | 203,357 | 23,147 | 201,814 | 22,585 | 202,376 | 22,540 | 202,421 | ||
Assessment accuracy (correctness metric) | 82.9% | 91.6% | 93.2% | 87.5% | ||||||
2015, July | Manually extracted | Shadow | 11,845 | 2416 | 13,030 | 1231 | 13,320 | 941 | 12,497 | 1764 |
Non-shadow | 3454 | 207,246 | 2561 | 208,139 | 1459 | 209,241 | 2964 | 207,736 | ||
Total | 15,299 | 209,662 | 15,591 | 209,370 | 14,779 | 210,182 | 15,461 | 209,500 | ||
Assessment accuracy (correctness metric) | 83.1% | 91.3% | 93.4% | 87.6% | ||||||
2016, May | Manually extracted | Shadow | 18,301 | 3459 | 19,668 | 2092 | 20,268 | 1492 | 18,796 | 2964 |
Non-shadow | 5697 | 197,504 | 3294 | 199,907 | 2314 | 200,887 | 4198 | 199,003 | ||
Total | 23,998 | 200,963 | 22,962 | 201,999 | 22,582 | 202,379 | 22,994 | 201,967 | ||
Assessment accuracy (correctness metric) | 84.1% | 90.4% | 93.1% | 86.4% |