Table 2. Primary and secondary outcomes.
Mean outcome (95% CI)a |
Crude intervention- control difference (95% CI); P valueb |
Adjusted intervention- control difference (95% CI); P valueb |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Intervention (clusters = 15) |
Control (clusters = 15) |
||||
Primary outcomes | |||||
BODE index score changec |
-1.67 (-2.18 to -1.16) |
-0.66 (-1.09 to -0.22) |
-1.01 (-1.65 to -0.37); 0.003 |
-0.96 (-1.49 to -0.44); 0.001 |
|
COPD controld | 66.88% (54.99 to 78.77) |
38.20% (22.35 to 54.06) |
28.68% (9.68 to 47.67); 0.005 |
29.03% (12.41 to 45.64); 0.001 |
|
Secondary outcome | |||||
Quit rate among smokerse |
53.90% (34.98 to 72.82) |
17.52% (7.36 to 27.69) |
36.38% (15.66 to 57.10); 0.002 |
31.98% (15.42 to 48.54); 0.001 |
|
Follow-up adherencef |
65.54% (52.64 to 78.44) |
25.17% (14.86 to 35.47) |
40.38% (24.57 to 56.18); <0.001 |
40.40% (24.15 to 56.67); <0.001 |
aArm-specific mean outcomes and their 95% confidence intervals are calculated from cluster-level mean and/or proportion summary values of outcomes. bAll intervention minus control differences (that is, intervention effect estimates) are based on crude and/or covariate-adjusted analysis of cluster-level mean and/or proportion summary values of outcomes. cBODE index score change calculated as outcome at 6-month follow-up minus outcome at baseline. dCOPD control defined as BODE index ≤ 2 at 6-month follow-up. eQuit rate among smokers calculated as smokers who had quit smoking at 6-month follow-up. fFollow-up adherence defined as attending ≥4 follow-up visits. All analyses use only complete cases.
BODE = Body mass index, airway Obstruction, Dyspnoea, Exercise capacity. CI = confidence intervals. COPD = chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.