Skip to main content
. 2017 Jun 22;2017(6):CD011947. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011947.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Abbott 1968 Ineligible outcomes
Agren 1985 Ineligible outcomes
Ahmad 2008 Ineligible intervention
Alvarez 1999 Ineligible outcomes
Alvarez 2000a Ineligible outcomes
Alvarez 2000b Ineligible outcomes
Alvarez 2002 Ineligible outcomes
Alvarez Vázquez 2014 Ineligible patient population
Aminian 1999 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Amione 2005 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Anitua 2008 Ineligible patient population
Anonymous 1982 Ineligible study design
Anonymous 2000 Ineligible study design
Anzai 1989 Ineligible patient population
Avanzi 1998a Ineligible outcomes
Avanzi 1998b Ineligible outcomes
Avanzi 2000a Ineligible outcomes
Avanzi 2000b Ineligible outcomes
Avanzi 2000c Ineligible outcomes
Avanzi 2001 Ineligible outcomes
Baade 1965 Ineligible intervention
Baatenburg de Jong 2004 Ineligible patient population
Baker 1981 Ineligible study design
Bale 1997b Ineligible outcomes
Bale 1997c Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Bale 1998a Ineligible patient population
Bale 1998b Ineligible outcomes
Bale 2004 Ineligible outcomes
Banks 1997a Ineligible outcomes
Banks 1997b Ineligible indication
Barnes 1992 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Bazzigaluppi 1991 Ineligible study design
Becker 1984 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Beele 2010 Ineligible patient population
Berard 1986 Ineligible study design
Bigolari 1991 Ineligible patient population
Bito 2012 Mixed intervention
Blanco Blanco 2002 Ineligible indication
Blum 1973 Ineligible patient population
Boxer 1969 Ineligible outcomes
Boykin 1989 Ineligible study design
Brady 1987 Ineligible study design
Brem 2000 Ineligible study design
Brett 2003 Ineligible outcomes
Brown‐Etris 1999a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Brown‐Etris 1999b Mixed intervention
Burgos 2000 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Burke 1998 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Capillas Pérez 2000 Ineligible patient population
Carusone 2001 Ineligible indication
Casali 1997 Ineligible study design
Chang 1998 Ineligible outcomes
Chen 2004 Ineligible intervention
Cheneworth 1994 Ineligible study design
Chirwa 2010 Ineligible patient population
Chuangsuwanich 2011a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Chuangsuwanich 2011b Ineligible outcomes
Chuangsuwanich 2013 Ineligible outcomes
Colin 1996a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Colin 1996b Ineligible type of healing outcome
Colonna 2004 Ineligible study design
Cooper 2008 Ineligible patient population
Coutts 2000 Ineligible outcomes
D'Aniello 1998 Ineligible outcomes
Dat 2014 Ineligible study design
Day 1995 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
De Laat 2005 Ineligible outcomes
De Laat 2011 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Dealey 1997 Ineligible outcomes
Dealey 1998 Ineligible study design
Dealey 2008 Editorial
Dierick 2004a Ineligible outcomes
Dierick 2004b Ineligible type of healing outcome
Dobrzanski 1990 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Durović 2008 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Dwivedi 2016 Ineligible type of healing outcome
El Zayat 1989 Ineligible study design
Ellis 2002 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Ellis 2003 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Engdahl 1980 Ineligible study design
Esch 1989 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Farsaei 2014 Ineligible patient population
Fear 1992 Ineligible outcomes
Feldman 2005 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Felzani 2011 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Flanagan 1995 Ineligible study design
Ford 2002 Mixed intervention
Fowler 1983 Ineligible study design
Franek 2011 Mixed intervention
Franek 2012 Mixed intervention
Franken 1999 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Fulco 2015 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Fønnebø 2008 Ineligible study design
García González 2002 Ineligible outcomes
Garrett 1969 Ineligible outcomes
Gerding 1992 Ineligible patient population
Gilligan 2014 Ineligible intervention
Goldmeier 1997 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Gostishchev 1983 Ineligible study design
Greer 1999 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Gregory 1997 Ineligible intervention
Guthrie 1989 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Hamilton Hislop 1962 Ineligible study design
Hampton 1998 Ineligible patient population
Harada 1996 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Harding 1996 Ineligible outcomes
Harding 2000 Ineligible study design
Helaly 1988 Ineligible patient population
Heuckeroth 2013 Ineligible study design
Heyer 2013 Ineligible study design
Hinz 1986 Ineligible patient population
Hirshberg 2001 Ineligible intervention
Hock 1997 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Hofman 1994 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Horch 2005 Ineligible study design
Hsu 2000 Ineligible study design
Hu 2009 Ineligible patient population
Ishibashi 1991 Ineligible patient population
Ishibashi 1996 Ineligible patient population
Janssen 1989 Ineligible patient population
Jercinovic 1994 Ineligible intervention
Johnson 1992 Mixed intervention
Kallianinen 2000 Ineligible intervention
Karap 2008 Ineligible outcomes
Kerihuel 2010 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Kerstein 2004 Ineligible study design
Kim 1996 Ineligible patient population
Kloth 2000a Mixed intervention
Kloth 2000b Ineligible study design
Kloth 2001 Mixed intervention
Kloth 2002 Mixed intervention
Knudsen 1982 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Kohr 2000 Ineligible outcomes
Kordestani 2008 Ineligible study design
Kucan 1981 Ineligible outcomes
Kuflik 2001 Ineligible patient population
Kuisma 1987 Ineligible indication
Kukita 1990 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Kurring 1994 Ineligible study design
Kurzuk‐Howard 1985 Ineligible study design
Landi 2003 Ineligible intervention
Langer 1996 Ineligible intervention
Lazareth 2012 Ineligible patient population
Lechner 1991 No results
Lee 1975 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Lee 2014 Ineligible patient population
LeVasseur 1991 Ineligible study design
Li 2016 Dressings/topical agents not the only difference between interventions (nursing care was also different)
Lin 1997 Ineligible study design
Lindsay 2011 Ineligible study design
Lingner 1984 Ineligible study design
Liu 2012 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Liu 2013 Ineligible study design
Ljungberg 1998 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Llewellyn 1996 Ineligible outcomes
Lopez‐Jimenez 2003 Ineligible outcomes
Lum 1996 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Macario 2002 Ineligible study design
Manzanero‐Lopez 2004 Protocol only and review still not published
Martin 1996 Ineligible outcomes
Meaume 1996a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Meaume 1996b Ineligible type of healing outcome
Meaume 2005 Ineligible patient population
Mian 1992 Ineligible study design
Milne 2012 Confounded ‐ selection into phase 2 of trial on basis of results
Mizuhara 2012 Mixed intervention
Mo 2015 Ineligible patient population
Moberg 1983 Mixed intervention
Mody 2008 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Moody 1991 Ineligible study design
Moody 2002 Ineligible study design
Moore 2011 Ineligible patient population
Morimoto 2015 Ineligible study design
Motta 1991 Ineligible study design
Motta 2004 Ineligible patient population
Mouës 2004 Ineligible patient population
Mouës 2007 Ineligible patient population
Mulder 1989a Ineligible patient population
Mulder 1989b Ineligible patient population
Mulder 1993a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Mulder 1993b Ineligible type of healing outcome
Mustoe 1994 Ineligible intervention
Myers 1990 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Münter 2006 Ineligible patient population
Nasar 1982 Ineligible type of healing outcome
NCT02299557 Ineligible patient population
Neill 1989b Ineligible study design
Niezgoda 2004 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Niimura 1990 Ineligible patient population
Niimura 1991 Ineligible patient population
Nixon 1998 Ineligible intervention
Ohura 2004 Mixed intervention
Olivar 1999 Ineligible intervention
Ovington 1999 Ineligible study design
Ozdemir 2011 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Panahi 2015 Ineligible patient population
Payne 2001 Ineligible intervention
Perez 2000 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Peschardt 1997 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Picard 2015 Ineligible patient population
Pierce 1994 Ineligible outcomes
Pullen 2002 Ineligible outcomes
Quelard 1985 Ineligible intervention
Ramsay 1979 Ineligible study design
Rhodes 1979 Ineligible study design
Rhodes 2001 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Roberts 1959 Ineligible indication
Robson 1992a Ineligible type of healing outcome
Robson 1992b Ineligible intervention
Robson 1992c Ineligible intervention
Robson 1994 Ineligible intervention
Romanelli 2008 Ineligible patient population
Romanelli 2009 Ineligible patient population
Rooman 1991 Ineligible patient population
Routkovsky‐Norval 1996 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Saha 2012 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Saidkhani 2016 Ineligible study design
Sayag 1996 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Saydak 1990 Ineligible study design
Scevola 2010 Ineligible outcomes
Scott 1999 Ineligible study design
Seaman 2000 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Sebern 1989 Ineligible outcomes
Serra 2005 Ineligible study design
Settel 1969 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Shamimi Nouri 2008 Ineligible outcomes
Shannon 1988 Ineligible study design
Sherman 2000 Ineligible study design
Shirakawa 2005 Ineligible study design
Shojaei 2008 Ineligible outcomes
Shrivastava 2011 Ineligible patient population
Sibbald 2011 Ineligible patient population
Small 2002 Mixed intervention
Smietanka 1981 Ineligible study design
Souliotis 2016 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Stepan 2014 Ineligible study design
Stephen 2016 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Stoker 1990 Ineligible study design
Strong 1985 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Subbanna 2007 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Takahashi 2006 Ineligible study design
Teot 2008 Ineligible outcomes
Teot 1997 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Tewes 1993 Ineligible study design
Thomas 1993 Ineligible outcomes
Thomas 1997b Ineligible outcomes
Toba 1997 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Tolentino 2011 Ineligible study design
Toriyabe 2004 Ineligible study design
Torra i Bou 1999 Ineligible outcomes
Trial 2010 Ineligible outcomes
Tricco 2015 Ineligible study design
Unglaub 2004 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Valentini 2015 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Van Leen 2004 Ineligible study design
Varma 1973 Ineligible outcomes
Vernassiere 2005 Ineligible patient population
Wagstaff 2014 Comparison of two interventions in the same class
Wallace 2009 Ineligible study design
Wang 2014 Ineligible intervention
Wanner 2003 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Watts 1994 Ineligible outcomes
Waycaster 2011 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Waycaster 2013 Confounded ‐ selection into phase 2 of trial on basis of results
Weheida 1991 Ineligible patient population
Weststrate 1999 Ineligible study design
Whitney 1999 Mixed intervention
Whitney 2001 Mixed intervention
Wild 2009 Ineligible outcomes
Wild 2012 Ineligible outcomes
Winter 1990 Ineligible patient population
Woo 2009 Ineligible outcomes
Worsley 1991 Ineligible patient population
Yastrub 2004 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Yastrub 2005 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Young 1973 Ineligible study design
Young 1997 Ineligible type of healing outcome
Yura 1984 Ineligible patient population
Zhou 2001 Ineligible intervention
Zuloff‐Shani 2010 Ineligible study design