Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2019 Apr 24.
Published in final edited form as: Acad Radiol. 2017 Mar 2;24(7):876–890. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2016.12.017

Table 1.

Reference standard criteria for target lesions for each diagnostic task in this study

Cohort of cases Reference Standard
Hepatic Metastasis Detection of Indeterminate Pulmonary Nodules Cause of potential acute neurologic deficit
Positive cases For each case
  • proven malignancy

  • at least one hepatic lesion that meets criteria below

For each lesion
  • hepatic metastasis by histopathology (surgical extirpation or biopsy)

  • progression (increase in size) over serial cross-sectional exams

  • regression (decrease in size) over serial cross-sectional exams while on medical treatment

Two chest radiologists, not participating as readers in this study, independently evaluate routine dose CT images, unblinded to prior and subsequent exams
  • Both chest radiologists circumscribe every indeterminate nodule 5–15 mm in size

  • Nodules circled by both radiologists are reference nodules

Head CT findings visible in retrospect by diagnostic task leader, and (one of the following)…
  • Neurologist or attending physician or neurosurgical note indicating clinical findings that correspond to CT findings, or

  • Subsequent confirmation on MRI, or

  • Subsequent progression on serial CT exams, or

  • Confirmation of CT findings at neurosurgery and/or histology

Negative cases
without other
findings
  • Agreement between individual assessment by 2 GI radiologists that no liver lesions are present

  • A subsequent CT or MRI performed ≥ 6 months later also showing absence of liver lesions

Two non-reader chest radiologists verify absence of indeterminate pulmonary nodules comparing to prior and subsequent CT exams 2 non-reader neuro-radiologists to agree on absence of CT findings on routine dose images that would indicate acute neurologic deficit, as well as corresponding neurological assessment prior to discharge
Negative cases
with benign
findings
Characteristic imaging features 19 plus stability on separate CT or MR exam performed ≥ 5 months from index CT Not applicable
(granulomas are not marked or tracked)
Leukoaraiosis was confirmed and noted when present on subsequent MRI exam