Intervention |
Comparison |
For people with |
Relevant excluded study |
Relevant existing Cochrane Reviews |
Music medicine (music listening alone, without a music therapist) |
Standard care |
Schizophrenia |
Chambliss 1996; Glicksohn 2000; Haimov 2012; Kong 2007; Li 2011; Lin 2003; Margo 1981; Muller 2014; Ni 2002; Vadas 2012; Wang 2002a; Wang 2002b; Zhang 2010; Zhang 2013; Zhou 2003; Zhou 2006; Zhu 2002
|
‐‐ |
Other music interventions |
Hannes 1974; Hu 2004; Leung 1998; Li 2005; Tang 2002; Wang 2006a; Wang 2007; Zhang 2003a; Zhang 2005; Zincir 2011
|
‐‐ |
Other creative arts therapies (art therapy, dance/movement therapy) |
Standard care or other therapy |
Apter 1978; Green 1987; Krajewski 1993; Su 1999
|
Ren 2013; Ruddy 2005; Ruddy 2007
|
Treatment packages including music interventions |
Barrowclough 2001; Gaszner 2009; Ji 2013; Su 2005; Tan 2009; Xiao 2005; Yang 2005
|
‐‐ |
Music therapy |
Other interventions |
Valencia 2006; Zhang 2003b
|
‐‐ |
Olanzapine |
Placebo |
Arango 2003 |
Duggan 2005 |
Ondansetron |
Placebo |
Adler 2005 |
‐‐ |
Cognitive behaviour therapy/behaviour therapy |
Standard care or other therapy |
Bechdolf 2005; Drury 1996; Krajewski 1993
|
Jones 2012 |
Family therapy |
Standard care |
Hogarty 1988 |
Pharoah 2010; Okpokoro 2014
|
Music therapy |
Standard care or other therapy |
People in mental health care |
Silverman 2011a; Silverman 2011b; Silverman 2011c
|
‐‐ |