Table 1.
Study | Country | Method/Approach | Assumed Shadow Wage Rate | Average Economic Cost of CHVs’ Unpaid Time (Nominal Prices) | Year of Prices |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
[25] | Ghana | Opportunity cost | Agricultural wage (equivalent to the minimum wage in the study setting) | US$0.046 per treatment | 2011 |
[48] | Nigeria | Opportunity cost | Minimum wage | US$0.125 per treatment | 1998 |
[26] | Cameroon, Nigeria, Uganda | Opportunity cost | GNI | Overall average: US$0.16 per treatment ○ Nigeria: US$0.13 per treatment ○ Uganda: US$0.16 per treatment ○ Cameroon: US$0.35 per treatment |
2003 |
[39] | Niger | Opportunity cost | Agricultural wage | US$0.05–0.07 per treatment | 2005 |
[24] | Uganda | Opportunity cost | Laborer wage, minimum wage, GNI. | The average cost per CHV for one delivery round: ○ Laborer wage: US$28.06 ○ Minimum wage: US$20.25 ○ GNI: US$38.58 Assuming 70% treatment coverage this would correspond to: ○ Laborer wage: US$0.08 per treatment ○ Minimum wage: US$0.06 per treatment ○ GNI: US$0.11 per treatment |
2010 |
[3] | Cameroon, Nigeria, Uganda | Opportunity cost | Minimum wage | US$44 per community treated. Assuming an average community size of 884 peoplea and a 70% treatment coverage, would correspond to an average of US$0.071 per treatment. The total cost per community was observed to vary substantially across the different study sites. |
2005 |
[49] | Niger | Opportunity cost | Agricultural wage | The data pertaining to CHVs alone was not shown. | - |
[50] | The Philippines | Replacement cost | The average allowance typically provided to volunteer health workers | The data pertaining to CHVs alone was not shown. | - |
Abbreviations: CHV, community health volunteers; GNI, gross national income.
a Based on Kim et al. [28]. Nominal prices: The values have not been adjusted for inflation.