Table 1.
Trial | Type of hepatic encephalopathy | Neuropsychiatric assessment | Definition of overall improvement |
Amodio 1997 | Minimal | Number Connection Test and Brainstem Auditory Evoked Response. | Investigators did not define or assess the number of participants with an overall improvement. |
Barbaro 1998 | Overt | Mental status assessed using a clinical scale (Table 4), Modified Glasgow Coma Scale (Table 4), and electroencephalography (Table 5). | Improvement in clinical scores or electroencephalography. |
Cadranel 1995 | Overt | Mental status assessed using a clinical scale (Table 4), and electroencephalography (Table 5). | Improvement in clinical score or electroencephalography. |
Dursun 2003 | Minimal or overt | Mental status assessed using a clinical scale (Table 4), Number Connection Test results, and electroencephalography (Table 5). | Improvement based on the clinical score and Number Connection Test results. |
Giger‐Mateeva 1999 | Minimal | Number Connection Test and brainstem auditory evoked response. | Not defined. The investigators included a post‐hoc subjective assessment of alertness. |
Gooday 1995 | Minimal | Simple and complex reaction time, verbal memory, psychomotor speed, short‐term and working memory. | Improvement in psychomotor speed evaluated using change in reaction time; Investigators did not define or assess the number of participants with overall improvement. . |
Gyr 1996 | Overt | Mental status (Table 4), and electroencephalography (Table 5). | Clinically relevant improvement defined as a 2‐point improvement in clinical score at any time during treatment compared with baseline. The investigators also reported improvement defined using the clinical scale score (mean for all individual observations). |
Hermant 1991 | Overt | Glasgow Coma Scale (Table 4), and electroencephalography. | A 2‐point improvement in the Glasgow Coma Score and electroencephalography. |
Klotz 1989 | Overt | Clinical assessment (score not described). | Improvement in clinical status |
Lacetti 2000 | Overt | Mental status (scale not specified) and Glasgow Coma Scale (Table 4). | Investigators originally classified participants as Grade III to IV coma. Method of assessment not stipulated. The trial report defined 'clinically relevant improvement' as primary outcome defined as a 3‐point improvement in Glasgow Coma Score. |
Li 2009 | Overt | Glasgow Coma Scale (Table 4), and electroencephalography | Improvement in the Glasgow Coma Score of ≥ 3 points. |
Pomier‐Layrargues 1994 | Overt | Modified Glasgow Coma Score (Table 4), and electroencephalography. | Improvement in ≥ 2 items on modified Glasgow Coma Score within 1 hour after the end of treatment. |
Van der Rijt 1995 | Overt | Clinical scale (Table 4). | A ≥ 1 ‐point decrease in severity of hepatic encephalopathy. |
Zhu 1998 | Overt | Clinical scale (Table 4). | Overall improvement in hepatic encephalopathy based on clinical grade. |
RCT: randomised clinical trial.