Skip to main content
. 2002 Apr 22;2002(2):CD002068. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002068

Ernst 1997.

Methods 2 active arms, 1 placebo control
 Crossover study: washout period: 2 weeks
Pain measurement tool: 15 cm VAS, 
 patient reported
Analgesic scale: morphine equivalent for amount consumed in 24 hours
Participants Any primary
Bone metastases required
Pain required
Co‐intervention: systemic therapy as part of standard practice
Performance status criteria: no specifications
Other criteria: exclude radiotherapy, chemotherapy within 4 weeks, cardiac failure, and renal failure.
Interventions 1. Active arm 1:
 Clodronate
 Intravenous
 600mg
 x1 dose
2. Active arm 2:
 Clodronate
 Intravenous
 1500 mg
 x1 dose
3. Control arm:
 Placebo
Crossover after 2 weeks
 Patients on chemotherapy or hormonal therapy as part of standard care
60 pts
Outcomes 1. Pain:
 a. Mean change in pain score
2. Analgesic: 
 a. Mean change in morphine equivalent
Others:
 a. Patient preference
 26/60 preferred pamidronate
 12/60 preferred placebo
 8/60 no preference
No adverse effects reported
Withdrawals: 
 9 pts
Notes QS = 4