Skip to main content
. 2017 Jul 12;2017(7):CD011821. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011821.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Afilalo 1992 Ineligible intervention: antiseptic combined with SSD
Ang 2002 Ineligible intervention: chlorhexidine rinse followed by SSD treatment
Ang 2003 Ineligible intervention: chlorhexidine cleansing then SSD treatment for deeper burns
Babb 1977 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Bowser 1981 Ineligiblestudy design: quasi‐randomised trial
Brown 2016 Antiseptic agent did not differ between groups
Cason 1966 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Chen 2007 Ineligible study design: study designed only to test moisture‐absorption properties of dressings over short time period
Chmyrev 2011 Ineligible population ‐ post‐surgical burn wounds
Chokotho 2005 Ineligible intervention ‐ comparison of non‐antiseptic with a mixture of antiseptic and non‐antiseptic agents
Choudhary 2013 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Colombo 1993 Ineligible population: minority burns patients
Daryabeigi 2010 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Fisher 1968 Ineligible was not the only systematic difference between the groups: other agents included in sprays
Gee Kee 2015 Ineligible agent did not differ between groups
Helvig 1979 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Kumar 2004 Ineligible intervention: combination of SSD and chlorhexidine
Madhusudhan 2015 Ineligiblepopulation ‐ residual burns were a minority of participants
Mohammadi 2013 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial
Palombo 2011 Ineligible population (post‐surgery burns)
Shoma 2010 Ineligible intervention: additional treatments given in both comparison groups
Subrahmanyam 1993a Ineligible population: burn wounds a minority of included participants
Subrahmanyam 1999 Antiseptic was not only systematic difference between groups
Tredget 1998 Antiseptic agent did not differ between groups
Vehmeyer‐Heeman 2005 Wrong population: post‐surgical burn wounds
Verbelen 2014 Antiseptic agent did not differ between groups
Weng 2009 Antiseptic was not only systematic difference between groups
Xu 2009 Ineligible study design: agents under investigation only used for short period to assess blood and urine levels
Zhu 2006 Ineligible study design: quasi‐randomised trial

RCT: randomised controlled trial; SSD: silver sulfadiazine