Skip to main content
. 2017 Aug 10;2017(8):CD002798. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002798.pub4

5. Baseline screening for benzodiazepines in trial participants.

Trial Required period free of benzodiazepines before inclusion Baseline screening for benzodiazepines Screening method and detection level Negative testing at baseline an inclusion criterion Proportion testing positive for benzodiazepines at baseline
Amodio 1997 2 weeks Yes
  • Blood

  • Emit‐dau technique, Dupont

  • Detection limit 0.3 μg/mL diazepam

No 0%
Barbaro 1998 4 days Yes
  • Blood

  • Thin‐layer chromatography:

  • Detection limit > 11 mg/L

No 1.9%
Cadranel 1995 Not reported Yes
  • Blood and urine

  • Thin‐layer chromatography:

  • Detection limit > 11 mg/L

No 21.4%
Dursun 2003 3 days No Not reported Not reported Not reported
Giger‐Mateeva 1999 3 months Yes
  • Urine

  • Abbott TDx/TDxFLx immunoassay

  • Detection limit < 200 ng/mL

No 0%
Gooday 1995 1 month No Not reported Not reported Not reported
Gyr 1996 Yes, but length not specified Yes
  • Blood and urine

  • Abbott TDx immunoassay

  • Detection limits: blood 10 ng/mL 100 ng/mL, urine < 200 ng/mL


Post‐hoc analysis
  • High‐pressure liquid chromatography

  • Detection limits: blood < 50 ng/mL, urine 10 ng/mL to 100 ng/mL

No 8.2% on screening tests
Flumazenil 11%; placebo 5%
12/49 samples for more sensitive testing lost
Hermant 1991 Not reported Yes Not reported Yes 0%
Klotz 1989 Not reported No Not reported Not reported Not reported
Lacetti 2000 2 weeks Yes
  • Urine

  • Roche KIMS immuno‐enzymatic assay

  • Detection limit: not specified


Post‐hoc analysis
  • High‐pressure liquid chromatography

  • Detection limit: not specified

Yes 0%
Li 2009 Not reported No Not reported N/A N/A
Pomier‐Layrargues 1994 3 days Yes
  • Blood

  • Abbott TDx immunoassay

  • Detection limit 12 ng/mL


Post‐hoc analysis
  • Gas chromatography‐mass spectroscopy

  • Detection limit: 1 ng/mL

No 19%
Van der Rijt 1995 Recent Yes
  • Blood

  • High‐pressure liquid chromatography

  • Detection limit: not specified

Yes 0%
Zhu 1998 7 days No Not reported Not reported Not reported