Skip to main content
. 2008 Apr 16;2008(2):CD005536. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005536.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Becker 1985 Not acute asthma.
Carson 1985 Study comparison was a home‐made spacer vs. oxygen‐driven nebulizer, no commercial spacer involved.
Duarte 2002 Study comparison was a home‐made spacer vs. oxygen‐driven nebulizer, no commercial spacer involved.
El‐Kassimi 1987 Study included adult patients
Fowler 2001 Study included adult patients, and did not include outcomes of interest.
Henry 1983 Study comparison was salbutamol versus placebo via a home‐made spacer, no commercial spacer involved.
Kerac 1998 Not acute asthma
Kissoon 2001 No outcomes of interest in this study.
Lipworth 2002 Not a randomised controlled trial, not acute asthma, and absence of outcomes of interest.
Mazur 2000a Not a randomised controlled trial, but a review and commentary of a previous published paper.
Mazur 2000b Same study as Zar 1999.
Mazur 2000c Same study as Zar 1999.
Motala 2000 Review article.
Obgaidze 2005 Non‐randomized trial
Quetulio 2004 Probably some patients included in Quetulio 2002, no outcomes presented in this abstract in a usable form, and no response from authors to request for clarification.
Rajkumar 2002 Not acute asthma.
Samaranayake 1998 Mixed population of patients (pediatric and adult participants), not possible to separate data from pediatric patients and no response from authors.
Schleufe 1998 Not a randomised controlled trial, design more suitable to before and after study. Not acute asthma. Probably adult patients, no response from authors to request for clarification.
Teo 1988 Study comparison was salbutamol versus placebo via a home‐made spacer, no commercial spacer involved.
Vichyanond 1992 Not acute asthma.
Willemse 2003 Study included adult patients. Not acute asthma.
Zar 1998a Absence of outcomes of interest.
Zar 1998b Absence of outcomes of interest.
Zar 2002a Review article.
Zar 2002b Review article.

vs: versus