Skip to main content
. 2017 Oct 4;2017(10):CD003942. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003942.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Al‐Arifi 2014 Irrelevant intervention
Alassaad 2014 Not primary care
Alicic 2016 Protocol of a study
Barker 2012 This study does not appear to be a primary care intervention.
Barker 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Barnes 2014 Outcomes not relevant
Basheti 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Bell 2016 Not primary care
Benard‐Laribiere 2015 Irrelevant intervention
Bhatt 2014 Study protocol
Billington 2015 Outcomes not relevant
Bonnet‐Zamponi 2013 This was not a primary care intervention; it was done by geriatricians.
Briggs 2015 Not primary care
Carrington 2013 Irrelevant intervention
Clyne 2013 Outcomes not relevant
Clyne 2015 Outcomes not relevant
Clyne 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Cowper 1998 Cost‐effectiveness study that had data in a form not enabling data extraction.
Desveaux 2016 Study protocol
Dhalla 2014 Outcomes not relevant
Elliott 2014 Study protocol
Forster 2015 Study protocol
Fredericks 2013 Irrelevant intervention
Furniss 2000 Study was for a pre‐post design not included in the protocol
Geurts 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Gorgas 2012 This study did not occur in primary care.
Graffen 2004 Study was for a pre‐post design not included in the protocol
Guthrie 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Hallsworth 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Hanlon 1996 This study did not occur in primary care.
Hugtenburg 2009 This is not a randomised trial (it is described as a controlled intervention study and there is no evidence of randomisation).
Huiskes 2014 Outcomes not relevant
Keane 2014 Not primary care
Knowlton 1994 Not possible to extract appropriate data
Lee 1996 This study was not a randomised trial.
Leendertse 2011 This study was not a randomised trial.
Leendertse 2013 This study was not a randomised trial.
Liu 2010 This study was a conference abstract only and did not address adverse drug reactions.
Malin 2016 Outcomes not relevant
Mills 2001 This study is reported elsewhere (see Furniss 2000, also excluded)
Montero‐Balosa 2016 Not a randomised trial
Moreno 2016 Not a randomised trial
Naunton 2003 This is a hospital intervention and not done in primary care. It appears that the study pharmacist is recruited from the hospital. As it says, the pharmacist complied with the Society of Hospital Pharmacist clinical pharmacy services. It is also published in a hospital journal.
Neven 2016 Not primary care
Ni 2016 Not a randomised trial
Perula 2014 Outcomes not relevant
Phung 2013 Study protocol
Pinnock 2013 Irrelevant intervention
Przytula 2015 Study protocol
Safran 1993 This study was not a randomised trial
Saltzberg 2011 This study was not a randomised trial
Setter 2009 The outcomes reported are not appropriate for this study
Sinnott 2015 Outcomes not relevant
Stingl 2016 Study protocol
Sturgess 2003 Reported elsewhere (see Bernsten 2001)
Wolf 2015 Outcomes not relevant
Wooster 2016 Study protocol
Xin 2014 Not primary care
Yuan 2003 Complex study, which made data extraction not possible.