NDHS Faribault 1968.
Methods | RCT | |
Participants | Men living in a mental health institute (USA) CVD risk: low Control: randomised 57, analysed 52 Interventions B, C, E combined: randomised 167, analysed 143 Mean years in trial: control 1.0, Interventions 0.9 % male: 100 Age: unclear (all 45‐54) |
|
Interventions | Modified fat vs. usual diet
Control aims: total fat 40%E, SFA 16‐18%E, dietary chol 650‐750mg/d, P/S 0.4
Intervention aims: B (C, E) total fat 30%E (40%E, 40%E), SFA <9%E (<9%E, not stated), dietary chol 350‐450mg/d (350‐450mg/d, not stated), PUFA 15%E (18‐20%E, not stated), P/S 1.5 (2.0, 4.4) Control methods: whole diet provided Intervention methods: whole diet provided Total fat intake (at 28 & 44 weeks combined): B (C, E) mod fat 29.2 (38.5, 37.1) (sds unclear)%E, cont 39.4 (sd unclear)%E Saturated fat intake (at 28 & 44 weeks combined): B (C, E) mod fat 6.6 (7.4, 4.9) (sds unclear)%E, cont 15.6 (sd unclear)%E Style: diet provided Setting: residential institution |
|
Outcomes | Stated trial outcomes: lipid levels and dietary assessment
Data available on total mortality? yes
Cardiovascular mortality? no
Events available for combined cardiovascular events: none Secondary outcomes: no cancer deaths or diagnoses occurred Tertiary outcomes: total cholesterol |
|
Notes | ||
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | Stratified randomisation by the statistical centre |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Low risk | |
Blinding (performance bias and detection bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Double blind, facilitated by provision of the whole diet |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Institution so able to follow up all participants through study. |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | Not relevant for primary and secondary outcomes as all trialists asked for data |
Other bias | Low risk | |
Free of systematic difference in care? | Low risk | Whole diet provided for both groups. See Control and Intervention Methods in Interventions section of the Table of Characteristics of Included Studies |
Free of dietary differences other than fat? | Low risk | See Control and Intervention Aims in Interventions section of the Table of Characteristics of Included Studies |