Skip to main content
. 2017 Nov 6;2017(11):CD008727. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008727.pub4

2. 'Risk of bias' assessment criteria for randomised controlled trials.

Selection bias
Sequence generation (adequate: yes/no):
  • if the rule for allocating interventions to participants was based on some chance (random) process.


Allocation concealment (adequate: yes/no):
  • if the randomisation method did not allow investigator and child to know or influence allocation of treatment before eligible children entered the study.

Performance bias 
 Blinding of care providers (yes/no):
  • if knowledge of the allocated intervention was adequately prevented during the study.


Blinding of participants (yes/no):
  • if knowledge of the allocated intervention was adequately prevented during the study.

Detection bias 
 Blinding of outcome assessors (yes/no; assessed for each outcome separately):
  • if knowledge of the allocated intervention was adequately prevented during the study.

Attrition bias 
 Incomplete outcome data (adequate: yes/no; assessed for each outcome separately):
  • if incomplete outcome (attrition and exclusions) data have been adequately addressed.

Reporting bias 
 Selective outcome reporting (yes/no):
  • if reports of the study were free of the suggestion of selective outcome reporting.

Other bias 
 Other bias (yes/no):
  • if the study was free of other problems (i.e. potential source of bias related to specific study design, premature termination of the study due to some data‐dependent process, extreme baseline imbalance) that could put it at high risk of bias.